Abstract
We discovered a hysteresis in a microwave-driven low-pressure argon plasma during gas pressure change across the transition region between $\alpha$ and $\gamma$ discharge modes. The hysteresis is manifested in that the critical pressure of mode transition depends on the direction of pressure change. As a corollary, the plasma would attain different discharge properties under the same operating parameters (pressure, power, and gas composition), suggesting a bi-stability or existence of memory effect. Analysis of the rotational and vibrational temperatures measured from the OH (A-X) line emissions shows that the hysteresis is mainly due to the fast gas heating in the $\gamma$-mode leading to a smaller neutral density than that of the $\alpha$-mode. When increasing the gas pressure, the $\gamma$-mode discharge maintains a relatively higher temperature and lower neutral density, and thus, it requires a higher operating pressure to reach the $\alpha$-mode. On the other hand, decreasing the pressure while maintaining $\alpha$-mode, the transition to $\gamma$-mode occurs at a lower pressure than the former case due to a relatively higher neutral density of $\alpha$-mode discharge. This interpretation is supported by the fact that the hysteresis disappears when the plasma properties are presented with respect to the neutral gas density instead of pressure.
Introduction
In high-precision semiconductor manufacturing, plasma reproducibility is paramount. Processes such as etching and deposition frequently utilize microwave-driven plasmas for their high electron density at low power. However, these plasmas can exist in two distinct discharge states: the $\alpha$-mode, dominated by bulk-plasma electrons, and the $\gamma$-mode, dominated by secondary electrons from ion bombardment. A significant challenge arises when identical operating parameters produce different plasma states—a phenomenon known as hysteresis or bi-stability. This study investigates the physical mechanisms behind this "memory effect" in argon plasmas.
Experimental Methodology
The researchers employed a coaxial transmission line resonator (CTLR) to generate argon plasma at approximately 890 MHz. Diagnostics included:
- Optical Emission Spectroscopy (OES): Tracking argon line intensity ratios to monitor electron temperature and ion population.
- Molecular Thermometry: Analyzing OH (A-X) emission lines to estimate rotational ($T_{rot}$) and vibrational ($T_{vib}$) gas temperatures.
- Visual Imaging: High-resolution CMOS photography to characterize the physical morphology of the plasma plumes.
Mode Characterization and Visual Analysis
The transition between $\alpha$ and $\gamma$ modes is marked by a distinct change in the plasma's physical appearance. In the $\alpha$-mode, the plasma exhibits a spherical shape. Upon transitioning to the $\gamma$-mode, the plume adopts a reverse-cone shape, indicating a shift in the underlying discharge physics.
The Hysteresis Phenomenon and Gas Heating
Experimental results revealed that the transition pressure is not constant. When increasing pressure, the plasma remains in the $\gamma$-mode until a higher critical point is reached. Conversely, when decreasing pressure, the $\alpha$-mode persists to a lower pressure point. This creates a hysteresis loop in the transition region (typically 18–22 mTorr).
The study identifies localized gas heating as the primary driver. In the $\gamma$-mode, intense ion bombardment heats the neutral gas significantly. According to the ideal gas law ($PV = nRT$), at a fixed pressure ($P$), an increase in temperature ($T$) necessitates a decrease in neutral density ($n$). The plasma transition is fundamentally governed by the neutral gas density rather than the pressure measured by external gauges.
Conclusion
The discovery that hysteresis disappears when data is plotted against neutral gas density provides a critical insight for industrial plasma control. By accounting for gas heating and monitoring neutral density—perhaps through real-time rotational temperature measurements—manufacturers can eliminate bi-stability and ensure highly reproducible plasma processes for semiconductor fabrication.
Reference: Kim, K., et al. (2022). Mode transition ($\alpha-\gamma$) and hysteresis in microwave-driven low-temperature plasmas. arXiv:2203.00420v1 [physics.plasm-ph].
Summary updated