Mirror-enhanced scanning light-field microscopy for long-term high-speed 3D imaging with isotropic resolution

Bo Xiong, Tianyi Zhu, Yuhan Xiang, Xiaopeng Li, Jinqiang Yu, Zheng Jiang, Yihan Niu, Dong Jiang, Xu Zhang, Lu Fang, Jiamin Wu, Qionghai DaiLight 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Mirror-Enhanced Scanning Light-Field Microscopy (MiSLFM), a novel technique that significantly improves axial resolution in 3D live-cell imaging. By incorporating a tilted mirror below the sample, MiSLFM effectively overcomes the "missing-cone" problem inherent in traditional Light-Field Microscopy, enabling high-speed, low-phototoxicity 3D imaging with near-isotropic resolution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Observing dynamic biological processes within cells in 3D at high speeds and over extended periods is crucial for understanding fundamental life mechanisms. Current microscopy techniques often struggle to balance these requirements. While Light-Field Microscopy (LFM) offers a compact way to capture 3D information simultaneously, it suffers from a significant limitation: the "missing-cone" problem. This leads to poor axial (depth) resolution, making it difficult to accurately discern fine structures and track dynamic events in the z-axis. This degraded axial resolution hinders detailed analysis of intercellular and organelle interactions and can lead to artifacts in reconstructions. Existing solutions to improve axial resolution often come with trade-offs in speed, complexity, or phototoxicity, limiting their applicability for long-term, high-speed live-cell imaging.

Methods

The core innovation of MiSLFM lies in its ingenious use of a tilted mirror placed beneath the sample. This setup allows the microscope to capture two views of the sample simultaneously: the direct view and a mirror-reflected view. This effectively creates a "multiplexed" light-field image. The system then employs a phase-space deconvolution algorithm, enhanced with a symmetry constraint derived from the direct and mirror images. This constraint helps to fill in the missing information in the Fourier domain, thereby improving the axial resolution.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Mirror Integration: A simple, tilted mirror is added below the sample, leveraging the extended depth of field of LFM.
  • Phase-Space Deconvolution with Symmetry Constraint: This algorithm reconstructs the 3D volume by utilizing the relationship between the direct and mirror images, effectively compensating for the missing angular information.
  • Mirror Estimation: The system includes a step to estimate the mirror's position, crucial for accurate reconstruction.
  • Scanning LFM (sLFM) Foundation: MiSLFM builds upon the principles of scanning LFM, which already offers improved resolution by scanning the image plane.

Datasets

The paper does not discuss datasets used for training. Instead, it focuses on evaluating the performance of MiSLFM using various biological samples and imaging scenarios. These include:

  • Fixed L929 cells: Used to demonstrate the improvement in axial resolution compared to sLFM.
  • NRK live cells: Used for two-color imaging to visualize cell membrane and mitochondria dynamics.
  • B16-GFP cells: Used for long-term imaging to assess photobleaching and phototoxicity.
  • Dictyostelium discoideum: Used to demonstrate robustness in imaging fast-moving, photosensitive samples.
  • Zebrafish larvae: Used for in vivo imaging of blood flow and cell tracking.

The paper also utilizes simulated data of spheres to quantitatively analyze axial resolution improvements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Missing Cone" is Solvable with Simple Optics: The paper elegantly demonstrates that a seemingly simple addition of a tilted mirror can significantly address a fundamental limitation in LFM, showcasing the power of clever optical design.
  • Symmetry is a Powerful Reconstruction Constraint: By exploiting the inherent symmetry between the direct and reflected views, the reconstruction algorithm can effectively "fill in" missing information, leading to substantial axial resolution gains.
  • Low Phototoxicity is Key for Long-Term Observation: The ability to image with extremely low light levels, a hallmark of LFM and further enhanced by MiSLFM's efficiency, is critical for observing natural biological behaviors without perturbation.
  • Near-Isotropic Resolution is Achievable: The combination of LFM's capabilities and the mirror enhancement allows for resolution that is nearly equal in all three dimensions, a significant leap for 3D imaging.

Key Results

  • Substantial Axial Resolution Improvement: MiSLFM achieved an axial resolution of approximately 0.4 µm, a threefold improvement compared to sLFM's ~1.5 µm axial resolution with a 40x/0.8NA objective.
  • Near-Isotropic Resolution: The system achieved near-isotropic resolution of ~400 nm.
  • High-Speed 3D Imaging: MiSLFM supports high-speed 3D imaging at rates of up to 2 Hz (NRK cells) and 18 Hz (zebrafish larvae).
  • Low Phototoxicity and Photobleaching: Long-term imaging experiments (up to 14 hours) showed minimal photobleaching (around 10% for cell membranes) and excellent cell viability, significantly outperforming traditional confocal microscopy.
  • Robust Tracking of Fast-Moving Samples: The method demonstrated successful imaging and tracking of fast-moving Dictyostelium discoideum and blood cells in zebrafish larvae.
  • Improved Visualization of Biological Interactions: MiSLFM enabled clearer visualization of intercellular contacts and organelle interactions that were obscured in sLFM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Field of View Trade-off: The paper acknowledges that MiSLFM sacrifices some of the field of view (FoV) to obtain the mirror image and improve axial resolution.
  • Resolution Decrease at FoV Edges: The resolution may decrease when the sample is located near the edge of the FoV.
  • Angle Dependence: While a 45° mirror angle achieved isotropic resolution, other angles might result in slightly worse axial resolution compared to lateral resolution.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that a tilted imaging framework could be developed in the future to simplify sample preparation. They also envision MiSLFM as a compact add-on for existing upright wide-field fluorescence microscopes, facilitating advanced imaging capabilities for a broad range of biological applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Various biological behaviors can only be observed in 3D at high speed over the long term with low phototoxicity. Light-field microscopy (LFM) provides an elegant compact solution to record 3D information in a tomographic manner simultaneously, which can facilitate high photon efficiency. However, LFM still suffers from the missing-cone problem, leading to degraded axial resolution and ringing effects after deconvolution. Here, we propose a mirror-enhanced scanning LFM (MiSLFM) to achieve long-term high-speed 3D imaging at super-resolved axial resolution with a single objective, by fully exploiting the extended depth of field of LFM with a tilted mirror placed below samples. To establish the unique capabilities of MiSLFM, we performed extensive experiments, we observed various organelle interactions and intercellular interactions in different types of photosensitive cells under extremely low light conditions. Moreover, we demonstrated that superior axial resolution facilitates more robust blood cell tracking in zebrafish larvae at high speed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiong2021mirror,
  author = {Bo Xiong and Tianyi Zhu and Yuhan Xiang and Xiaopeng Li and Jinqiang Yu and Zheng Jiang and Yihan Niu and Dong Jiang and Xu Zhang and Lu Fang and Jiamin Wu and Qionghai Dai},
  title = {{Mirror-enhanced scanning light-field microscopy for long-term high-speed 3D imaging with isotropic resolution}},
  booktitle = {Light},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41377-021-00665-9},
}
Figure