Mindfulness meditation styles differently modulate source-level MEG microstate dynamics and complexity

Antea D’Andrea, Pierpaolo Croce, Jordan O’Byrne, Karim Jerbi, Annalisa Pascarella, Antonino Raffone, Vittorio Pizzella, Laura MarzettiFrontiers in Neuroscience 2024 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Neuroscience, explores how different styles of mindfulness meditation—Focused Attention (FAM) and Open Monitoring (OMM)—reconfigure the brain's dynamic landscape. By analyzing source-level magnetoencephalography (MEG) data from expert Buddhist monks, the researchers demonstrate that meditation shifts the brain away from its resting-state dynamics toward a more complex, "edge-of-chaos" state, with OMM exhibiting the highest levels of neural complexity.

TL;DR

Researchers used high-resolution MEG to show that different meditation styles uniquely modulate the brain's "microstates"—brief, stable patterns of neural activity. The study reveals that meditation, particularly Open Monitoring, increases brain complexity and shifts neural dynamics closer to a critical "edge-of-chaos" state, which may enhance information processing and cognitive flexibility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While we know meditation changes brain activity, understanding the dynamics of these changes has been challenging. Most previous research relied on EEG "sensor-space" analysis, which lacks the spatial resolution to pinpoint exactly where in the brain these changes occur. Furthermore, there is a theoretical gap in understanding how meditation affects "brain criticality"—the delicate balance between order and disorder that allows the brain to function optimally.

The authors sought to bridge this gap by using source-reconstructed MEG data to track how the brain transitions between different states (microstates) and how these transitions relate to mathematical measures of complexity and criticality.

Methods

The researchers recruited 10 Theravada Buddhist monks with significant meditative expertise (minimum 2,265 hours).

  • Experimental Design: A randomized block design where monks performed 6 minutes of FAM (focusing on a single object like breath), 6 minutes of OMM (non-reactive awareness of all thoughts/sensations), and resting-state (REST) periods.
  • Imaging & Source Reconstruction: MEG data were acquired and projected into "source space" using the eLORETA algorithm, then mapped onto the Human Connectome Project (HCP) atlas.
  • Microstate Analysis: The team used a $k$-means clustering algorithm to identify 9 distinct "microstates"—quasi-stable topographical maps of brain activity lasting milliseconds.
  • Complexity Metrics: They calculated the Hurst exponent (a measure of long-range temporal correlations or "avalanche criticality") and Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC) (a measure of how "compressible" or diverse the sequence of brain states is, often linked to "edge-of-chaos" criticality).

Datasets

  • Primary Dataset: Newly acquired MEG and T1-weighted MRI data from 10 expert Theravada Buddhist monks.
  • Reference Atlas: The Human Connectome Project (HCP230) multimodal parcellation was used to define 230 cortical regions of interest.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Meditation as a Dynamic Shift: Meditation isn't just a "quieter" brain; it’s a different way of moving between states. The study found that microstates associated with the Default Mode Network and Visual systems (MS6 and MS8) were more dominant during meditation than at rest.
  • OMM vs. FAM: The two styles are neurally distinct. FAM (focus) showed higher activity in visual areas (MS1), likely due to internal visualization. OMM (monitoring) showed higher activity in the Central Executive and Ventral Attention networks (MS3 and MS5), reflecting the high cognitive demand of maintaining broad, non-reactive awareness.
  • The Complexity Gradient: The most striking finding was a progressive increase in Lempel-Ziv Complexity from REST $\rightarrow$ FAM $\rightarrow$ OMM. This suggests that OMM represents a more information-rich, diverse state of brain activity.
  • Shifting Criticality: Meditation reduced the Hurst exponent compared to rest. In physics terms, this suggests a shift away from "avalanche" dynamics toward a state that may favor local processing or reduced information propagation, potentially reflecting the "internalized" nature of the meditative state.

Key Results

  • Microstate Modulation: Specific microstates were modulated by meditation style. For example, MS5 (Ventral Attention/Executive) coverage was significantly higher in OMM than in FAM ($p < 0.001$).
  • Complexity (LZC): OMM showed significantly higher complexity than both FAM and REST ($p < 0.001$).
  • Criticality (Hurst): The Hurst exponent was significantly higher in REST than in either meditative condition ($p = 0.009$ for FAM; $p = 0.025$ for OMM), indicating a shift in the brain's dynamical operating point.
  • Expertise Correlation: The difference in MS5 coverage and LZC between OMM and FAM positively correlated with the monks' years of meditative expertise ($R = 0.675$ and $R = 0.640$, respectively).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: The study only included 10 participants. While these were "Olympic-level" meditators, the small $N$ limits the generalizability of the findings.
  • Age/Expertise Confound: In this cohort, older monks naturally had more hours of practice, making it difficult to separate the effects of aging from the effects of long-term meditation.
  • Directionality: As a cross-sectional study, it cannot definitively prove that meditation caused these dynamic traits, though the "state-like" changes (differences between REST and meditation blocks) strongly suggest an acute effect.

Future Work: The researchers suggest replicating the study with a larger group, including "novice" meditators, to see if these complexity shifts can be trained over shorter periods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Importantly, we report changes in brain criticality indices during meditation and between meditation styles, in line with a state-like effect of meditation on cognitive performance. In line with previous reports, we suggest that the change in cognitive state experienced in meditation is paralleled by a shift with respect to critical points in brain dynamics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dandrea2024mindfulness,
  author = {Antea D’Andrea and Pierpaolo Croce and Jordan O’Byrne and Karim Jerbi and Annalisa Pascarella and Antonino Raffone and Vittorio Pizzella and Laura Marzetti},
  title = {{Mindfulness meditation styles differently modulate source-level MEG microstate dynamics and complexity}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2024.1295615},
}
Figure