R. E. Mitchell, M. R. Shepherd, D. Besson, T. K. Pedlar, D. Cronin-Hennessy, K. Y. Gao, J. Hietala, Y. Kubota, T. Klein, B. W. Lang, R. Poling, A. W. Scott, P. Zweber, S. Dobbs, Z. Metreveli, K. K. Seth, A. Tomaradze, J. Libby, A. Powell, G. Wilkinson, K. M. Ecklund, W. A. Love, V. Savinov, A. Lopez, H. Méndez, J. E. Ramirez Vargas, Jun Ge, D. H. Miller, I. P. J. Shipsey, B. Xin, G. S. Adams, Mark Anderson, J. P. Cummings, I. Dankó, D. Hu, B. Moziak, J. Napolitano, Q. He, J. Insler, H. Muramatsu, C. S. Park, E. H. Thorndike, F. Yang, M. Artuso, S. Blusk, S. Khalil, Jiangfeng Li Jiangfeng Li, R. Mountain, S. Nisar, K. Randrianarivony, N. Sultana, T. Skwarnicki, S. Stone, J. C. Wang, L. M. Zhang, G. Bonvicini, D. Cinabro, M. Dubrovin, A. Lincoln, P. Naik, J. H. Rademacker, D. M. Asner, K. W. Edwards, J. Reed, R. A. Briere, T. Ferguson, G. Tatishvili, H. Vogel, M. E. Watkins, J. L. Rosner, J. Alexander, D. G. Cassel, J. E. Duboscq, R. Ehrlich, L. Fields, R. S. Galik, L. Gibbons, R. Gray, S. W. Gray, D. L. Hartill, B. K. Heltsley, D. Hertz, J. M. Hunt, J. Kandaswamy, D. L. Kreinick, В. Е. Кузнецов, James Ledoux, H. Mahlke-Krüger, D. Mohapatra, P. U. E. Onyisi, J. R. Patterson, D. Peterson, D. Riley, A. Rýd, A. J. Sadoff, X. Shi, S. Stroiney, W. Sun, T. Wilksen, S. B. AtharPhysical2009 · DOI · arXiv
Using $2.45 \times 10^7$ $\psi(2S)$ decays collected with the CLEO-c detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring, we present the most precise measurements of magnetic dipole transitions in the charmonium system. We measure $\mathcal{B}(\psi(2S) \to \gamma \eta_c) = (4.32 \pm 0.16 \pm 0.60) \times 10^{-3}$, $\mathcal{B}(J/\psi \to \gamma \eta_c) / \mathcal{B}(\psi(2S) \to \gamma \eta_c) = 4.59 \pm 0.23 \pm 0.64$, and $\mathcal{B}(J/\psi \to \gamma \eta_c) = (1.98 \pm 0.09 \pm 0.30)\%$. We observe a distortion in the $\eta_c$ line shape due to the photon-energy dependence of the magnetic dipole transition rate. We find that measurements of the $\eta_c$ mass are sensitive to the line shape, suggesting an explanation for the discrepancy between measurements of the $\eta_c$ mass in radiative transitions and other production mechanisms.
Introduction
In the field of subatomic physics, charmonium—a bound state of a charm quark and its antiquark—serves as a crucial testing ground for Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the theory describing the strong force. Magnetic dipole (M1) transitions, where higher-energy states like $J/\psi$ or $\psi(2S)$ decay into the lower-energy $\eta_c$ by emitting a photon, are fundamental processes. Historically, these transitions have been difficult to measure accurately, leading to a $3.3\sigma$ inconsistency: the mass of the $\eta_c$ measured via radiative transitions did not match the mass measured through other methods such as proton-antiproton collisions. This study by the CLEO Collaboration addresses this gap by providing high-precision measurements and improved line shape modeling.
Methodology and Data Analysis
The research team utilized the CLEO-c detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR), analyzing a dataset of 24.5 million $\psi(2S)$ decays. They employed two complementary approaches: an exclusive analysis tracking 12 specific $\eta_c$ decay modes to suppress background noise and study the particle's shape, and an inclusive analysis of the total photon energy spectrum to measure the overall transition rate.
A significant technical breakthrough was the implementation of a modified relativistic Breit-Wigner fit for the $\eta_c$ line shape. Standard practice often uses a symmetric distribution, but the CLEO team accounted for the $E_\gamma^3$ photon-energy dependence of the M1 transition rate, which skews the resulting signal.
Table of primary measured yields and efficiencies used in the branching fraction calculations.
The primary measured quantities, including inclusive and exclusive yields ($N$) and efficiencies ($\epsilon$), are summarized in the table above. These values form the basis for the final branching fraction determinations.
