TL;DR
This paper introduces a mixed reality (MR) game designed to educate users about the environmental impact of bread waste and carbon emissions. By integrating this MR game into a blended learning approach, the study demonstrates its effectiveness in raising awareness and promoting sustainable behaviors, with participants showing high engagement and usability ratings.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Food waste is a significant global issue, contributing to environmental degradation. In Macau, food scraps constitute a substantial portion of solid waste. While initiatives exist to combat this, the waste of staple foods like bread remains a persistent problem. Existing educational approaches often fail to connect individual actions to broader environmental impacts. This paper addresses the need for more engaging and effective methods to educate the public about food waste, specifically bread waste, and its link to carbon emissions, by leveraging the immersive capabilities of mixed reality within a blended learning framework.
Methods
The study employs a mixed-methods approach combining a custom-designed MR game with a blended learning model.
- MR Game Design: The game, developed using Unity and targeting the Meta Quest 3, focuses on the relationship between bread waste and carbon footprints. It features interactive elements, such as striking virtual bread to earn "carbon footprint points," and incorporates educational quizzes. The design emphasizes perceptual interaction and task-oriented challenges to immerse users in the pathway of sustainable behavioral impact.
- Blended Learning Model: The approach combines online web-based learning for foundational knowledge on carbon footprints and food waste with offline MR game experiences for practical, experiential learning.
- Data Collection: User feedback was gathered through questionnaires, including the Game Experience Questionnaire (GEQ) and the System Usability Scale (SUS), and semi-structured interviews.
Datasets
The study did not utilize pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it involved:
- Empirical Case Studies: Field investigations were conducted in eight Macau bakeries to collect and categorize surplus bread samples.
- User Data: Data was collected from 59 university student participants through questionnaires and interviews after they engaged with the MR game.
Key Insights and Ideas
- MR for Sustainability Education: Mixed reality offers a powerful platform for making abstract environmental concepts, like carbon footprints, tangible and engaging for learners.
- Blended Learning Synergy: Combining online theoretical learning with offline MR experiential learning creates a more comprehensive and effective educational experience.
- Behavioral Linkage: The game successfully links individual actions (bread consumption and waste) to measurable environmental consequences (carbon emissions), fostering a deeper understanding of sustainable behaviors.
- High User Engagement: The MR game design, with its interactive challenges and visually appealing interface, led to high participant affinity and perceived intuitiveness.
Key Results
- Usability and Affinity: Over 90% of participants expressed strong affinity for the MR game's system design, and over 85% found it intuitively operable.
- Positive Experience: The Game Experience Questionnaire (GEQ) revealed highly positive engagement, with high scores in Competence and Flow State, and extremely low negative emotions.
- System Usability Scale (SUS): Both user and non-user groups scored above the industry benchmark of 68, indicating good overall system usability. The non-user group achieved an average score of 72.8.
- Awareness Impact: Post-instructional engagement with the MR game demonstrated the system's potential to deliver solutions for reducing bread waste and carbon emissions.
Limitations and Future Work
- Single-Site Student Sample: The study's reliance on university students in Macau limits the generalizability of findings to broader demographics. Future research should include more diverse populations.
- Lack of a Control Group: The one-group pretest-posttest design makes it difficult to definitively attribute learning gains solely to the MR game. Experimental or quasi-experimental designs with control groups are recommended.
- Short-Term Data: Data was collected immediately after the MR experience, capturing only short-term reactions. Longitudinal studies are needed to assess long-term retention and behavioral change.
- Self-Reported Measures: The study primarily used subjective measures. Future research could incorporate objective measures like knowledge tests or real-world behavior tracking.
- Enhancing Motivation: While engagement was high, participants suggested further enhancements to the game's motivational aspects, such as leaderboards and reward badges. Improved tutorial design was also noted as beneficial for users new to VR.
Summary updated