(MIS3 & 2) millennial oscillations in Greenland dust and Eurasian aeolian records – A paleosol perspective

Denis‐Didier Rousseau, Niklas Boers, Adriana Sima, Anders Svensson, Matthias Bigler, France Lagroix, Samuel N. Taylor, Pierre AntoineQuaternary 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study bridges the gap between Greenland ice core records and European paleosol development during the last glacial period. By meticulously comparing high-resolution ice core data with terrestrial loess records, the authors provide a more precise understanding of the timing and duration of abrupt climate shifts (Greenland Interstadials) and their impact on soil formation in mid-latitude Europe. This work refines our ability to correlate past climate events across different archives, crucial for reconstructing Earth's climate history.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding past abrupt climate changes, particularly those occurring during the last glacial period (MIS3 and MIS2, roughly 60,000 to 15,000 years ago), is critical for predicting future climate behavior. Greenland ice cores provide high-resolution records of these events, known as Dansgaard-Oeschger (D-O) cycles, characterized by rapid warming (Greenland Interstadials, GIs) and cooling (Greenland Stadials, GSs). While these ice core records are well-established, correlating them precisely with terrestrial records, such as European paleosols (fossil soils preserved in loess deposits), has been challenging. Paleosols offer insights into local environmental conditions, including soil development, which is directly influenced by climate. However, the dating and interpretation of these soil horizons have often lacked the temporal resolution and precision to definitively link them to specific GIs. This paper aims to resolve this by establishing a robust correlation between Greenland ice core GIs and the development of paleosols in European loess sequences, thereby refining our understanding of the duration and impact of these abrupt climate shifts.

Methods

The study employs a multi-pronged approach to correlate Greenland ice core data with European paleosol records:

  • High-Resolution Ice Core Analysis: The authors utilize high-resolution data from the North Greenland Ice Core Project (NGRIP) ice core, specifically focusing on oxygen isotope ratios ($\delta^{18}$O) and dust concentration. These proxies represent temperature and atmospheric dustiness in Greenland, respectively.
  • Visual and Algorithmic Identification of GIs: Greenland Interstadials (GIs) are identified in both the $\delta^{18}$O and dust records using two methods:
  • Visual Determination: GIs are identified by the beginning of an abrupt $\delta^{18}$O increase or dust concentration decrease, and their end is marked by the return to pre-transition values.
  • Algorithmic Detection: A more robust algorithm is developed to detect transitions by analyzing the derivative of the time series, identifying local maxima above a certain percentile. This method aims to provide a more objective and reproducible identification of GI start and end dates.
  • Paleosol Stratigraphy and Correlation: The study leverages detailed stratigraphies of European loess sequences, particularly from the Nussloch site, which are known to preserve a record of alternating paleosols and loess layers corresponding to GIs and GSs.
  • Duration Estimation: The duration of GIs is estimated from both the $\delta^{18}$O and dust records, using both visual and algorithmic methods. This allows for a comparison of durations derived from different proxies and methodologies.
  • Paleosol Development and GI Duration Link: The core of the study involves correlating the identified GIs with the types and development stages of paleosols observed in the European loess sequences. The duration of a GI is interpreted as the maximum time available for soil development.

Datasets

  • NGRIP Ice Core Data: High-resolution $\delta^{18}$O and dust concentration records from the North Greenland Ice Core Project (NGRIP). These data are based on the GICC05 multi-core multi-parameter layer-counted age scale.
  • European Loess-Paleosol Sequences: Stratigraphic data from key European loess sites, with a particular focus on the Nussloch sequence in Germany, which has been extensively studied and dated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precise GI Timing: The high-resolution NGRIP data, analyzed with both visual and algorithmic methods, allows for a more precise determination of GI start and end dates than previously possible.
  • Two Categories of GIs: The study suggests that GIs can be broadly categorized based on their duration: shorter GIs (200-1200 years) and longer GIs (1800-4000+ years). This aligns with interpretations of soil diagnostic features that are reversible versus irreversible.
  • Synchronous Transitions: The study highlights that transitions between stadial and interstadial conditions (the onset of GIs) in both Greenland $\delta^{18}$O and dust records occur within a similar, abrupt timeframe (around 30-90 years).
  • Paleosol Development as a Climate Proxy: The type and development of European paleosols are directly linked to the duration of GIs, providing a terrestrial confirmation of the climate shifts recorded in ice cores. Brown arctic soils, for instance, indicate longer GIs, allowing for more extensive soil development.
  • Refined Correlation: The study establishes a strong correlation between Greenland Interstadials and European paleosol succession, improving our ability to synchronize climate events across different geographical regions and archives.

Key Results

  • GI Durations: Visually determined GI durations range from 200 to 4200 years, while algorithmically determined durations range from 200 to 4800 years for the interval 60-23 ka b2k.
  • Transition Durations: The abrupt transitions between stadial and interstadial conditions are found to be very rapid, with durations averaging 55.4±16.1 years (visual, $\delta^{18}$O) and 36.4±13.4 years (algorithmic, $\delta^{18}$O).
  • Temperature Increase: The $\delta^{18}$O increases during GIs correspond to a mean temperature difference of approximately 11.8°C on the Greenland ice sheet.
  • Paleosol Types and Durations:
    • Tundra gleys and oxidized horizons correspond to shorter maximum development durations (100-1000 years).
  • Brown arctic soils indicate longer GI intervals, with maximum development durations ranging from 1600 to 4200 years (visually determined) and 1700 to 4800 years (algorithmically determined).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Objectivity of Visual Determination: The authors acknowledge potential objections regarding the objectivity of visual determination of interval boundaries in the NGRIP records, which motivated the development of the algorithmic approach.
  • Complexity of Records: The high-resolution nature of the NGRIP data makes a simple correlation strategy (e.g., using lowest dust deposition as a proxy for soil development start) challenging and prone to overinterpretation.
  • Uncertainty in Dust Deposition Resumption: Determining the exact timing of the resumption of eolian dust deposition in Europe after a GI is complex and not definitively resolved by this study. The authors adopt a conservative approach by considering the end of the interstadial as the conventional restart point.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further work is needed to quantify the re-mineralization processes observed in tundra gley units, which could further support the correlation with GIs of variable duration. Additionally, the study highlights the need for more sophisticated methods to address the complex issue of precisely dating the end of paleosol development and the start of subsequent eolian deposition.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{rousseau2017mis,
  author = {Denis‐Didier Rousseau and Niklas Boers and Adriana Sima and Anders Svensson and Matthias Bigler and France Lagroix and Samuel N. Taylor and Pierre Antoine},
  title = {{(MIS3 \& 2) millennial oscillations in Greenland dust and Eurasian aeolian records – A paleosol perspective}},
  booktitle = {Quaternary},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.quascirev.2017.05.020},
}
Figure