Mixed-Field Radiation Monitoring and Beam Characterization Through Silicon Diode Detectors

Kacper Biłko, Rubén García Alía, Mario Sacristán Barbero, Sylvain Girard, Ygor Quadros de Aguiar, Matteo Cecchetto, C. Bélanger-Champagne, Salvatore Danzeca, Wojtek Hajdas, Alex Hands, Pedro Martín‐Holgado, Yolanda Morilla, Amor Romero-Maestre, Daniel Prelipcean, Federico Ravotti, Marc SebbanIEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully repurposed commercial silicon PIPS diodes to characterize the complex, "mixed-field" radiation environments found in high-energy accelerators like CERN’s LHC. By combining these sensors with fast acquisition electronics, the team demonstrated a versatile tool capable of measuring everything from single-particle energy depositions to overall dose rates and beam time profiles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-energy particle accelerators are harsh environments. When primary beams (like protons) hit targets or beam pipes, they create a "mixed-field" of secondary radiation—a chaotic soup of protons, neutrons, pions, and photons. This radiation is the primary cause of electronic failure in accelerator infrastructure.

To ensure new components are "radiation-hard," engineers test them at facilities like CERN’s CHARM, which mimics these mixed fields. However, accurately monitoring these fields in real-time is difficult. Standard dosimeters often lack the temporal resolution to see individual particle interactions, while specialized beam monitors can be bulky or expensive. There is a need for a compact, fast, and commercially available detector that can provide both high-level dosimetry and granular particle-level data.

Methods

The authors utilized Canberra FD 50-14-300RM silicon diode detectors (300 µm thick) paired with a high-speed acquisition chain (CIVIDEC preamplifiers and a CAEN 1GS/s digitizer).

The methodology followed three main stages:

  1. Calibration: The detectors were calibrated at the CNA facility in Spain using proton and alpha beams to establish an energy deposition scale ($k$-factor) and a Cobalt-60 source to correlate leakage current with dose rate.
  2. Direct Characterization: The setup was tested with high-energy proton beams at PSI and TRIUMF to see how well it resolved direct beam interactions.
  3. Indirect (Mixed-Field) Characterization: The detectors were placed in the CHARM facility at CERN. Here, they weren't hit by the primary beam but by the secondary "spallation" products. The results were compared against FLUKA Monte Carlo simulations and standard CERN monitors (RadMON and RPL dosimeters).

Datasets

While the paper doesn't use a "dataset" in the machine-learning sense, it relies on several experimental benchmarks:

  • Calibration Data: Proton/alpha energy spectra from the 3MV Tandem accelerator at CNA.
  • Facility Benchmarks: Comparative data from the RadMON (Radiation Monitoring) system and RPL (Radio-Photo-Luminescence) dosimeters at CERN.
  • Simulation Data: High-fidelity particle transport simulations using the FLUKA code, which served as the "ground truth" for the expected particle spectra in the CHARM facility.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Punch-Through" Signature: For a 300 µm silicon detector, the maximum energy a proton can deposit via direct ionization is roughly 6 MeV. In the energy spectra, this creates a distinct "step." Particles depositing more than this are likely undergoing nuclear reactions or are different species. This step acts as a convenient, "built-in" calibration point in the field.
  • Dual-Mode Utility: The system can operate in two modes simultaneously:
  • Event-by-event: Counting individual hits to determine flux and particle species (useful at lower intensities).
  • Current-mode: Measuring leakage current to determine the total dose rate (essential when the beam is too intense for individual counting).
  • The Case Effect: The diode's metal casing is a double-edged sword. It helps achieve "electron equilibrium" for more accurate gamma dosimetry, but it also partially shields the silicon, creating a ~70% uncertainty in absolute flux measurements unless the beam's ability to penetrate the case is known.
  • Pulse Shape Discrimination (PSD): By looking at the "falling time" of the signal, the researchers could distinguish between protons that stopped in the silicon versus those that punched through, a technique highly useful for identifying contaminants in heavy-ion beams.

Key Results

  • Accuracy: In the CHARM mixed-field, the diode’s Total Ionizing Dose (TID) measurements were within 10% of the RPL dosimeters and 25% of the RadMON system.
  • Simulation Alignment: There was "very good agreement" between the measured energy deposition spectra and the FLUKA simulations at the G0 testing position.
  • Time Profiling: The diode successfully resolved the primary beam's "spill" profile (how the beam intensity varies over milliseconds) by monitoring the secondary field, matching the performance of much more expensive dedicated beam transformers.
  • Dose Rate: The system demonstrated a linear response to dose rates up to 8 mGy(Si)/s.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bandwidth Bottleneck: The current setup is limited by the USB 2.0 link between the digitizer and the PC, capping the event rate at about 30 kHz. This leads to "buffer saturation" in high-intensity environments.
  • Geometric Uncertainty: The exact active volume of the silicon under the metal case remains an estimate (0.75–0.85 cm²), which limits absolute flux accuracy.
  • Position Discrepancy: While the G0 position matched simulations well, the 'm5' position showed discrepancies, likely due to the simplified 2-step simulation approach which ignored the directionality of the radiation field.
  • Future Direction: The authors suggest this setup will be a "complementary instrument" for future CERN monitoring, potentially moving toward permanent installation in accelerator tunnels.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a calibration of a commercial silicon diode with proton and alpha beams and gamma rays. The diode together with a fast acquisition chain can be exploited for both direct and indirect (through the secondary radiation field) beam characterization. Within this work, we demonstrate the detector capabilities of resolving single-energy-deposition events and independently measuring dose rate and beam flux. Profiting from the mixed radiation field in CERN’s high-energy accelerator mixed field facility (CHARM) we show how the silicon detector can be exploited to characterize the mixed radiation field present in it, which in turn is used for validating the radiation tolerance of components and systems to be installed in the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) accelerator complex.
BibTeX
@article{biko2024mixed,
  author = {Kacper Biłko and Rubén García Alía and Mario Sacristán Barbero and Sylvain Girard and Ygor Quadros de Aguiar and Matteo Cecchetto and C. Bélanger-Champagne and Salvatore Danzeca and Wojtek Hajdas and Alex Hands and Pedro Martín‐Holgado and Yolanda Morilla and Amor Romero-Maestre and Daniel Prelipcean and Federico Ravotti and Marc Sebban},
  title = {{Mixed-Field Radiation Monitoring and Beam Characterization Through Silicon Diode Detectors}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tns.2024.3350342},
}
Figure