Mini Review: Comparison of Bio-Inspired Adhesive Feet of Climbing Robots on Smooth Vertical Surfaces

Pongsiri Borijindakul, Aihong Ji, Zhendong Dai, Stanislav N. Gorb, Poramate ManoonpongFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Developing climbing robots for smooth vertical surfaces (e.g., glass) is one of the most challenging problems in robotics. Here, the adequate functioning of an adhesive foot is an essential factor for successful locomotion performance. Among the various technologies (such as dry adhesion, wet adhesion, magnetic adhesion, and pneumatic adhesion), bio-inspired dry adhesion has been actively studied and successfully applied to climbing robots. Thus, this review focuses on the characteristics of two different types of foot microstructures, namely spatula-shaped and mushroom-shaped, capable of generating such adhesion. These are the most used types of foot microstructures in climbing robots for smooth vertical surfaces. Moreover, this review shows that the spatula-shaped feet are particularly suitable for massive and one-directional climbing robots, whereas mushroom-shaped feet are primarily suitable for light and all-directional climbing robots. Consequently, this study can guide roboticists in selecting the right adhesive foot to achieve the best climbing ability for future robot developments.

Introduction

Climbing smooth vertical surfaces like glass remains a classic challenge in robotics. Traditional methods, including magnetic, pneumatic (suction), and wet adhesives, often face limitations regarding surface material compatibility, residue, or environmental sensitivity. Bio-inspired dry adhesion has emerged as a superior alternative because it is typically reversible, leaves no residue, and functions effectively across diverse environments.

However, dry adhesion is not a monolithic technology; it encompasses various microstructures inspired by different biological systems. This review provides a comparative framework to assist roboticists in selecting the optimal adhesive geometry—spatula-shaped versus mushroom-shaped—based on a robot's weight, movement requirements, and durability needs.

Bio-Inspired Microstructures

Research over the last 15 years has synthesized findings from bionics and soft robotics to categorize two primary synthetic adhesive types based on their biological counterparts.

Biological inspiration for adhesive microstructures across different species, showing the progression from beetles to geckos.

Spatula-Shaped Adhesives

Inspired by gecko setae, these structures utilize directional polymer stalks (DPSs) that rely on van der Waals forces. A defining characteristic of spatula-shaped feet is their requirement for a shear force—pulling parallel to the surface—to "engage" the adhesion. This mechanism allows for high load-bearing capacity but introduces inherent directionality.

Mushroom-Shaped Adhesives

Inspired by the attachment systems of beetles (family Chrysomelidae), these are typically fabricated from polyvinyl siloxane (PVS) and often feature hexagonal patterning. Unlike spatulas, mushroom-shaped structures rely on a normal force (pressing into the surface) for attachment, providing a more uniform, all-directional adhesive capability.

Comparative Analysis: Directionality and Scaling

The deciding factor for many robotic applications is directionality. Spatula-shaped feet are inherently directional; they adhere when pulled in one direction and release when pushed or lifted. While this is advantageous for heavy robots moving in a straight line, it complicates navigation for robots requiring multi-directional movement or ceiling traversal without foot rotation. In contrast, mushroom-shaped feet provide all-directional adhesion, facilitating more versatile locomotion.

Furthermore, the "Scaling Law of Spatulas" dictates that adhesion strength increases as the size of the terminal element decreases. For instance, synthetic spatulas based on carbon nanotubes (approx. 8 nm) can generate forces nearly ten times stronger than those of a natural gecko foot. While spatula feet require minimal normal preloads to engage, mushroom feet require a slight initial press, which may be a disadvantage for extremely lightweight or fragile robotic frames.

Performance Results in Robotic Platforms

The practical application of these microstructures has been demonstrated across several landmark robotic platforms. The performance metrics, including weight and maximum climbing angle, vary significantly based on the chosen adhesive geometry.

Comparison of climbing robot performance, detailing the relationship between robot weight, foot shape, and maximum climbing angle.

Key achievements in the field include:

  • Load Capacity: The 9g climber, utilizing 100 μm spatulas, demonstrated the ability to hoist 1,000% of its body weight (1 kg) while ascending glass surfaces.
  • Adhesion Strength: Mushroom-shaped MSAMS (Mushroom-Shaped Adhesive Microstructure) tapes have supported weights up to 70 kg using a relatively small 20 cm × 20 cm patch.
  • Climbing Versatility: While most robots achieve a 90° vertical climb, spatula-based designs like StickyBot have reached 110° (overhanging), and specific mushroom-based designs are capable of 180° (ceiling) locomotion.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While bio-inspired dry adhesives offer a robust solution for vertical locomotion, several challenges remain. Mushroom-shaped feet require precise "peeling angles" for damage-free detachment, a movement that is mechanically complex to automate at high speeds. Additionally, while these adhesives excel on smooth glass, their performance degrades on rough or dusty surfaces.

Future research should focus on enhancing the durability of mushroom-shaped structures and developing sophisticated control systems. Such systems would allow robots to dynamically adjust foot orientation, effectively overcoming the directional limitations of spatula-shaped adhesives and paving the way for more agile climbing robots.

Summary updated

Abstract

Developing climbing robots for smooth vertical surfaces (e.g., glass) is one of the most challenging problems in robotics. Here, the adequate functioning of an adhesive foot is an essential factor for successful locomotion performance. Among the various technologies (such as dry adhesion, wet adhesion, magnetic adhesion, and pneumatic adhesion), bio-inspired dry adhesion has been actively studied and successfully applied to climbing robots. Thus, this review focuses on the characteristics of two different types of foot microstructures, namely spatula-shaped and mushroom-shaped, capable of generating such adhesion. These are the most used types of foot microstructures in climbing robots for smooth vertical surfaces. Moreover, this review shows that the spatula-shaped feet are particularly suitable for massive and one-directional climbing robots, whereas mushroom-shaped feet are primarily suitable for light and all-directional climbing robots. Consequently, this study can guide roboticists in selecting the right adhesive foot to achieve the best climbing ability for future robot developments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{borijindakul2021mini,
  author = {Pongsiri Borijindakul and Aihong Ji and Zhendong Dai and Stanislav N. Gorb and Poramate Manoonpong},
  title = {{Mini Review: Comparison of Bio-Inspired Adhesive Feet of Climbing Robots on Smooth Vertical Surfaces}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2021.765718},
}
Figure