Model Generation with Provable Coverability for Offline Reinforcement Learning

Zongzhang ZhangarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of offline reinforcement learning (RL) where agents learn from pre-collected data without further interaction. They introduce "Provable Coverability Model Generation" (PoCo), a novel method that generates a diverse set of dynamics models with guaranteed "coverability" – meaning they can collectively approximate the real-world dynamics. This allows for better out-of-distribution generalization and improved policy performance compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Standard reinforcement learning algorithms struggle in offline settings because they cannot explore to correct errors in their learned models. This leads to "extrapolation errors," where the agent makes poor decisions when encountering states or dynamics not well-represented in the training data. While model-based RL aims to overcome this by learning a dynamics model of the environment, existing methods often fail to accurately capture the real dynamics from limited offline data. Previous approaches like ensembling models are inefficient and lack guarantees on how well they cover the true dynamics. This paper addresses this "model inaccuracy" problem by proposing a principled way to generate a set of models that are provably good at covering the real dynamics, enabling better generalization and exploration.

Methods

The core of PoCo involves two main stages:

  1. Probing Policy Set Learning: To measure how well a set of learned models covers the real dynamics, the authors first learn a diverse set of "probing policies." These policies are designed to explore different aspects of the state-action space, and their interactions with the learned models are used as a metric for "Maximum Occupancy Distance" (MOD). This helps quantify the difference between dynamics models.
  2. Goal-Oriented Model Generation: Instead of simply training models on offline data (supervised learning), PoCo generates models in a "goal-oriented" manner. This involves:
  3. Target Representation Sampling: Creating target representations that are diverse and likely to cover the real dynamics. This is achieved by sampling from a latent space derived from the probing policies.
  4. Model Matching: Training candidate models to not only accurately predict the next state and reward (supervised loss) but also to match these target representations (auxiliary loss). This ensures the generated models are both accurate on the training data and diverse enough to cover unseen dynamics.

The paper also introduces a "dynamics-aware policy optimization" stage, where a contextual policy is trained using the generated set of models. This policy can adapt to different dynamics within the generated set, leading to better generalization.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on the D4RL (Datasets for Deep Reinforcement Learning) benchmark, specifically using the MuJoCo simulator environments (Walker2d, HalfCheetah, Hopper) with different dataset types (random, medium, medium-replay, medium-expert). No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Model Coverability" is Crucial: The paper formalizes the concept of "model coverability" – the ability of a set of learned dynamics models to approximate the real environment's dynamics. This is presented as a key bottleneck in offline model-based RL.
  • Beyond Supervised Learning for Models: Simply training models to minimize prediction error on offline data is insufficient. PoCo's "goal-oriented" generation, which explicitly optimizes for coverability through target representations, is shown to be more effective.
  • Probing Policies as a Metric: Using a set of diverse probing policies is an effective way to measure and guide the coverability of learned dynamics models.
  • Provable Guarantees: The theoretical analysis provides bounds on the performance gap between the learned policy and the optimal policy, directly linking model coverability to policy performance.
  • Out-of-Distribution Exploration: The generated diverse models enable policies to explore beyond the training data manifold, leading to better generalization and zero-shot transfer performance.

Key Results

  • Superior Performance on D4RL: PoCo achieved state-of-the-art or competitive performance on over half of the D4RL benchmark tasks, particularly excelling in environments where dynamics are challenging to model (e.g., Walker2d, HalfCheetah).
  • Outperforming Model-Free Methods: PoCo demonstrated dominating performance compared to model-free offline RL algorithms on most tasks.
  • Effective Out-of-Distribution Exploration: Visualizations (t-SNE plots) showed that policies trained with PoCo generated data distributions distinct from the offline data, indicating successful exploration beyond the training data manifold.
  • Reduced Conservative Penalties: Policies trained with PoCo required significantly lower or no conservative penalties, a common technique in offline RL that can hinder exploration.
  • Zero-Shot Transfer: PoCo policies showed better zero-shot transfer performance on changed environment dynamics, highlighting their improved generalization capabilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hyperparameter Sensitivity: While the paper analyzes the impact of hyperparameters like probing policy set size and noise amplitude, finding optimal values might still require tuning.
  • Tabular Case for Proofs: Theoretical proofs were presented for the tabular case, which might not directly translate to complex continuous state-action spaces without further analysis.
  • End-to-End Provable Generation: The authors express interest in developing a fully end-to-end model generation method with provable coverability.
  • Rethinking Design Choices: Future work could involve reviewing and refining design choices such as the uncertainty metric and policy rollout horizon.

Summary updated

Abstract

Model-based offline optimization with dynamics-aware policy provides a new perspective for policy learning and out-of-distribution generalization, where the learned policy could adapt to different dynamics enumerated at the training stage. But due to the limitation under the offline setting, the learned model could not mimic real dynamics well enough to support reliable out-of-distribution exploration, which still hinders policy to generalize well. To narrow the gap, previous works roughly ensemble randomly initialized models to better approximate the real dynamics. However, such practice is costly and inefficient, and provides no guarantee on how well the real dynamics could be approximated by the learned models, which we name coverability in this paper. We actively address this issue by generating models with provable ability to cover real dynamics in an efficient and controllable way. To that end, we design a distance metric for dynamic models based on the occupancy of policies under the dynamics, and propose an algorithm to generate models optimizing their coverage for the real dynamics. We give a theoretical analysis on the model generation process and proves that our algorithm could provide enhanced coverability. As a downstream task, we train a dynamics-aware policy with minor or no conservative penalty, and experiments demonstrate that our algorithm outperforms prior offline methods on existing offline RL benchmarks. We also discover that policies learned by our method have better zero-shot transfer performance, implying their better generalization.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2022model,
  author = {Zongzhang Zhang},
  title = {{Model Generation with Provable Coverability for Offline Reinforcement Learning}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.00316},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.00316},
}
Figure