Mixed Methods Research on Satisfaction with Basic Medical Insurance for Urban and Rural Residents in China

Xiaofang Liu, Fang Yang, Wenwei Cheng, Yanyan Wu, Cheng Jin, Weichu Sun, Xiaofang Yan, Mingming Luo, Xiankun Mo, Mi Hu, Qian Lin, Jingcheng ShiResearch 2020 · DOI

Introduction

In 2016, China initiated a major healthcare reform by merging urban and rural resident medical insurance schemes into a single integrated system known as the Urban and Rural Resident Basic Medical Insurance (URRBMI). While this move aimed to enhance equity and efficiency, achieving high levels of public satisfaction has proven difficult due to the complexity of the policies and the diverse needs of the insured population. This study investigates the factors influencing public satisfaction and trust in the URRBMI system to provide evidence-based recommendations for policy improvement.

Methodology

The researchers employed an explanatory sequential mixed-methods design to capture both statistical trends and individual experiences:

  1. Quantitative Phase: A survey was conducted among 1,335 guardians of primary school students in Changsha. The team utilized Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to analyze relationships between latent variables such as "Perceived Quality," "Public Expectations," and "Public Trust." They also used Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) to identify which policy attributes were most critical yet underperforming.
  2. Qualitative Phase: To explain the quantitative results, 23 semi-structured telephone interviews were conducted with participants representing various satisfaction levels. This allowed for a deeper exploration of specific grievances and policy perceptions.

Key Results

The quantitative analysis demonstrated that public satisfaction is primarily "quality-driven" rather than "price-driven." The statistical model revealed that Perceived Quality had the most significant impact on Public Satisfaction, which in turn served as the primary driver for Public Trust.

Structural model of public satisfaction with URRBMI showing path coefficients between latent variables.

As shown in the structural model, the path from Perceived Quality to Public Satisfaction showed a total effect of 0.737, while the path from Public Satisfaction to Public Trust showed a total effect of 0.634. These results suggest that trust in the government’s health system is earned through the functional performance and perceived value of the policy.

Policy Quality and the "Propaganda Gap"

The Importance-Performance Analysis (IPA) highlighted Policy Quality as the most critical area for improvement. Despite its high importance to the public, it received the lowest performance score (50.256) among all quality indicators.

Qualitative interviews further illuminated these findings, revealing several key pain points:

  • Narrow Reimbursement Scopes: Participants frequently complained about the limited "reimbursable drug list" and high deductibles, especially for chronic diseases that require expensive outpatient care rather than hospitalization.
  • The Communication Mismatch: A significant "propaganda gap" was identified. The government typically promotes insurance when residents are healthy, but the insured only seek detailed policy information when they are ill. This leads to low "policy cognition" and frustration during the actual reimbursement process.
  • Economic Pressures: While urban residents generally accepted annual premium increases, rural residents—often supporting large, multi-generational households—viewed rising costs as a substantial financial burden.

Discussion and Recommendations

The study concludes that improving the quality of the URRBMI is the most effective way to bolster public satisfaction and trust. The authors suggest that the government should:

  • Broaden Coverage: Expand the drug catalogue and medical treatment projects covered by the insurance.
  • Refine Reimbursement: Rationally formulate reimbursement standards to reduce the out-of-pocket burden for chronic disease management.
  • Targeted Education: Implement "just-in-time" health education at the point of clinical service to ensure residents understand their benefits when they need them most.

Conclusion

By shifting the focus from universal coverage to high-quality service and effective communication, the Chinese government can address the current bottlenecks in public satisfaction. Future research should look into "heterogeneity," examining how specific groups—such as the elderly or low-income families—experience these policies differently to allow for even more targeted interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: There are few studies on satisfaction with integrated basic medical insurance for urban and rural residents (URRBMI), and satisfaction with URRBMI is not very high due to the complexity of its policies and differences among the insured. The aim of the present study was to explore the factors that influence satisfaction with URRBMI in China and to provide scientific suggestions for the government to effectively manage and improve the policy. Methods: An explanatory sequential design in mixed method research was used. Quantitative study adopted a three-stage stratified cluster sampling method to randomly select the guardians of pupils who had participated in the URRBMI ( n =1335). A quantitative study was conducted to calculate latent variables’ score and path coefficient between latent variables by SmartPLS3. 0. With public trust, public satisfaction and perceived quality as the target variables, the important-performance analysis (IPA) was used to explore the important but insufficient performance factors, which were the key elements to improve satisfaction of URRBMI. A purposeful sampling strategy was used to get qualitative research subjects from quantitative research subjects according to satisfaction level. A qualitative study was conducted using semi-structured interviews and the thematic analysis method was used to summarize the interview data. Results: Perceived quality to public satisfaction with a total effect of 0.737 ( t =41.270, P <0.001), perceived quality to perceived value with a total effect of 0.676 ( t =31.964, P <0.001), and public satisfaction to public trust with a total effect of 0.634 ( t =31.305, P <0.001) were three strongest paths. IPA showed that public satisfaction and perceived quality were key factors for public trust and that perceived quality was of high importance and low performance for public satisfaction. The policy quality was a determining factor for perceived quality. Qualitative research showed that the most unsatisfactory aspect for the insured was the policy quality. Conclusions: This study found that improving quality is key to improving public satisfaction and public trust of URRBMI. The government should improve the compensation level by broadening the channel of financing for URRBMI fund, rationally formulating reimbursement standards and broadening the scope of the drug catalogue and the medical treatment projects. The government should establish a stable financing growth mechanism and effective ways of health education so as to improve public satisfaction and public trust.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020mixed,
  author = {Xiaofang Liu and Fang Yang and Wenwei Cheng and Yanyan Wu and Cheng Jin and Weichu Sun and Xiaofang Yan and Mingming Luo and Xiankun Mo and Mi Hu and Qian Lin and Jingcheng Shi},
  title = {{Mixed Methods Research on Satisfaction with Basic Medical Insurance for Urban and Rural Residents in China}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-15564/v2},
}
Figure