Mobile elements in human population-specific genome and phenotype divergence

Shohei Kojima, Satoshi Koyama, Mirei Ka, Yuka Saito, Erica H. Parrish, Mikiko Endo, Sadaaki Takata, Misaki Mizukoshi, Keiko Hikino, Atsushi Takeda, Asami F. Gelinas, Steven M. Heaton, Rie Koide, Anselmo Jiro Kamada, Michiya Noguchi, Michiaki Hamada, Yoichiro Kamatani, Yasuhiro Murakawa, Kazuyoshi Ishigaki, Yukio Nakamura, Kaoru Ito, Chikashi Terao, Yukihide Momozawa, Nicholas F. ParrishbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Mobile genetic elements (MEs) are heritable mutagens that contribute to divergence between lineages by recursively generating structural variants. ME variants (MEVs) are difficult to genotype, obscuring their impact on recent genome and trait diversification. We developed MEGAnE, a tool that uses short-read sequence data to accurately genotype MEVs, enabling us to study them using statistical genetics methods in global human genomes. We observe population-specific differences in the distribution of Alu insertions that distinguish Japanese from other populations. We integrated MEVs with epigenomic and expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) maps to determine how they impact traits. This reveals coherent patterns by which specific MEs regulate tissue-specific gene expression, including creating or attenuating enhancers and recruiting post-transcriptional regulators. We pinpoint MEVs as genetic causes of disease risk, including a LINE-1 insertion linked to keloid and other diseases of fibroblast inflammation, by introducing MEVs into the genome-wide association study (GWAS) framework. In addition to nominating previously-hidden MEVs as causes of human diseases, this work highlights MEs as accelerators of human population divergence and begins to decipher the semantics of MEs.

Introduction

The human genome is significantly composed of mobile genetic elements (MEs)—DNA sequences like Alu, LINE-1, and SVA that can relocate via retrotransposition. Despite their prevalence, MEs are often considered the "dark matter" of genomics due to the difficulty of accurately mapping repetitive sequences with standard short-read sequencing. This technical barrier has historically excluded ME variants (MEVs) from large-scale Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS), potentially leaving causal variants for many complex traits unidentified.

Methodology: The MEGAnE Framework

To address this, we developed the Mobile Element Genotype Analysis Environment (MEGAnE). MEGAnE utilizes chimeric and hybrid reads, polyA/T tail detection, and Target-Site Duplication (TSD) analysis to identify ME insertion breakpoints and infer genotypes from local read depth. The study leveraged massive genomic resources, including the 1000 Genomes Project (1000GP) for global population analysis, BioBank Japan (BBJ) for population-specific insights, and the Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) project to link MEVs to gene expression across 49 tissues.

MEGAnE was validated against "ground truth" data from long-read sequencing and targeted deep sequencing, achieving high accuracy and low false-positive rates (3–6%).

Validation of MEGAnE genotyping accuracy against ground truth and deep sequencing data.

Results: Mobile Elements as Drivers of Diversity

Our analysis identified 48,360 MEVs in the 1000GP cohort and 10,996 in the Japanese cohort. Principal component analysis (PCA) of these genotypes clearly distinguishes major global populations. Notably, we observed population-specific shifts in Alu insertion preferences; in Japanese genomes, Alu elements are more frequently found in early-replicating, gene-rich regions compared to European or African populations.

Population structure and distribution of mobile element variants (MEVs) across global and Japanese cohorts.

The "Semantics" and Regulatory Impact of MEs

MEs follow a functional logic: LINE-1 elements tend to land in heterochromatin, while SVA elements prefer active chromatin regions. Integration with eQTL data identified 1,073 instances where an ME insertion directly regulated gene expression. Some MEs act as enhancers, while others attenuate existing regulatory elements. Additionally, some Alu insertions in the 3’UTR recruit proteins like FAM120A to destabilize RNA, providing a post-transcriptional regulatory mechanism.

Disease Associations and Functional Validation

By including MEVs in a GWAS framework, we pinpointed five MEVs associated with major diseases in the Japanese population. A specific LINE-1 insertion in the NEDD4 gene was identified as a functional enhancer for a protein isoform strongly linked to keloid risk. This was validated experimentally using CRISPR-Cas9 to knock out the insertion in iPSCs, which demonstrated its role in regulating NEDD4 expression and fibroblast inflammation. Other findings include an L1 insertion linked to Type 2 Diabetes risk and an Alu insertion in the EGFR gene associated with asthma risk.

Discussion and Future Directions

MEGAnE represents a significant advancement in resolving the genomic "dark matter" of mobile elements. While short-read data has intrinsic limits in resolving complex nested insertions, this tool enables the identification of previously hidden causal variants. Future research applying these methods to larger biobanks will further clarify the "missing heritability" of complex diseases and the functional logic governing ME transposition and function.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Mobile genetic elements (MEs) are heritable mutagens that contribute to divergence between lineages by recursively generating structural variants. ME variants (MEVs) are difficult to genotype, obscuring their impact on recent genome and trait diversification. We developed a tool that uses short-read sequence data to accurately genotype MEVs, enabling us to study them using statistical genetics methods in global human genomes. We observe population-specific differences in the distribution of Alu insertions that distinguish Japanese from other populations. We integrated MEVs with epigenomic and expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) maps to determine how they impact traits. This reveals coherent patterns by which specific MEs regulate tissue-specific gene expression, including creating or attenuating enhancers and recruiting post-transcriptional regulators. We pinpoint MEVs as genetic causes of disease risk, including a LINE-1 insertion linked to keloid and other diseases of fibroblast inflammation, by introducing MEVs into the genome-wide association study (GWAS) framework. In addition to nominating previously-hidden MEVs as causes of human diseases, this work highlights MEs as accelerators of human population divergence and begins to decipher the semantics of MEs.
BibTeX
@misc{kojima2022mobile,
  author = {Shohei Kojima and Satoshi Koyama and Mirei Ka and Yuka Saito and Erica H. Parrish and Mikiko Endo and Sadaaki Takata and Misaki Mizukoshi and Keiko Hikino and Atsushi Takeda and Asami F. Gelinas and Steven M. Heaton and Rie Koide and Anselmo Jiro Kamada and Michiya Noguchi and Michiaki Hamada and Yoichiro Kamatani and Yasuhiro Murakawa and Kazuyoshi Ishigaki and Yukio Nakamura and Kaoru Ito and Chikashi Terao and Yukihide Momozawa and Nicholas F. Parrish},
  title = {{Mobile elements in human population-specific genome and phenotype divergence}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.03.25.485726},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure