Mining Candidate Genes for Maize Tassel Spindle Length Based on a Genome-Wide Association Analysis

Xudong Cao, Han Lu, Zhiwen Zhao, Yujie Lian, Hui Chen, Yu Min, Fan Wang, Huayue Sun, Dong Ding, Xuehai Zhang, Chen Xiao-yang, Jihua TangGenes 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies a key gene, Zm00001d042312, that regulates maize tassel spindle length, a trait crucial for yield. By combining genome-wide association studies (GWAS) with gene expression and haplotype analyses, the researchers pinpoint this gene's role in plant hormone signaling and its high expression in tassels, offering valuable targets for maize breeding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maize is a vital global crop, and its yield is significantly influenced by various traits, including the architecture of its tassel. The tassel spindle length, specifically, is important because it affects pollen production and shedding duration, which in turn impacts fertilization success and ultimately, grain yield. Furthermore, tassel development can be sensitive to environmental stressors. Understanding the genetic underpinnings of tassel spindle length is therefore critical for improving maize productivity and resilience. While previous studies have identified quantitative trait loci (QTLs) associated with tassel traits, the specific genes responsible have often remained elusive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using a genome-wide association study (GWAS) to pinpoint candidate genes that control maize tassel spindle length.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS): They utilized a dataset of 182 maize inbred lines genotyped with over 1.25 million single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers. A GWAS was performed using the Q+K model, which accounts for population structure and kinship, to identify SNPs significantly associated with tassel spindle length. A stringent significance threshold (p < 1.0 × 10⁻⁴) was applied.
  • Co-localization Analysis: Significant SNPs were used to define quantitative trait loci (QTLs). The study then identified QTLs that were consistently detected across multiple environments or in different populations, indicating robustness.
  • Candidate Gene Identification: Genes located within 30 kb upstream and downstream of significant SNPs within co-localized QTLs were considered candidate genes.
  • KEGG Enrichment Analysis: This analysis was used to understand the biological pathways that the candidate genes are involved in.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: The expression levels of candidate genes were examined in different maize tassel developmental stages (immature and meiotic) to identify genes that are actively expressed in the relevant tissue.
  • Haplotype Analysis: For the most promising candidate gene, a haplotype analysis was conducted to identify different genetic variations (haplotypes) and assess their association with tassel spindle length.

Datasets

  • Maize Inbred Lines: 182 maize inbred lines were used for the association population.
  • Genotypic Data: High-quality SNP marker data (1,253,814 markers) covering the entire maize genome was utilized. This data was obtained from Professor Yan Jianbing's laboratory at Huazhong Agricultural University.
  • Phenotypic Data: Tassel spindle length measurements were collected from the 182 inbred lines across three different experimental locations (Yuanyang, Hebi, and Tieling) in 2023.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tassel Spindle Length is Highly Heritable: The study found a broad-sense heritability of 0.89 for tassel spindle length, confirming that genetic factors play a dominant role in determining this trait. This high heritability makes it a good target for genetic improvement.
  • GWAS is Powerful for Identifying Complex Traits: The application of GWAS, particularly with the Q+K model, effectively identified numerous significant SNPs and QTLs associated with tassel spindle length, demonstrating its utility for dissecting complex quantitative traits.
  • Co-localization Pinpoints Robust Genetic Loci: Identifying QTLs that co-localize across multiple environments or populations increases confidence in their association with the trait and reduces the likelihood of false positives.
  • Plant Hormone Signaling is Key: The KEGG enrichment analysis highlighted "Plant Hormone Signal Transduction" as a significantly enriched pathway among candidate genes. This aligns with existing knowledge about the role of hormones in plant development.
  • A Specific Histidine Kinase is a Strong Candidate: The gene Zm00001d042312 emerged as a prime candidate due to its high expression in maize tassels and its involvement in plant hormone signaling. Its homology to known cytokinin receptors in other species strengthens this hypothesis.
  • Haplotype Variation Explains Phenotypic Differences: The significant differences observed in tassel spindle length between different haplotypes of Zm00001d042312 provide strong evidence for its functional role in regulating this trait.

Key Results

  • 240 Significant SNPs and 99 QTLs: The GWAS identified 240 SNPs significantly associated with tassel spindle length, which were linked to 99 QTLs.
  • 21 Co-localized QTLs: Out of the 99 QTLs, 21 were detected in two or more environments, indicating their stability.
  • 51 Candidate Genes Identified: Within these co-localized QTLs, 51 candidate genes were identified.
  • Zm00001d042312 Identified as a Key Gene: This gene, encoding a histidine kinase, was found to be highly expressed in maize tassels and significantly associated with tassel spindle length.
  • Three Haplotypes for Zm00001d042312: Haplotype analysis revealed three distinct haplotypes, with significant differences in tassel spindle length observed between Hap1 and Hap2.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Candidate Gene Validation: While Zm00001d042312 is a strong candidate, its precise function and mechanism of action in regulating tassel spindle length require further experimental validation, likely through gene knockout or overexpression studies.
  • Environmental Interactions: Although the study considered multiple environments, the complex interplay between genotype and environment in shaping tassel spindle length could be further explored.
  • Broader Gene Network: The study focused on one key gene. Future work could investigate the broader gene network and regulatory pathways involved in tassel development.
  • Breeding Applications: The identified candidate genes and haplotypes offer potential for marker-assisted selection to accelerate maize breeding programs aimed at improving tassel architecture and yield.

Summary updated

Abstract

Maize tassel spindle length is closely related to the number of pollen grains and the duration of the flowering stage, ultimately affecting maize yield and adaptations to stress conditions. In this study, 182 maize inbred lines were included in an association population. A genome-wide association study was conducted on maize tassel spindle length using the Q + K model. With <i>p</i> ≤ 1.0 × 10<sup>-4</sup> applied as the significance threshold, 240 SNPs significantly associated with tassel spindle length were detected, which were associated with 99 quantitative trait loci (QTLs), with 21 QTLs detected in two or more environments. Moreover, 51 candidate genes were detected in 21 co-localized QTLs. A KEGG enrichment analysis and candidate gene expression analysis indicated that <i>Zm00001d042312</i> affects plant hormone signal transduction and is highly expressed in maize tassels. A haplotype analysis of <i>Zm00001d042312</i> revealed three main haplotypes, with significant differences between Hap1 and Hap2. In conclusion, we propose that <i>Zm00001d042312</i> is a gene that regulates maize tassel spindle length. This study has further elucidated the genetic basis of maize tassel spindle length, while also providing excellent genetic targets and germplasm resources for the genetic improvement of maize tassel spindle length and yield.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2024mining,
  author = {Xudong Cao and Han Lu and Zhiwen Zhao and Yujie Lian and Hui Chen and Yu Min and Fan Wang and Huayue Sun and Dong Ding and Xuehai Zhang and Chen Xiao-yang and Jihua Tang},
  title = {{Mining Candidate Genes for Maize Tassel Spindle Length Based on a Genome-Wide Association Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Genes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/genes15111413},
}
Figure