Minimizing Expected Losses in Perturbation Models with Multidimensional Parametric Min-cuts

Adrian Kim, Kyomin Jung, Yongsub Lim, Daniel Tarlow, Pushmeet KohliUAI 2015 · OpenReview

Minimizing Expected Losses in Perturbation Models with Multidimensional Parametric Min-cuts

Abstract

Training perturbation-based models for structured prediction typically involves minimizing an expected loss function, a task often plagued by high-variance gradients and slow convergence when using Monte Carlo sampling. This paper introduces the Skeleton Method, a deterministic approach that utilizes multidimensional parametric min-cuts to partition the parameter space into convex polytopes. By calculating the volumes of these regions, the method provides an exact or highly accurate estimation of expected loss. Furthermore, a "Slicing" technique is proposed for stable gradient estimation. Experiments on image segmentation demonstrate that the Skeleton Method achieves significantly faster convergence and superior performance compared to traditional sampling-based baselines.

Introduction

In structured prediction tasks, such as image segmentation, perturbation models offer a robust framework by adding noise to model parameters and identifying the Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) solution. The primary challenge in training these models lies in minimizing the expected loss across all noise realizations. This requires integrating over high-dimensional spaces, a process traditionally handled by Monte Carlo sampling. However, sampling-based methods often suffer from high variance, leading to unstable gradients and slow optimization.

The Skeleton Method

The authors propose the Skeleton Method as a geometric alternative to stochastic sampling. The core insight is that the parameter space can be viewed as a collection of convex polytopes, where each polytope corresponds to a specific optimal output configuration.

The Skeleton Method iteratively refines the partition of the parameter space. (a) Initial partition. (b) Finding a new optimal solution to refine the region. (c) The updated partition with a new region.

As shown in Figure 1, the algorithm represents the dual function as a piecewise concave surface. It starts with a coarse approximation and iteratively refines this "Skeleton" by identifying new optimal solutions that "cut" the space. Once the partition is sufficiently refined, the probability of any output is determined by the volume of its corresponding polytope, allowing for precise loss calculation regardless of the specific loss function used (e.g., Hamming loss or boundary-only loss).

Gradient Estimation via Slicing

To optimize the model, stable gradients are required. The authors introduce Slicing, a finite-differencing technique. Instead of re-evaluating the entire parameter space, Slicing focuses on the thin regions at the boundaries of the polytopes where the optimal output changes. This approach significantly reduces computational overhead and provides much smoother gradient estimates than REINFORCE-style sampling, which often struggles with the "middle" of parameter regions that do not change under slight perturbations.

Experimental Results

The method was evaluated on a foreground-background segmentation task using the Berkeley image segmentation dataset. The objective was to learn parameters for a submodular energy function, a standard setup for min-cut problems.

Comparison of Expected Loss vs. Runtime. The Skeleton Method (pink) converges to a stable estimate in seconds, while Monte Carlo sampling (blue/green lines) remains highly variable even after 1000 seconds.

The results, illustrated in Figure 2, highlight the efficiency of the Skeleton Method. While Monte Carlo sampling exhibited significant variance even after 1000 seconds of runtime, the Skeleton Method converged to an accurate estimate in approximately 10 seconds. Empirically, the Slicing variant achieved a lower expected Hamming loss (2.048) than the Perturb-and-MAP baseline (2.186) and demonstrated the flexibility to handle complex, non-standard loss functions like "Boundary-only Pixel Loss."

Conclusion and Future Work

The Skeleton Method provides a powerful, deterministic framework for minimizing expected losses in perturbation models. By replacing randomness with geometry, it offers superior stability and speed. While currently limited by the "curse of dimensionality"—as computing polytope volumes becomes exponentially harder as the number of parameters increases—future research into hybrid Rao-Blackwellized samplers and upper-bounding techniques for high-dimensional spaces promises to extend the reach of this combinatorial approach.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2015minimizing,
  author = {Adrian Kim and Kyomin Jung and Yongsub Lim and Daniel Tarlow and Pushmeet Kohli},
  title = {{Minimizing Expected Losses in Perturbation Models with Multidimensional Parametric Min-cuts}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=SxEqUcKT-5},
}
Figure