Mixtures of Gaussians and Minimum Relative Entropy Techniques for Modeling Continuous Uncertainties

William B. Poland, Ross D. ShachterUAI 1993

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to modeling continuous uncertainties in decision analysis by fitting mixtures of Gaussian distributions. By leveraging the minimum relative entropy principle and the Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm, it offers a flexible and computationally efficient alternative to traditional discretization or restrictive parametric models, enabling more accurate and tractable analysis of complex problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Decision analysis and probabilistic inference often deal with continuous random variables. However, exact solution methods are typically limited to discrete variables. Existing approximation techniques like discretization can be computationally burdensome and inaccurate, especially for distributions with significant tails. Other methods, like Monte Carlo simulations, can also be slow, while moment-based approaches may fail for multimodal distributions. Parametric approaches, like Gaussian influence diagrams, are computationally efficient but often too restrictive in their assumptions about the underlying distributions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a flexible yet computationally tractable method for modeling continuous uncertainties using mixtures of Gaussian distributions.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in combining two key ideas:

  • Minimum Relative Entropy (MRE) Principle: This principle is used to find a distribution of a desired form (e.g., Gaussian or a mixture of Gaussians) that is "closest" to an original, potentially complex, distribution. Relative entropy (Kullback-Leibler divergence) quantifies this "distance." The paper shows how MRE can drive both transformations of variables and fitting of mixture distributions.
  • Mixture of Gaussians (MoG) and Influence Diagrams (IDs): The authors extend the concept of Gaussian Influence Diagrams (GIDs) to Mixture-of-Gaussians Influence Diagrams (MOGIDs). A MoG is a flexible distribution formed by a weighted sum of Gaussian distributions, allowing for more complex shapes than a single Gaussian. They propose a procedure to expand MoG nodes in an ID, making them amenable to standard ID solution techniques, provided certain conditions are met (no continuous-to-discrete arcs, and the remaining structure is a GID).
  • Expectation-Maximization (EM) Algorithm: For fitting MoGs to a given distribution, the paper adapts the EM algorithm. This algorithm iteratively refines the parameters (means, variances, and mixture weights) of the MoG to maximize the likelihood of the observed data (or, in this case, to minimize the relative entropy with the target distribution).
  • Variable Transformation: To improve the fit of Gaussian or MoG distributions, the paper proposes transforming variables using a power/logarithm family (Box-Cox transformations). The MRE principle is used to find the optimal transformation parameter that makes the transformed variable's distribution as close as possible to a Gaussian.
  • Automated Mixture Size Selection: A heuristic is presented to automatically determine the optimal number of components in a MoG, balancing accuracy (measured by relative entropy decrease) and computational cost (related to the number of components).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and algorithmic procedures, illustrating them with examples of fitting distributions (exponential, uniform) and a conceptual oil wildcatter problem.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flexibility of MoGs: Mixtures of Gaussians offer a powerful way to approximate a wide range of continuous distributions, including multimodal and skewed ones, without resorting to computationally expensive discretization.
  • MRE as a Unifying Principle: The minimum relative entropy criterion elegantly connects variable transformations and distribution fitting, providing a principled way to achieve desired distributional forms.
  • EM Algorithm for Distribution Fitting: Adapting the EM algorithm for fitting distributions (rather than just empirical data) is a key procedural contribution, generalizing maximum likelihood estimation.
  • MOGIDs for Decision Analysis: Extending influence diagrams to handle MoGs allows for more expressive and realistic modeling of continuous uncertainties in decision problems, while still leveraging efficient ID solution techniques.
  • Transformation-then-Fit Strategy: Combining variable transformations (like Box-Cox) with MoG fitting provides a robust two-step approach to accurately model complex continuous distributions.

Key Results

  • The paper demonstrates that power/logarithm transformations, guided by the MRE principle, can make distributions (like exponential and uniform) significantly closer to Gaussian distributions.
  • The EM algorithm is shown to effectively fit MoGs to various distributions, approximating non-Gaussian shapes with a small number of components.
  • A heuristic for selecting the number of MoG components is proposed, which balances fitting accuracy with computational complexity.
  • The paper outlines how MOGIDs can be solved using existing influence diagram reduction procedures, enabling decision analysis with these more flexible models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Multivariate Generalization: While the paper focuses on univariate transformations and fitting, it acknowledges that multivariate generalizations are straightforward but require further research for practical implementation, especially regarding dependence structures.
  • Computational Cost of MoGs: Although more efficient than discretization for complex distributions, fitting MoGs, especially with many components, can still be computationally intensive.
  • Nested Optimization: The paper suggests exploring the possibility of nesting the minimum-relative-entropy transformation search within the mixture size search to potentially improve computational efficiency.
  • Dependence Structures: Developing methods to fit dependence relationships in an analytically convenient way for multivariate MoGs is highlighted as a key research direction.
  • Generalizing Tractable Models: Further research is needed to generalize existing models that rely on the tractability of Gaussians but are limited by their restrictive assumptions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{poland1993mixtures,
  author = {William B. Poland and Ross D. Shachter},
  title = {{Mixtures of Gaussians and Minimum Relative Entropy Techniques for Modeling Continuous Uncertainties}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1993},
}
Figure