Mobility Spectrometer Studies on Hydrazine and Ammonia Detection

Hsienchi Niu, Gary A. Eiceman, Andrew W. Szumlas, John Lewis41st 2011 · DOI

Abstract: An airborne vapor analyzer for detecting sub- to low- parts-per-million (ppm) hydrazine in the presence of higher concentration levels of ammonia has been under development for the Orion program. The detector is based on ambient pressure ionization and ion mobility characterization. The detector encompasses: 1) a membrane inlet to exclude particulate and aerosols from the analyzer inlet; 2) a method to separate hydrazine from ammonia which would otherwise lead to loss of calibration and quantitative accuracy for the hydrazine determination; and 3) response and quantitative determinations for both hydrazine and ammonia. Laboratory studies were made to explore some of these features including mobility measurements mindful of power, size, and weight issues. The study recommended the use of a mobility spectrometer of traditional design with a reagent gas and equipped with an inlet transfer line of bonded phase fused silica tube. The inlet transfer line provided gas phase separation of neutrals of ammonia from hydrazine at 50 C simplifying significantly the ionization chemistry that underlies response in a mobility spectrometer. Performance of the analyzer was acceptable between ranges of 30 to 80 C for both the pre-fractionation column and the drift tube. An inlet comprised of a combined membrane with valve-less injector allowed high speed quantitative determination of ammonia and hydrazine without cross reactivity from common metabolites such as alcohols, esters, and aldehydes. Preliminary test results and some of the design features are discussed.

Introduction

When the Orion Crew Exploration Vehicle (CEV) returns to Earth, it utilizes hydrazine thrusters for orientation and ammonia evaporation for cabin cooling. This creates a critical safety challenge: if the fuel system is compromised upon landing, toxic hydrazine vapor could mix with the vented ammonia plume. Hydrazine is exceptionally hazardous, with a Spacecraft Maximum Allowable Concentration (SMAC) for long-term exposure of just 4 parts-per-billion (ppb). Detecting hydrazine is complicated by the presence of ammonia, which is often found in much higher concentrations and competes for charge during the ionization process, potentially "blinding" standard sensors to the presence of hydrazine.

Experimental Methodology

The study evaluated two primary technologies: Ion Mobility Spectrometry (IMS) and Differential Mobility Spectrometry (DMS). Both techniques identify chemicals by ionizing gas molecules and measuring their velocity through an electric field.

Schematic of a traditional Ion Mobility Spectrometer (IMS) showing the separation of ion clusters in a drift region based on drift velocity (vd).

Key technical innovations included:

  • Membrane Inlet: A dimethylsilicone membrane filtered out dust, aerosols, and moisture to stabilize ion chemistry.
  • Pre-fractionation: A valveless injector and a short gas chromatograph (GC) capillary column were implemented to separate neutral ammonia and hydrazine molecules before they reached the ionization source, preventing charge competition.
  • Reagent Gas Chemistry: The system was doped with acetone to shift ionization toward stable acetone-ion associations, suppressing interference from common human metabolites like alcohols and esters.

Results and Discussion

A critical finding of the study was the power-resolution tradeoff. While DMS offers high resolution for small molecules, it requires high-frequency, high-voltage RF fields. Traditional IMS was deemed more "flight-capable" for the Orion program due to its significantly lower power consumption during the post-landing phase.

Ion mobility spectra demonstrating the distinct separation of ammonia (NH3) and hydrazine (N2H4) peaks from the reactant ion peak (RIP) in milliseconds.

The detector successfully identified hydrazine at 100 ppb, with an estimated limit of detection (LOD) near 10 ppb. By utilizing a short capillary transfer line, the total system response time was kept under 60 seconds. In the IMS drift tube, the team achieved distinct, quantifiable peaks for ammonia (approx. 5.8 ms) and hydrazine (approx. 7.5 ms). The system proved robust across a wide thermal range (30°C to 80°C), ensuring reliability in various landing environments.

Conclusion

While the individual components of the analyzer—the membrane, valveless injector, and spectrometer—demonstrated high performance in laboratory "breadboard" prototypes, further integration into a flight-hardened "brassboard" unit is required. Future work will focus on optimizing membrane efficiency to improve ultimate sensitivity and conducting rigorous quantitative testing in simulated real-world spacecraft landing environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

An airborne vapor analyzer for detecting sub- to low- parts-per-million (ppm) hydrazine in the presence of higher concentration levels of ammonia has been under development for the Orion program. The detector is based on ambient pressure ionization and ion mobility characterization. The detector encompasses: 1) a membrane inlet to exclude particulate and aerosols from the analyzer inlet; 2) a method to separate hydrazine from ammonia which would otherwise lead to loss of calibration and quantitative accuracy for the hydrazine determination; and 3) response and quantitative determinations for both hydrazine and ammonia. Laboratory studies were made to explore some of these features including mobility measurements mindful of power, size, and weight issues. The study recommended the use of a mobility spectrometer of traditional design with a reagent gas and equipped with an inlet transfer line of bonded phase fused silica tube. The inlet transfer line provided gas phase separation of neutrals of ammonia from hydrazine at 50 C simplifying significantly the ionization chemistry that underlies response in a mobility spectrometer. Performance of the analyzer was acceptable between ranges of 30 to 80 C for both the pre-fractionation column and the drift tube. An inlet comprised of a combined membrane with valve-less injector allowed high speed quantitative determination of ammonia and hydrazine without cross reactivity from common metabolites such as alcohols, esters, and aldehydes. Preliminary test results and some of the design features are discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{niu2011mobility,
  author = {Hsienchi Niu and Gary A. Eiceman and Andrew W. Szumlas and John Lewis},
  title = {{Mobility Spectrometer Studies on Hydrazine and Ammonia Detection}},
  booktitle = {41st},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.2514/6.2011-5065},
}
Figure