Mixed Multi-Pattern Regression for DNI Prediction in Arid Desert Areas

Tian Han, Ying Wang, Xiao Wang, Kang Chen, Huaiwu Peng, Zhenxin Gao, Lanxin Cui, Wentong Sun, Qinke PengSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Mixed Multi-Pattern Regression" (MMP) model for accurately predicting Direct Normal Irradiance (DNI) in arid desert regions, crucial for the stable operation of concentrated solar power (CSP) plants. By combining clear-sky irradiance models with extracted time-series patterns of meteorological data, MMP significantly outperforms existing methods. Furthermore, a transfer learning approach (T-MMP) is proposed to address data scarcity in these regions, showing even better prediction accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate prediction of Direct Normal Irradiance (DNI) is vital for the efficient and stable operation of Concentrated Solar Power (CSP) plants. However, DNI is inherently variable due to fluctuating weather conditions, posing a significant challenge. Arid desert areas, while rich in solar potential, often suffer from limited historical weather data, making it difficult to train robust prediction models. Existing methods, especially those relying heavily on large datasets or complex sky-image analysis, struggle with this data scarcity and the unique meteorological patterns of arid environments. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a DNI prediction model that leverages both physical insights (clear-sky models) and data-driven pattern recognition, specifically tailored for data-limited arid regions.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the proposed Mixed Multi-Pattern Regression (MMP) model. MMP integrates two key components:

  1. Clear-Sky Solar Irradiance (CSI) Model: This provides a theoretical baseline estimation of solar radiation under ideal, cloud-free conditions. The paper utilizes the BIRD model, a well-established framework for this purpose.
  2. Pattern Representation using Dynamic Time Warping (PR-DTW): This technique, developed by the authors, is used to extract short-term, medium-term, and long-term patterns from meteorological time series data (including DNI, GHI, DHI, pressure, wind, and humidity). PR-DTW is chosen for its robustness against noise and its ability to handle time-series segmentation.

MMP works by:

  • Calculating the difference (using DTW) between the actual meteorological patterns and the theoretical patterns derived from the CSI model. These differences become "pattern variables."
  • These pattern variables, along with the original meteorological time series, are fed into a Gradient Boosting Regression Tree (GBRT) regressor.
  • Predictions from different time scales are then integrated into an ensemble model to produce the final DNI prediction.

To address the challenge of limited data in arid regions, the authors also propose T-MMP, which combines MMP with transfer learning. This involves training an MMP model on a similar, data-rich "source" dataset and then fine-tuning it on the limited "target" dataset.

Datasets

The study utilizes hourly observational data from three arid desert locations in Northwest China:

  • Dataset 1: Hami, Xinjiang, China (2013)
  • Dataset 2: Dunhuang, Gansu, China (2013)
  • Dataset 3: Jinta, Gansu, China (2014)

These datasets contain seven key meteorological factors: GHI, DNI, DHI, atmospheric pressure, wind direction, wind speed, and relative humidity. For training and testing, data from January to October was used as the training set, and November and December data served as the test set, reflecting a whole year's worth of data. For the T-MMP model, Jinta County data (2014) was used as the source dataset, and Dunhuang data (2013) as the target dataset, chosen due to their geographical proximity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Patterns: The research strongly suggests that extracting and analyzing time-series patterns of meteorological data, especially at different time scales, is crucial for accurate DNI prediction. These patterns capture subtle dynamics that raw data might miss.
  • CSI as Prior Knowledge: Integrating clear-sky irradiance models provides valuable physical context, acting as a strong prior that guides the prediction process and improves accuracy, particularly in arid environments where clear skies are frequent.
  • Inter-Region Pattern Correlation: A surprising discovery is that meteorological change patterns in geographically similar arid areas show a strong correlation. This insight is the foundation for the successful application of transfer learning, suggesting that knowledge gained from one arid region can be effectively transferred to another.
  • Addressing Data Scarcity: The T-MMP model demonstrates that transfer learning is a viable and effective strategy to overcome the limitations of sparse historical data in arid regions, leading to improved prediction performance.

Key Results

The proposed MMP model consistently outperformed 15 other benchmark models across three datasets. Key quantitative results include:

  • MMP Performance: On the Dunhuang dataset, MMP achieved an nMAE of 0.2570, nRMSE of 0.4633, and an R-value of 0.9194. These metrics were generally better than most other models, including deep learning approaches.
  • T-MMP Improvement: The T-MMP model, using Dunhuang as the target dataset, further improved performance with an nMAE of 0.2357, nRMSE of 0.4210, and an R-value of 0.9236, surpassing the standalone MMP.
  • Qualitative Comparison: Visualizations showed that MMP's predicted DNI sequences closely matched the true values, even during cloudy conditions, with smaller DTW distances compared to other models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: While T-MMP addresses data scarcity, the paper acknowledges that the amount of available data in arid desert areas can still be a limiting factor.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on specific arid desert regions in Northwest China. Further research could explore the applicability of these models to other arid regions globally.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the discovered correlation between meteorological patterns in similar arid areas could be a fertile ground for future research in data analysis and climate change studies. They also highlight the potential for these insights to inform meteorological analyses and improve solar radiation prediction more broadly.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a crucial issue in renewable energy, accurate prediction of direct normal solar irradiance (DNI) is essential for the stable operation of concentrated solar power (CSP) stations, especially for those in arid desert areas. In this study, in order to fully explore the laws of climate change and assess the solar resources in arid desert areas, we have proposed a mixed multi-pattern regression model (MMP) for short-term DNI prediction using prior knowledge provided by the clear-sky solar irradiance (CSI) model and time series patterns of key meteorological factors mined using PR-DTW on different time scales. The contrastive experimental results demonstrated that MMP can outperform existing DNI prediction models in terms of three recognized statistical metrics. To address the challenge of limited data in arid desert areas, we presented the T-MMP model involving combined transfer learning and MMP. The experimental results demonstrated that T-MMP outperformed MMP in DNI prediction by exploiting the significant correlation between meteorological time series patterns in similar areas for data augmentation. Our study provided a valuable prediction model for accurate DNI prediction in arid desert areas, facilitating the economical and stable operation of CSP plants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2023mixed,
  author = {Tian Han and Ying Wang and Xiao Wang and Kang Chen and Huaiwu Peng and Zhenxin Gao and Lanxin Cui and Wentong Sun and Qinke Peng},
  title = {{Mixed Multi-Pattern Regression for DNI Prediction in Arid Desert Areas}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151712885},
}
Figure