Minimal Impairment in a Rat Model of Duration Discrimination Following Excitotoxic Lesions of Primary Auditory and Prefrontal Cortices

Shraddha Pai, Jeffrey C. Erlich, Charles D. Kopec, Carlos D. BrodyFrontiers in Systems Neuroscience 2011 · DOI

Abstract

We present a behavioral paradigm for the study of duration perception in the rat, and report the result of neurotoxic lesions that have the goal of identifying sites that mediate duration perception. Using a two-alternative forced-choice paradigm, rats were either trained to discriminate durations of pure tones (range = [200,500] ms; boundary = 316 ms; Weber fraction after training = 0.24 ± 0.04), or were trained to discriminate frequencies of pure tones (range = [8,16] kHz; boundary = 11.3 kHz; Weber = 0.16 ± 0.11); the latter task is a control for non-timing-specific aspects of the former. Both groups discriminate the same class of sensory stimuli, use the same motions to indicate decisions, have identical trial structures, and are trained to psychophysical threshold; the tasks are thus matched in a number of sensorimotor and cognitive demands. We made neurotoxic lesions of candidate timing-perception areas in the cerebral cortex of both groups. Following extensive bilateral lesions of the auditory cortex, the performance of the frequency discrimination group was significantly more impaired than that of the duration discrimination group. We also found that extensive bilateral lesions of the medial prefrontal cortex resulted in little to no impairment of both groups. The behavioral framework presented here provides an audition-based approach to study the neural mechanisms of time estimation and memory for durations.

Introduction

How does the brain keep track of time? While we understand the molecular "clocks" behind circadian rhythms and the microsecond-level timing used for sound localization, the mechanisms for "interval timing"—the range of hundreds of milliseconds to seconds—remain a mystery. Previous research often conflated the perception of time with the production of a motor action. To isolate the sensory aspect of timing, this study utilized a two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) paradigm to determine if the auditory cortex (ACx) or the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) are necessary for auditory duration discrimination.

Experimental Paradigm and Methods

Researchers trained Long-Evans rats on two nearly identical tasks to ensure results were specific to timing, not general cognitive or motor demands:

  1. Duration Discrimination: Rats categorized a tone as "short" (near 200ms) or "long" (near 500ms).
  2. Frequency Discrimination (Control): Rats categorized a tone as "low" (8kHz) or "high" (16kHz).

Both groups used the same hardware and trial structures. After training to psychophysical limits, researchers performed excitotoxic lesions in either the ACx or the mPFC. To quantify the damage's effect, they developed the IMPAIR score, which combines changes in the slope of the animal's psychometric curve (sensitivity) and accuracy at the easiest "endpoint" stimuli.

Figure 1: Trial structure for the duration and frequency discrimination tasks. Rats initiate trials with a center poke and indicate decisions via side pokes following a "GO" signal.

Key Insights and Results

Anatomical Dissociation in the Auditory Cortex

The most striking finding was that ACx lesions severely degraded frequency discrimination but left duration discrimination relatively intact. This suggests that while the ACx is the primary processor for what a sound is, it is not the primary "clock" for how long it lasts.

The mPFC is Not the Timer

Despite the mPFC's known role in short-term memory and executive function, extensive bilateral lesions there caused almost zero impairment in either task. This suggests the mPFC is not required for simple perceptual bisection of sub-second intervals.

Subcortical Robustness

Because the animals could still time sounds without a functional auditory cortex, the authors propose that timing happens "lower down" in the brain—potentially in the thalamus, striatum, or inferior colliculus. The ability to discriminate 316ms intervals appears remarkably resilient to cortical damage, pointing toward a robust, possibly ancient, subcortical timing system.

Discussion and Future Work

While the researchers achieved approximately 80% coverage of target areas, the stark difference in impairment between the frequency and duration tasks following ACx lesions strongly supports the conclusion that the primary auditory cortex is non-essential for duration perception. This "negative result" for the cortex shifts the focus of the field toward subcortical structures. Future work will likely target the striatum (part of the basal ganglia) or the auditory thalamus to locate the actual "stopwatch" neurons of the brain.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a behavioral paradigm for the study of duration perception in the rat, and report the result of neurotoxic lesions that have the goal of identifying sites that mediate duration perception. Using a two-alternative forced-choice paradigm, rats were either trained to discriminate durations of pure tones (range = [200,500] ms; boundary = 316 ms; Weber fraction after training = 0.24 ± 0.04), or were trained to discriminate frequencies of pure tones (range = [8,16] kHz; boundary = 11.3 kHz; Weber = 0.16 ± 0.11); the latter task is a control for non-timing-specific aspects of the former. Both groups discriminate the same class of sensory stimuli, use the same motions to indicate decisions, have identical trial structures, and are trained to psychophysical threshold; the tasks are thus matched in a number of sensorimotor and cognitive demands. We made neurotoxic lesions of candidate timing-perception areas in the cerebral cortex of both groups. Following extensive bilateral lesions of the auditory cortex, the performance of the frequency discrimination group was significantly more impaired than that of the duration discrimination group. We also found that extensive bilateral lesions of the medial prefrontal cortex resulted in little to no impairment of both groups. The behavioral framework presented here provides an audition-based approach to study the neural mechanisms of time estimation and memory for durations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pai2011minimal,
  author = {Shraddha Pai and Jeffrey C. Erlich and Charles D. Kopec and Carlos D. Brody},
  title = {{Minimal Impairment in a Rat Model of Duration Discrimination Following Excitotoxic Lesions of Primary Auditory and Prefrontal Cortices}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.3389/fnsys.2011.00074},
}
Figure