Model-based optimized steering and focusing of local magnetic particle concentrations for targeted drug delivery

Rikkert Van Durme, Guillaume Crevecoeur, Luc Dupré, Annelies CoeneDrug 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel model-based optimal control framework for magnetic drug targeting (MDT). By combining a detailed physical model of particle dynamics with advanced computational techniques like model order reduction and direct multiple shooting, the authors demonstrate precise and flexible steering of magnetic nanoparticles towards target locations, even in the presence of fluid flow. This work brings MDT closer to clinical application by offering a more accurate and efficient targeting strategy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Targeted drug delivery aims to deliver therapeutic agents specifically to diseased areas in the body, minimizing side effects and improving efficacy. Magnetic drug targeting (MDT) is a promising approach that uses magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) as carriers, manipulated by external magnetic fields. However, a significant challenge in MDT is achieving precise and controlled steering of these particles, especially deep within tissues and in dynamic environments like blood flow. Existing methods often struggle with accuracy, flexibility, and computational feasibility, hindering clinical translation. This paper addresses the need for a more robust and computationally efficient control strategy for MDT that can handle complex scenarios and optimize particle concentration at target sites.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a model-based optimal control approach. The authors developed a dynamical model that integrates magnetic forces, hydrodynamic drag, and advection-diffusion dynamics of MNPs. This model is then discretized into a state-space representation, where each "voxel" (a grid element representing a small volume) holds a particle concentration.

To tackle the computational complexity of optimizing this system, two key techniques are employed:

  • Model Order Reduction (MOR): This technique reduces the dimensionality of the dynamical model by identifying dominant modes of particle behavior. This significantly decreases the number of variables the optimization algorithm needs to handle, making computations feasible.
  • Direct Multiple Shooting (DMS): This is a powerful numerical method for solving optimal control problems. It breaks down the problem into smaller segments and iteratively refines the control inputs (electromagnet currents) to minimize a cost function, in this case, maximizing particle concentration at the target voxel.

The authors also highlight the compatibility of their voxel-based model with state-of-the-art magnetic particle imaging (MPI) modalities, suggesting a pathway for integrated theranostic platforms.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention or use external datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies on simulations of an in-vitro targeting setup. This setup involves:

  • A 2-D square sample (8 cm x 8 cm) representing the target area.
  • Four electromagnets modeled as infinitely-thin circular wires.
  • Biocompatible magnetite nanoparticles (Fe3O4 core, 400 nm diameter, saturation magnetization Ms = 4.78 × 10⁵ A/m).
  • A uniform fluid medium with properties mimicking blood viscosity.
  • Simulated fluid flow profiles (stationary and moving).

The "dataset" for evaluation is generated through these simulations, where the algorithm's performance is assessed based on the achieved particle concentration at target voxels under various conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Voxel-based modeling for MDT: Representing particle concentration in discrete voxels aligns well with imaging techniques, creating a bridge between diagnostics and therapy.
  • MOR + DMS synergy: The combination of model order reduction and direct multiple shooting is crucial for making complex optimal control problems computationally tractable for MDT.
  • Optimizing for concentration, not just trajectory: Unlike some previous methods that focused on following a predefined path, this approach directly optimizes for maximizing particle concentration at the target, offering greater flexibility.
  • Handling non-stationary fluids: The framework demonstrates the ability to steer particles effectively even in the presence of fluid flow, a critical factor for in-vivo applications.
  • Theranostic potential: The model's compatibility with imaging opens doors for integrated systems that can both deliver therapy and monitor its progress in real-time.

Key Results

The simulation results demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method:

  • Successful targeting: Particle ensembles were successfully guided towards predefined target voxels, achieving significantly improved concentrations compared to an initial guess.
  • Dispersion reduction: The method achieved targeting with limited dispersion of particles through the surrounding liquid.
  • Flexibility: The algorithm showed flexibility in handling different target voxel locations, cost functions, and fluid velocities.
  • Performance in fluid flow: The control strategy was effective in maintaining particle focus against a uniform fluid velocity of 3 µm/s, preventing them from being washed away.
  • Computational feasibility: While full-order simulations can be computationally intensive, the use of MOR reduced computation times significantly. For instance, a 31x31 voxel grid with 4 time steps and l=6 reduced states took approximately 23 minutes for one optimization sequence.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Feedforward control: The current strategy uses feedforward control, meaning it relies on a model and does not incorporate real-time feedback from measurements during motion. This makes it susceptible to modeling errors.
  • In-vitro validation: The presented results are based on simulations. Experimental validation in a lab setup is necessary to verify and refine the algorithm.
  • Model complexity: Future work should incorporate more sophisticated models that account for in-vivo vasculature systems, intervening blood flow forces, and potential particle chaining/agglomeration.
  • 3D targeting: The current work focuses on 2D scenarios. Extending the methodology to 3D targeting would be a significant advancement.
  • Real-time integration: Integrating targeting with imaging sequences for real-time feedback and adaptive control is a key future goal.
  • Hardware limitations: The computational time can still be a bottleneck, suggesting the need for better hardware or further optimization of the algorithms.
  • Targeting time vs. feasibility: In some cases, the predefined time interval might not be sufficient to reach the target, highlighting the need to consider physical limitations and potentially adjust target goals or timeframes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Magnetic drug targeting (MDT) is an application in the field of targeted drug delivery in which magnetic (nano)particles act as drug carriers. The particles can be steered toward specific regions in the human body by adapting the currents of external (electro)magnets. Accurate models of particle movement and control algorithms for the electromagnet currents are two of the many requirements to ensure effective drug targeting. In this work, a control approach for the currents is presented, based on an underlying physical model that describes the dynamics of particles in a liquid in terms of their concentration in each point in space. Using this model, the control algorithm determines the currents generating the magnetic fields that maximize the particle concentration in spots of interest over a period of time. Such an approach is computationally only feasible thanks to our innovative combination of model order reduction with the method of direct multiple shooting. Simulation results of an in-vitro targeting setup demonstrated that a particle collection can be successfully guided toward the targeted spot with limited dispersion through a surrounding liquid. As now present and future particle behavior can be taken into account, and non-stationary surrounding liquids can be dealt with, a more precise and flexible targeting is achieved compared to existing MDT methods. This proves that the presented methodology can bring MDT closer to its clinical application. Moreover, the developed model is compatible with state-of-the-art imaging methods, paving the way for theranostic platforms that combine both therapy as well as diagnostics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{durme2020model,
  author = {Rikkert Van Durme and Guillaume Crevecoeur and Luc Dupré and Annelies Coene},
  title = {{Model-based optimized steering and focusing of local magnetic particle concentrations for targeted drug delivery}},
  booktitle = {Drug},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1080/10717544.2020.1853281},
}
Figure