Mindfulness-Based Movement Intervention to Improve Sleep Quality: A Meta-Analysis and Moderator Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials

Jiayi Yang, Yan Du, Haoran Shen, Ren Shujie, Zhiyuan Liu, Danni Zheng, Qingqing Shi, Youfa Li, Gao‐Xia WeiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This meta-analysis of 61 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) found that Mindfulness-Based Movement (MBM) interventions significantly improve subjective sleep quality. The study also identified optimal MBM protocols, suggesting that longer durations, higher frequencies, and specific populations (healthy individuals and older adults) benefit most.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sleep disturbances are a widespread public health concern, impacting physical and mental well-being. While pharmacological and psychotherapeutic approaches are common, they can have side effects or require significant time commitment. Mindfulness-based interventions, particularly Mindfulness-Based Movement (MBM), have emerged as a promising alternative. However, the optimal "dose" (frequency, duration, type) and the most receptive populations for MBM to improve sleep quality remained unclear, hindering its widespread clinical application and research.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published up to August 2021. They searched three major databases (PubMed, Web of Science, and EBSCO) for studies investigating MBM interventions for sleep quality. The risk of bias in the included studies was assessed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool. A meta-analysis was performed using Stata 16.0, employing a random-effects model due to significant heterogeneity among studies. Crucially, a moderator analysis was conducted to explore how different intervention parameters (population type, age, MBM type, intervention duration, frequency, and total intervention time) influenced the effectiveness of MBM on sleep quality.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it synthesized data from 61 existing randomized controlled trials (RCTs) involving a total of 2697 participants. The data extracted from these RCTs included participant characteristics (age, gender, health status), intervention protocols (type of MBM, duration, frequency), and sleep quality measurements (primarily self-report scales, with some using polysomnography).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MBM is a potent sleep enhancer: The overarching finding that MBM significantly improves sleep quality is a strong endorsement for this intervention.
  • Dose makes the difference: The moderator analysis reveals that not all MBM interventions are created equal. Specific parameters significantly amplify the positive effects on sleep.
  • "More is better" for MBM: Longer intervention durations (over 3 months), higher frequencies (at least twice a week), and a cumulative intervention time exceeding 24 hours consistently showed larger effect sizes. This suggests a dose-response relationship.
  • Targeted populations yield greater gains: Healthy individuals and older adults appear to benefit more from MBM for sleep quality compared to patients with physical or psychiatric conditions, or younger adults. This highlights the importance of considering individual characteristics.
  • Subjective sleep quality is the primary outcome: While some studies used objective measures like PSG, the meta-analysis primarily relied on self-reported sleep quality, which is a crucial aspect of perceived well-being.

Key Results

The meta-analysis of 61 RCTs with 2697 participants demonstrated that MBM significantly improved subjective sleep quality compared to control groups, with a standardized mean difference (SMD) of -0.794 (95% CI: -0.794 to -0.994, p < 0.001).

Moderator analysis revealed:

  • Duration: Long-term MBM (>3 months) had a larger effect size (SMD = -0.829) than short-term MBM (≤3 months) (SMD = -0.714).
  • Frequency: Practicing MBM at least twice per week (SMD = -0.793) was more effective than once per week (SMD = -0.687).
  • Total Intervention Time: Interventions exceeding 24 hours in total duration showed better sleep improvement (SMD = -0.759) compared to those below 24 hours (SMD = -0.746).
  • Population: Healthy individuals (SMD = -0.899) and older adults (SMD = -0.873) experienced greater benefits than patients with somatic diseases (SMD = -0.627), psychiatric illnesses (SMD = -0.618), or younger adults (SMD = -0.618).
  • MBM Type: Yoga/Pilates (SMD = -0.808) showed a slightly greater effect than MBM combined with mindfulness/muscle relaxation (SMD = -0.741) or Tai Chi/Qigong/Baduanjin (SMD = -0.567).

Objective measures of sleep quality (PSG) did not show a significant difference in total sleep time between MBM and control groups.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Database Search: The search was limited to English-language databases, potentially excluding relevant studies from other languages and impacting generalizability.
  • Objective Sleep Measures: The meta-analysis primarily relied on subjective sleep quality measures. While significant, the lack of robust objective data (e.g., from PSG) limits conclusions about physiological sleep improvements.
  • Gender Differences: Many studies did not report gender-specific data, preventing a detailed analysis of how gender might influence MBM's effectiveness on sleep.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • More Objective Measures: Incorporating objective sleep measurements (e.g., actigraphy, PSG) in future RCTs.
  • Investigating Gender: Conducting comparative RCTs specifically designed to explore the role of gender in MBM's impact on sleep.
  • Exploring Mechanisms: Further interdisciplinary research to understand the molecular and psychological mechanisms underlying MBM's effects on sleep, such as emotional regulation, autonomic nervous system function, and inflammatory processes.
  • Optimizing Protocols: Continued refinement of MBM intervention protocols based on the identified optimal parameters (duration, frequency, total time) for various populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

(1) Background: Given that the most effective dose, optimal type, and most beneficial population for improving sleep with mindfulness-based movement (MBM) remains unknown, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis with moderator analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to assess these effects. (2) Methods: Three electronic databases (PubMed, Web of Science, and EBSCO) were systematically searched for RCTs published through August 2021 for analysis. The risk of bias of the included studies was assessed with Review Manager 5.3, and the meta-analysis was performed in Stata 16.0. (3) Results: A meta-analysis of 61 RCTs with 2697 participants showed that MBM significantly improved sleep quality compared to controls (SMD = −0.794; 95% CI: −0.794 to −0.994, p < 0.001, I2 = 90.7%). Moderator analysis showed that a long-term MBM (SMD = −0.829; 95% CI: 0.945 to 0.712; p < 0.001) had a larger effect size on sleep than a short-term MBM (SMD = −0.714; 95% CI: 0.784 to 0.644; p < 0.001). Practicing at least twice per week (SMD = −0.793; 95% CI: −0.868 to −0.718; p < 0.001) was more effective compared to practicing once per week (SMD = −0.687; 95% CI: −0.804 to −0.570; p < 0.001). Studies with a total intervention time of more than 24 h also revealed better sleep quality improvement (SMD = −0.759; 95% CI: −0.865 to −0.653; p < 0.001). In addition, the healthy population and older adults gained more from MBM than the patients and younger adults. (4) Conclusions: MBM can effectively improve subjective sleep quality, and the optimal intervention dose of MBM can be utilized in future intervention studies to treat or improve sleep disturbance (MBM more than twice a week for more than three months, with a total intervention time of more than 24 h).
BibTeX
@article{yang2022mindfulness,
  author = {Jiayi Yang and Yan Du and Haoran Shen and Ren Shujie and Zhiyuan Liu and Danni Zheng and Qingqing Shi and Youfa Li and Gao‐Xia Wei},
  title = {{Mindfulness-Based Movement Intervention to Improve Sleep Quality: A Meta-Analysis and Moderator Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191610284},
}
Figure