Results and Systematic Uncertainties
The study found that accounting for the line shape distortion significantly shifts the measured $\eta_c$ mass. Using a standard fit yielded a mass of ~2977 MeV/$c^2$, while the modified fit resulted in ~2982 MeV/$c^2$, aligning perfectly with measurements from other production mechanisms.
These transition rates are 44% to 56% higher than previous world averages, suggesting that earlier experiments undercounted $\eta_c$ production by failing to model the asymmetric line shape.
Summary of systematic uncertainties (%) for the branching fractions and their ratio.
The precision of these results is supported by a detailed evaluation of systematic uncertainties, as shown in the table above. Major contributors include fitting procedures and the modeling of inclusive $\eta_c$ decays.
Discussion and Conclusion
This work demonstrates that the observed $\eta_c$ shape is heavily influenced by the dynamics of the M1 transition. Careful modeling of photon-energy dependence is essential for precision charmonium studies. While the empirical "damping factor" used in the fit introduces some uncertainty, the resolution of the mass discrepancy is a major step forward. These results necessitate the recalculation of many experimental values that rely on $\eta_c$ normalization and set a new benchmark for future high-precision studies at facilities like BESIII.
Summary updated
Abstract
Using 2.45x10;{7} psi(2S) decays collected with the CLEO-c detector at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring we present the most precise measurements of magnetic dipole transitions in the charmonium system. We measure B(psi(2S)-->gammaeta_{c})=(4.32+/-0.16+/-0.60)x10;{-3}, B(J/psi-->gammaeta_{c})/B(psi(2S)-->gammaeta_{c})=4.59+/-0.23+/-0.64, and B(J/psi-->gammaeta_{c})=(1.98+/-0.09+/-0.30)%. We observe a distortion in the eta_{c} line shape due to the photon-energy dependence of the magnetic dipole transition rate. We find that measurements of the eta_{c} mass are sensitive to the line shape, suggesting an explanation for the discrepancy between measurements of the eta_{c} mass in radiative transitions and other production mechanisms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mitchell2009mml,
author = {R. E. Mitchell and M. R. Shepherd and D. Besson and T. K. Pedlar and D. Cronin-Hennessy and K. Y. Gao and J. Hietala and Y. Kubota and T. Klein and B. W. Lang and R. Poling and A. W. Scott and P. Zweber and S. Dobbs and Z. Metreveli and K. K. Seth and A. Tomaradze and J. Libby and A. Powell and G. Wilkinson and K. M. Ecklund and W. A. Love and V. Savinov and A. Lopez and H. Méndez and J. E. Ramirez Vargas and Jun Ge and D. H. Miller and I. P. J. Shipsey and B. Xin and G. S. Adams and Mark Anderson and J. P. Cummings and I. Dankó and D. Hu and B. Moziak and J. Napolitano and Q. He and J. Insler and H. Muramatsu and C. S. Park and E. H. Thorndike and F. Yang and M. Artuso and S. Blusk and S. Khalil and Jiangfeng LI Jiangfeng LI and R. Mountain and S. Nisar and K. Randrianarivony and N. Sultana and T. Skwarnicki and S. Stone and J. C. Wang and L. M. Zhang and G. Bonvicini and D. Cinabro and M. Dubrovin and A. Lincoln and P. Naik and J. H. Rademacker and D. M. Asner and K. W. Edwards and J. Reed and R. A. Briere and T. Ferguson and G. Tatishvili and H. Vogel and M. E. Watkins and J. L. Rosner and J. Alexander and D. G. Cassel and J. E. Duboscq and R. Ehrlich and L. Fields and R. S. Galik and L. Gibbons and R. Gray and S. W. Gray and D. L. Hartill and B. K. Heltsley and D. Hertz and J. M. Hunt and J. Kandaswamy and D. L. Kreinick and В. Е. Кузнецов and James Ledoux and H. Mahlke-Krüger and D. Mohapatra and P. U. E. Onyisi and J. R. Patterson and D. Peterson and D. Riley and A. Rýd and A. J. Sadoff and X. Shi and S. Stroiney and W. Sun and T. Wilksen and S. B. Athar},
title = {{<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>J</mml:mi><mml:mo>/</mml:mo><mml:mi>ψ</mml:mi></mml:math>and<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>ψ</mml:mi><mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo><mml:mn>2</mml:mn><mml:mi>S</mml:mi><mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo></mml:math>Radiative Transitions to<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msub><mml:mi>η</mml:mi><mml:mi>c</mml:mi></mml:msub></mml:math>}},
booktitle = {Physical},
year = {2009},
doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.102.011801},
}