Mitochondrial somatic mutations and the lack of viral genomic variation in recurrent respiratory papillomatosis

Yuhan Hao, Ryan Ruiz, Liying Yang, Antonio Galvao Neto, Milan R. Amin, Dervla Kelly, Stratos Achlatis, Scott A. Roof, Renjie Bing, Kasthuri Kannan, Stuart M. Brown, Zhiheng Pei, Ryan C. BranskiScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates Recurrent Respiratory Papillomatosis (RRP), a rare HPV-driven disease, by analyzing oral rinses and tissue samples from patients. They found persistent oral HPV infection and identified novel HPV6 strains, suggesting a stable viral genome. Crucially, they discovered somatic mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations in RRP tissue, offering new insights into disease mechanisms and potential therapeutic targets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Recurrent Respiratory Papillomatosis (RRP) is a debilitating disease characterized by the growth of benign tumors in the airway, caused by the Human Papillomavirus (HPV). Current treatments are largely symptomatic, highlighting a significant need for a deeper understanding of the disease's underlying biology to develop more effective therapies. While HPV is known to cause RRP, the persistence of oral HPV infection and the specific viral genomic characteristics in RRP patients, as well as potential host-cell contributions to the disease, remain areas requiring further investigation. This paper aims to shed light on these aspects by exploring viral genomic stability and host cell mitochondrial mutations in RRP.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Oral HPV Detection: Multiplex PCR was used to detect HPV in oral rinses collected from 23 adult-onset RRP patients over a 12-month period, with samples taken every three months.
  • HPV Subtype Concordance: For a subset of patients, oral rinse samples were compared to laryngeal tissue samples using a novel method called HPViewer. This allowed for the determination of HPV subtype concordance between the oral cavity and the affected tissue.
  • Metagenomic Sequencing: Paired-end metagenomic sequencing was performed on both oral rinse and RRP tissue samples to analyze HPV genomes at a deeper level, enabling the reconstruction of complete HPV genomes and the identification of novel strains.
  • mtDNA Mutation Analysis: Somatic heteroplasmic mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations were identified in RRP tissue samples by comparing them to matched oral rinse samples to distinguish somatic mutations from germline variations.

Datasets

  • Patient Samples: Oral rinses and laryngeal tissue samples from 23 adult-onset RRP patients.
  • HPV Genome Databases: Publicly available HPV genome sequences from GenBank and the PaVE database were used for phylogenetic analysis and comparison with reconstructed HPV genomes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Persistent Oral HPV Infection: The study confirms that a high percentage of RRP patients harbor persistent oral HPV infections, with many remaining positive for HPV in their oral rinses for up to 12 months. This suggests that the oral cavity may serve as a reservoir or a site of continuous shedding for the virus.
  • Stable Viral Genome: Despite the chronic nature of RRP, the HPV genomes found in RRP lesions appear to be remarkably stable, with little genomic variation observed. This contrasts with other viruses that undergo rapid mutation to evade host immunity, suggesting that host susceptibility, rather than viral evolution, might be a key factor in RRP pathogenesis.
  • Novel HPV6 Strains: The researchers successfully reconstructed three novel HPV6 strains from RRP tissue samples. These strains exhibited distinct genetic variations from previously known HPV6 sequences, indicating ongoing viral evolution or adaptation within the RRP context.
  • Mitochondrial Dysfunction in RRP: A significant finding is the discovery of somatic heteroplasmic mtDNA mutations in RRP tissue. This is the first report of such mutations in RRP and suggests that mitochondrial dysfunction may play a role in the development or progression of the disease. The identification of two nonsynonymous mutations (A336T in COI and G215D in ND5) that have not been previously reported is particularly noteworthy.

Key Results

  • High Oral HPV Positivity: 95.6% of RRP patients had an initial positive oral rinse for HPV, and 77.2% had at least one additional positive rinse within 12 months.
  • Dominant HPV in Tissue: RRP tissue samples consistently showed a single dominant HPV strain, with multiple HPV copies (60-787 per human cell) detected.
  • Identical HPV in Rinse and Tissue: In two patients, HPV strains found at very low levels in oral rinses were identical to those found in their RRP tissue samples, suggesting potential concordance.
  • Novel HPV6 Isolates: Three novel HPV6 isolates were identified and reconstructed from RRP tissue.
  • Somatic mtDNA Mutations: An average of 1.8 somatic heteroplasmic mtDNA mutations per RRP tissue sample were observed, with two of these being nonsynonymous.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Qualitative PCR: The study acknowledges that the qualitative nature of the initial PCR for oral rinses limits the ability to definitively distinguish between persistent infection with the same genotype and new infections with different genotypes.
  • Limited Control Data: The study did not include analysis of control oral rinses, relying instead on comparisons with previously published data on oral HPV prevalence in the general population.
  • Shotgun Sequencing Sensitivity: The sensitivity of shotgun sequencing for detecting sparse HPV DNA in oral rinses was limited by the overabundance of human DNA. Future work could explore methods like host DNA depletion to improve HPV detection sensitivity.
  • Mitochondrial Mutation Function: While novel mtDNA mutations were identified, their precise functional impact on RRP pathogenesis requires further investigation. The authors hypothesize that these mutations could lead to mitochondrial dysfunction, but direct evidence is needed.
  • Therapeutic Targets: The identification of novel HPV strains and potential host cell mitochondrial involvement opens avenues for future research into targeted therapies for RRP. Further studies are needed to explore the clinical relevance of these findings and their potential as therapeutic targets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recurrent Respiratory Papillomatosis (RRP) is a rare disease of the aerodigestive tract caused by the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) that manifests as profoundly altered phonatory and upper respiratory anatomy. Current therapies are primarily symptomatic; enhanced insight regarding disease-specific biology of RRP is critical to improved therapeutics for this challenging population. Multiplex PCR was performed on oral rinses collected from twenty-three patients with adult-onset RRP every three months for one year. Twenty-two (95.6%) subjects had an initial HPV positive oral rinse. Of those subjects, 77.2% had an additional positive oral rinse over 12 months. A subset of rinses were then compared to tissue samples in the same patient employing HPViewer to determine HPV subtype concordance. Multiple HPV copies (60-787 per human cell) were detected in RRP tissue in each patient, but a single dominant HPV was found in individual samples. These data confirm persistent oral HPV infection in the majority of patients with RRP. In addition, three novel HPV6 isolates were found and identical HPV strains, at very low levels, were identified in oral rinses in two patients suggesting potential HPV subtype concordance. Finally, somatic heteroplasmic mtDNA mutations were observed in RRP tissue with 1.8 mutations per sample and two nonsynonymous variants. These data provide foundational insight into both the underlying pathophysiology of RRP, but also potential targets for intervention in this challenging patient cohort.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2019mitochondrial,
  author = {Yuhan Hao and Ryan Ruiz and Liying Yang and Antonio Galvao Neto and Milan R. Amin and Dervla Kelly and Stratos Achlatis and Scott A. Roof and Renjie Bing and Kasthuri Kannan and Stuart M. Brown and Zhiheng Pei and Ryan C. Branski},
  title = {{Mitochondrial somatic mutations and the lack of viral genomic variation in recurrent respiratory papillomatosis}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-53148-8},
}
Figure