Minimized Volume Expansion in Hierarchical Porous Silicon upon Lithiation

Fang Dai, Ran Yi, Hui Yang, Yuming Zhao, Langli Luo, Mikhail L. Gordin, Hiesang Sohn, Shuru Chen, Chongmin Wang, Sulin Zhang, Donghai WangACS 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a hierarchical porous silicon (hp-Si) material with tunable pore sizes that significantly minimizes the volume expansion during lithium-ion battery cycling. This innovation, validated by in situ TEM and chemomechanical modeling, promises to overcome a major hurdle in using silicon as a high-capacity anode, leading to more stable and durable next-generation batteries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Silicon is a highly attractive anode material for lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) due to its exceptionally high theoretical capacity and natural abundance. However, its practical application is severely hampered by a dramatic volume expansion (up to 400%) during lithiation (when it absorbs lithium ions). This massive volume change leads to mechanical stress, causing the silicon particles to pulverize, electrodes to degrade, and ultimately resulting in rapid capacity fading and poor cycling performance. This issue has been a critical bottleneck preventing silicon from realizing its full potential in high-energy-density LIBs.

Methods

The researchers synthesized hierarchical porous silicon (hp-Si) materials using a novel bottom-up wet synthesis route. This method involves using SiO2 nanoparticles as external templates for primary pores and salt by-products as internal templates for secondary pores. The key innovation lies in their ability to tune the size of these primary pores, creating two types of hp-Si: hp-Si-L (large primary pores, 20-200 nm) and hp-Si-S (small primary pores, ~20 nm), both with secondary nanopores (~3-10 nm).

To understand the volume expansion mechanism, they employed:

  • In situ Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): This technique allowed them to directly observe the lithiation process of individual hp-Si particles in real-time, visualizing how the porous structure accommodates volume changes.
  • Ex situ Characterization: Standard techniques like X-ray Diffraction (XRD), Raman spectroscopy, and BET surface area analysis were used to characterize the materials' structure and properties before and after cycling.
  • Electrochemical Measurements: Coin cells were assembled using the hp-Si materials as anodes and subjected to galvanostatic charge-discharge cycling and rate performance tests to evaluate their battery performance.
  • Chemomechanical Modeling: A computational model was developed to simulate the concurrent processes of phase transformation, stress generation, and morphological evolution within the porous silicon structure, providing insights into the role of pore size.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of novel materials and their electrochemical performance, rather than training on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Primary Pore Size is Crucial: While porosity is important, the size of the primary pores in hp-Si plays a more critical role in accommodating lithiation-induced volume expansion than previously thought. Larger primary pores are significantly more effective.
  • Inward Expansion Dominance: Chemomechanical modeling revealed that due to the differing stiffness of lithiated and unlithiated silicon, the reaction front tends to push inward, and larger pores can better accommodate this inward expansion.
  • Structural Integrity and SEI Formation: hp-Si with larger primary pores exhibits better structural preservation and more stable solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI) formation, which is vital for long-term cycling stability.
  • Hierarchical Structure Benefits: The combination of tunable primary pores and secondary nanopores in hp-Si offers a dual benefit: accommodating large-scale expansion and providing high surface area for electrochemical reactions.

Key Results

  • Minimized Volume Expansion: hp-Si-L (with larger primary pores) showed significantly less particle-level volume expansion compared to hp-Si-S during lithiation, as observed in in situ TEM.
  • Reduced Electrode Thickness Change: After 50 cycles, hp-Si-L electrodes experienced only a 16% thickness increase, comparable to commercial graphite electrodes, while hp-Si-S electrodes showed a much larger 47% increase.
  • Enhanced Electrochemical Performance:
    • Cycling Stability: hp-Si-L achieved a high capacity retention of 90% after 100 cycles at 1 A/g, and 69% after 350 cycles. hp-Si-S showed lower retention (80% after 100 cycles).
  • Rate Performance: hp-Si-L delivered 566 mAh/g at a high rate of 12.8 A/g, demonstrating superior rate capability compared to hp-Si-S (386 mAh/g at 12.8 A/g).
  • Model Validation: The chemomechanical model successfully explained the observed differences in volume expansion between hp-Si-L and hp-Si-S, highlighting the importance of primary pore size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Porosity Control: While the primary pore size was tunable, the paper notes that the internal pores (secondary pores) still dominate the overall porosity, leading to slightly shifted and broad pore size distributions rather than sharp peaks at the intended primary or secondary pore sizes.
  • Scalability: The synthesis method is described as "facile and scalable," but further work would be needed to demonstrate large-scale manufacturing feasibility.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings provide a strategy for designing high-performance Si anode materials with minimal volume change, implying that further optimization of pore structure and other material parameters could lead to even better battery performance. The study's insights into the role of pore size are expected to guide future designs for practical Si anode applications in LIBs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Silicon (Si) remains one of the most promising anode materials for next-generation lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). The key challenge for Si anodes is the huge volume change during lithiation-delithiation cycles that leads to electrode pulverization and rapid capacity fading. Here, we report a hierarchical porous Si (hp-Si) with a tailored porous structure [tunable primary pores (20-200 nm) and secondary nanopores (∼3-10 nm)] that can effectively minimize the volume expansion. An in situ transmission electron microscopy (TEM) study revealed that the hp-Si material with the same porosity but larger primary pores can more effectively accommodate lithiation-induced volume expansion, giving rise to a much reduced apparent volume expansion on both material and electrode levels. Chemomechanical modeling revealed that because of the different relative stiffnesses of the lithiated and unlithiated Si phases, the primary pore size plays a key role in accommodating the volume expansion of lithiated Si. The higher structural stability of the hp-Si materials with larger primary pores also maintains the fast diffusion channels of the connective pores, giving rise to better power capability and capacity retention upon electrochemical cycling. Our findings point toward an optimized hp-Si material with minimal volume change during electrochemical cycling for next-generation LIBs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dai2019minimized,
  author = {Fang Dai and Ran Yi and Hui Yang and Yuming Zhao and Langli Luo and Mikhail L. Gordin and Hiesang Sohn and Shuru Chen and Chongmin Wang and Sulin Zhang and Donghai Wang},
  title = {{Minimized Volume Expansion in Hierarchical Porous Silicon upon Lithiation}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acsami.9b01501},
}
Figure