Mining bacterial NGS data vastly expands the complete genomes of temperate phages

Xianglilan Zhang, Ruohan Wang, Xiangcheng Xie, Yunjia Hu, Jianping Wang, Qiang Sun, Xikang Feng, Shanwei Tong, Yujun Cui, Mengyao Wang, Shixiang Zhai, Qi Niu, Fangyi Wang, Andrew M. Kropinski, Xiaofang Jiang, Shaoliang Peng, Shuai Cheng Li, Yigang TongbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel computational method to identify and assemble complete temperate phage genomes from bacterial NGS data, significantly expanding the known temperate phage genome database by over 100-fold. This advancement enables a deeper understanding of phage roles in bacterial evolution, gene transfer, and host interactions, with implications for phage therapy and microbiome research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Temperate phages, which can integrate into bacterial genomes as prophages, play crucial roles in bacterial pathogenicity, community structure, and gut homeostasis. However, their lysogenic nature makes them difficult to study using traditional methods like plaque assays. Existing computational tools for identifying prophages often struggle to accurately determine complete and intact temperate phage genomes. This limitation hinders research into phage biology, their impact on bacterial evolution, and their potential applications in areas like phage therapy.

Methods

The authors developed a novel computational method for identifying complete temperate phage genomes from bacterial NGS data. This method involves three main steps:

  1. NGS Data Processing: Quality control and filtering of raw NGS reads, followed by assembly into scaffolds using tools like Spades.
  2. Prophage Region Detection: Using GLIMMER to predict ORFs on bacterial scaffolds and BLASTp to align these ORFs against a phage protein database. They consider a broad range of phage genes (e.g., capsid, integrase) to maximize prophage region identification. DBSCAN clustering is then used to identify potential phage ORF clusters.
  3. Temperate Phage Detection: This step leverages the biological principles of temperate phage life cycles. A prophage is identified as a temperate phage if it can circularize. This is detected by identifying paired reads that match the ends of the precise prophage region, indicating replication in the lytic cycle. The method also accounts for the integration and induction mechanisms, using attL and attR sites as termini.

The reliability of their method was validated through wet-lab experiments, where induced temperate phages were sequenced and their genomes used as ground truth.

Datasets

The study utilized bacterial NGS data. Specifically, they downloaded 789,383 raw NGS host data sets from GenBank (March 2020) for analysis. For validation, they sequenced bacterial strains preserved in their laboratory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A New Era for Temperate Phage Genomics: The developed computational method is a significant leap forward, enabling the discovery of a vast number of complete temperate phage genomes that were previously inaccessible.
  • Temperate Phages as Drivers of Bacterial Evolution: The analysis reveals that temperate phages are not just passive passengers but active participants in bacterial evolution, mediating gene transfer (antibiotic resistance, virulence factors) and shaping host interactions through systems like restriction-modification and CRISPR/anti-CRISPR.
  • Complexity of Phage-Host Interactions: The study highlights the intricate web of interactions between temperate phages and their hosts, including cross-species infections and the sharing of genetic elements across diverse bacterial species and genera.
  • Phage Defense Systems are a Two-Way Street: The research shows that both bacteria and phages employ sophisticated defense mechanisms (RM systems, CRISPR-Cas, anti-CRISPRs), indicating a dynamic evolutionary arms race.

Key Results

  • The method identified 192,326 complete temperate phage genomes from bacterial NGS data.
  • This represents an over 100-fold expansion of the known complete temperate phage genome database.
  • The identified phages span 2,717 host species and 710 host genera.
  • The method accurately determines complete genome sequences with exact flanking sites (attP and attB), outperforming existing state-of-the-art prophage prediction methods.
  • Analysis revealed that temperate phages are involved in transferring antibiotic resistance and virulence genes, and interact with hosts via RM and CRISPR/anti-CRISPR systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While outperforming many tools, the method's consideration of sequence boundaries and reliance on raw NGS reads for circulation detection requires more memory space (~700MB) compared to some other offline tools.
  • Database Expansion: The study provides a comprehensive database, but the authors suggest it can serve as a valuable resource for further phage research, implying ongoing exploration and discovery.
  • Clinical Applications: The findings on antibiotic resistance and virulence genes carried by temperate phages in human gut metagenomes have implications for the safety of fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT), suggesting that this aspect warrants further consideration in clinical applications.
  • Phage Therapy Potential: The study identified temperate phages that can be converted into virulent phages, suggesting potential applications in developing phage therapy for difficult-to-treat infections.

Summary updated

Abstract

Temperate phages (active prophages induced from bacteria) help control pathogenicity, modulate community structure, and maintain gut homeostasis 1 . Complete phage genome sequences are indispensable for understanding phage biology. Traditional plaque techniques are inapplicable to temperate phages due to the lysogenicity of these phages, which curb the identification and characterization of temperate phages. Existing in silico tools for prophage prediction usually fail to detect accurate and complete temperate phage genomes 2–5 . In this study, by a novel computational method mining both the integrated active prophages and their spontaneously induced forms (temperate phages), we obtained 192,326 complete temperate phage genomes from bacterial next-generation sequencing (NGS) data, hence expanded the existing number of complete temperate phage genomes by more than 100-fold. The reliability of our method was validated by wet-lab experiments. The experiments demonstrated that our method can accurately determine the complete genome sequences of the temperate phages, with exact flanking sites ( attP and attB sites), outperforming other state-of-the-art prophage prediction methods. Our analysis indicates that temperate phages are likely to function in the evolution of microbes by 1) cross-infecting different bacterial host species; 2) transferring antibiotic resistance and virulence genes; and 3) interacting with hosts through restriction-modification and CRISPR/anti-CRISPR systems. This work provides a comprehensive complete temperate phage genome database and relevant information, which can serve as a valuable resource for phage research.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2021mining,
  author = {Xianglilan Zhang and Ruohan Wang and Xiangcheng Xie and Yunjia Hu and Jianping Wang and Qiang Sun and Xikang Feng and Shanwei Tong and Yujun Cui and Mengyao Wang and Shixiang Zhai and Qi Niu and Fangyi Wang and Andrew M. Kropinski and Xiaofang Jiang and Shaoliang Peng and Shuai Cheng Li and Yigang Tong},
  title = {{Mining bacterial NGS data vastly expands the complete genomes of temperate phages}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.07.15.452192},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure