Mineralization age and genesis of the makeng-style iron deposits in the Paleo-Pacific tectonic domain of South China: In situ LA-ICPMS garnet U-Pb chronological and geochemical constraints

Sen Wang, Ke Cao, Da Zhang, Jinjun Yi, Bojie Hu, Jing Yang, Meng-Ying Cai, Yao-Yao Zhang, Yuan Yuan, Tian-Wang PanFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

Abstract

To reveal the genesis of Makeng-style iron polymetallic deposits from SE China in the paleo-Pacific tectonic domain, a new analytical method of LA-ICPMS garnet U-Pb dating and rare Earth element analysis was conducted for the Makeng, Luoyang, Dapai and Pantian deposits. The U-Pb dating results of nine garnet skarn samples from these deposits suggested that the Makeng-style iron polymetallic deposits mainly formed during 137–130 Ma, which is consistent with the zircon U-Pb and molybdenite Re-Os ages. This study provides more direct evidence of the mineralization age and the relationship between mineralization and granite, compared with previous studies on the zircon U-Pb dating for granites in the ore fields. Rare Earth element (REE) analysis results and REE patterns of four representative garnet samples from the Makeng, Luoyang, Dapai and Pantian deposits show that they are similar to typical skarn deposits, but obvious differences in the REE distribution types indicate that the ore-forming process may be distinct due to different mineralizing fluid for these Makeng-style deposits.

Introduction: The Makeng-Style Mystery

The Southwestern Fujian Iron Polymetallic Metallogenic Belt (SFIPMB) is home to some of China’s most significant iron reserves, known as "Makeng-style" deposits. Despite their economic importance, geologists have spent decades debating two fundamental questions: When did they form, and how?

Previous studies offered conflicting ages, split between the Late Jurassic (160–150 Ma) and the Early Cretaceous (135–130 Ma). The challenge lay in the "indirect" nature of the evidence; researchers were mostly dating zircon crystals found in nearby granites, assuming the ore formed at the same time as the rocks. This paper addresses the need for direct dating of the ore-forming process itself to provide a definitive chronological and geochemical framework.

Tectonic sketch map showing the location of the study area (A) and regional geological map of southwest Fujian (B).

Methodology: Direct Dating via Garnet

The authors employed in situ Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (LA-ICPMS) to analyze nine representative garnet skarn samples collected from four major deposits: Makeng, Luoyang, Dapai, and Pantian.

  • Target Mineral: The team focused on garnet (specifically andradite), a primary "skarn" mineral that crystallizes simultaneously with magnetite. Because garnet contains trace amounts of Uranium and Lead, it acts as a robust internal clock for the mineralization event.
  • Dual Analysis: They performed both U-Pb chronological dating and Rare Earth Element (REE) analysis on the same samples. This allowed them to determine not just the age, but also the chemical "fingerprint" of the fluids that deposited the iron.

Key Results and Tectonic Trigger

The U-Pb dating results pin the mineralization to the Early Cretaceous (137–130 Ma), effectively closing the window on the Late Jurassic hypothesis for these specific deposits. The resulting lower interception ages across the four sites were:

  • Makeng: ~133.3 to 130.4 Ma
  • Luoyang: ~137.5 to 136.9 Ma
  • Dapai: ~132.1 to 130.9 Ma
  • Pantian: ~133.8 Ma
Geological Section Maps of the Makeng (A), Dapai (B), Pantian (C) and Luoyang (D) Fe-polymetallic deposits.

This timing coincides perfectly with the rollback of the Paleo-Pacific plate. As the subducting plate retreated, it created an extensional tectonic environment. This "stretching" of the crust allowed Early Cretaceous magmas and mineral-rich hydrothermal fluids to rise and react with older limestone, forming the skarn deposits. The study confirms these are magmatic-hydrothermal skarn deposits, where iron was delivered by fluids exsolved from cooling Cretaceous granites.

Geochemical Diversity and Future Work

While the deposits share a similar tectonic trigger, REE patterns revealed significant differences in mineralizing fluids. Garnets from Makeng and Luoyang showed enrichment in Light Rare Earth Elements (LREE), whereas Dapai and Pantian showed flatter distribution curves. This suggests that the specific "recipe" of the mineralizing fluids varied across the belt, indicating a complex plumbing system.

This study demonstrates that garnet U-Pb dating is a highly effective tool for researching skarn-type deposits where traditional dating minerals might be absent. Future research involving detailed fluid inclusion studies and stable isotope analysis could further refine the genetic model and help identify new exploration targets in the Paleo-Pacific tectonic domain.

Summary updated

Abstract

To reveal the genesis of Makeng-style iron polymetallic deposits from SE China in the paleo-Pacific tectonic domain, a new analytical method of LA-ICPMS garnet U-Pb dating and rare Earth element analysis was conducted for the Makeng, Luoyang, Dapai and Pantian deposits. The U-Pb dating results of nine garnet skarn samples from these deposits suggested that the Makeng-style iron polymetallic deposits mainly formed during 137–130 Ma, which is consistent with the zircon U-Pb and molybdenite Re-Os ages. This study provides more direct evidence of the mineralization age and the relationship between mineralization and granite, compared with previous studies on the zircon U-Pb dating for granites in the ore fields. Rare Earth element (REE) analysis results and REE patterns of four representative garnet samples from the Makeng, Luoyang, Dapai and Pantian deposits show that they are similar to typical skarn deposits, but obvious differences in the REE distribution types indicate that the ore-forming process may be distinct due to different mineralizing fluid for these Makeng-style deposits. Our new garnet U-Pb dating and rare Earth element analysis result not only provides new evidence for the mineralization age and genesis of the Makeng-style deposits but is also of great significance to promote the application of U-Pb dating methods to research skarn type deposits.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023mineralization,
  author = {Sen Wang and Ke Cao and Da Zhang and Jinjun Yi and Bojie Hu and Jing Yang and Meng-Ying Cai and Yao-Yao Zhang and Yuan Yuan and Tian-Wang Pan},
  title = {{Mineralization age and genesis of the makeng-style iron deposits in the Paleo-Pacific tectonic domain of South China: In situ LA-ICPMS garnet U-Pb chronological and geochemical constraints}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.1027620},
}
Figure