Mobility, mortality, and the middle ages: Identification of migrant individuals in a 14th century black death cemetery population

Ellen J. Kendall, Janet Montgomery, James A. Evans, Chris Stantis, Valerie MuellerAmerican 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses strontium and oxygen stable isotope analysis of tooth enamel from individuals buried in a 14th-century Black Death cemetery in London to identify migrants. The findings reveal that a significant portion of the population, including women, were not local to London, highlighting the city's role as a major migration hub even during times of crisis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding human mobility and migration patterns in the past is crucial for reconstructing social dynamics, trade networks, and responses to environmental and societal pressures. However, traditional methods relying on documentary evidence are often incomplete or biased. For the turbulent 14th century in Britain, characterized by famine, war, and plague, understanding migration is particularly challenging. Previous isotopic studies on mobility in Britain have often used "attritional" cemeteries (where individuals are buried over long periods), making it difficult to pinpoint specific timeframes. This paper addresses this by using a "catastrophic" cemetery (the East Smithfield Black Death Cemetery) with a precisely dated, short use-life (1348-1350), offering a unique snapshot of migration during a period of immense upheaval.

Methods

The core of this study relies on stable isotope analysis of tooth enamel, specifically strontium (Sr) and oxygen (O) isotopes.

  • Strontium Isotopes (⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr): Strontium in tooth enamel reflects the geological bedrock of the region where an individual spent their childhood, as it is absorbed from the soil and water through food. Different geological areas have distinct strontium isotope ratios, acting like a geological fingerprint.
  • Oxygen Isotopes (δ¹⁸O): Oxygen isotopes in tooth enamel are primarily influenced by drinking water, which in turn is linked to local climate and meteorological patterns. This provides another geographical indicator, often reflecting broader climatic zones.

By analyzing both strontium and oxygen isotopes from the same individuals, researchers can create a more robust picture of their childhood origins. The study employed a two-isotope approach, which is more powerful than using a single isotope, as it helps to differentiate between individuals who might appear anomalous based on one isotope alone but are within the local range for the other.

The researchers also used a statistical approach to identify "nonlocals" or migrants. This involved defining a "local" range for the East Smithfield population based on the majority of the sample's isotopic values and then identifying individuals whose values fell significantly outside this range (statistical outliers).

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study consists of tooth enamel samples from 30 adult individuals excavated from the East Smithfield Black Death Cemetery (Royal Mint) in London. This cemetery has a well-documented and narrow use period of AD 1348-1350, making it ideal for studying migration during a specific historical event.

The study also references and compares its findings with data from two other London-based studies:

  • Old Church, Chelsea: A post-Roman cemetery with a broader time range.
  • St. Mary Spital: A medieval cemetery with a longer use period.

These comparative datasets helped to establish a broader context for London's isotopic signature and to highlight the unique temporal resolution offered by the East Smithfield site.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • London as a Magnet for Migration, Even During Crisis: The study found that a notable proportion of individuals buried in the East Smithfield cemetery were not local to London, suggesting that the city continued to attract migrants even during the devastating Black Death pandemic.
  • The Power of the Two-Isotope Approach: Combining strontium and oxygen isotope analysis was crucial for identifying outliers. An individual might have a strontium signature consistent with the local area but an anomalous oxygen signature, or vice versa, indicating a more complex migratory history or environmental influence.
  • Dietary Complexity Influences Strontium Signatures: The observed strontium isotope ratios in the London population were broader than expected based on local geology alone. This suggests that London's food sourcing practices, which involved importing food from a wide hinterland, significantly influenced the strontium signatures of its inhabitants.
  • Challenging Assumptions about Medieval Mobility: The presence of female nonlocals in the sample refutes the idea that migration during this period was exclusively a male prerogative.
  • The Importance of Precise Dating: The short, well-defined timeframe of the East Smithfield cemetery was critical for aligning isotopic data with specific historical events and for creating a more accurate picture of mobility during that period.

Key Results

  • Eight out of 30 individuals (approximately 27%) showed anomalous isotopic values, suggesting they were not local to London.
  • Of these, five individuals were identified as statistical outliers based on combined strontium and oxygen isotope data.
  • Potential origins for these migrants ranged from London's surrounding hinterlands to more distant parts of Britain, including areas with different geological compositions.
  • The study found a high level of consistency in isotopic data between the East Smithfield sample and other London datasets, but this data diverged from the geologically predicted range for the region.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Age Resolution: The study acknowledges limitations in precisely aging individuals, which can affect the interpretation of mobility patterns, especially for younger individuals.
  • "Nonlocal" vs. "Migrant": Isotopic data indicates where an individual spent their childhood, not necessarily where they were born or where they died. The term "nonlocal" is used to reflect this.
  • Dietary Influence on Strontium: The study highlights how complex food sourcing in urban environments can broaden strontium isotope ranges, making it harder to pinpoint precise origins without additional data.
  • Limited Comparative Data: The authors note the scarcity of published comparative strontium and oxygen isotope data for post-Roman London, emphasizing the need for more such studies.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future research should focus on increasing the number of comparative datasets, particularly for oxygen isotopes, and on developing more refined methods for age estimation to improve the accuracy of mobility studies. The authors also emphasize the need to consider the complex interplay of human behavior, diet, and environment when interpreting isotopic data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mobility and migration patterns of groups and individuals have long been a topic of interest to archaeologists, used for broad explanatory models of cultural change as well as illustrations of historical particularism. The 14th century AD was a tumultuous period of history in Britain, with severely erratic weather patterns, the Great Famine of 1315-1322, the Scottish Wars of Independence, and the Hundred Years' War providing additional migration pressures to the ordinary economic issues drawing individuals to their capital under more stable conditions. East Smithfield Black Death Cemetery (Royal Mint) had a documented use period of only 2 years (AD 1348-1350), providing a precise historical context (∼50 years) for data. Adults (n = 30) from the East Smithfield site were sampled for strontium and oxygen stable isotope analyses of tooth enamel. Five individuals were demonstrated to be statistical outliers through the combined strontium and oxygen isotope data. Potential origins for migrants ranged from London's surrounding hinterlands to distant portions of northern and western Britain. Historic food sourcing practices for London were found to be an important factor for consideration in a broader than expected (87) Sr/(86) Sr range reflected in a comparison of enamel samples from three London datasets. The pooled dataset demonstrated a high level of consistency between site data, divergent from the geologically predicted range. We argue that this supports the premise that isotope data in human populations must be approached as a complex interaction between behavior and environment and thus should be interpreted cautiously with the aid of alternate lines of evidence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kendall2012mobility,
  author = {Ellen J. Kendall and Janet Montgomery and James A. Evans and Chris Stantis and Valerie Mueller},
  title = {{Mobility, mortality, and the middle ages: Identification of migrant individuals in a 14th century black death cemetery population}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1002/ajpa.22194},
}
Figure