Mind, Brain, and Character: How Neuroscience Affects People's Views of Criminal Wrongdoers

Dena M. Gromet, Geoffrey P. Goodwin, Simone Tang, Thomas Nadelhoffer, Walter Sinnott‐ArmstrongSSRN 2014

Abstract

Ordinary psychological explanations of criminal behavior tend to focus on the causal role of mental states such as intentions, beliefs, and desires. In contrast, neuroscientific explanations of criminal behavior focus attention on the causal role of physiological states within the brain. Although these explanations may be seen as compatible, highlighting the role of brain, as opposed to purely the mind, may deferentially affect the way lay individuals view criminal wrongdoers. The present research examines whether these different ways of explaining criminal wrongdoing affect people’s assessments of the relevant wrongdoers’ culpability and punishment, as well as their views of the wrongdoers’ overall character. In three studies, we found that people view wrongdoers more favorably, and think they should be punished less severely, when their behavior is caused by an emotional dysfunction that is described as neurological rather than mental/psychological. Studies 2 and 3 demonstrated that this effect arises because people view the wrongdoer’s actions as less diagnostic of his true character when his dysfunction is described as brain-based. Implications for using neuroscience to explain behavior in legal settings (and more generally) are discussed.
BibTeX
@misc{gromet2014mind,
  author = {Dena M. Gromet and Geoffrey P. Goodwin and Simone Tang and Thomas Nadelhoffer and Walter Sinnott‐Armstrong},
  title = {{Mind, Brain, and Character: How Neuroscience Affects People's Views of Criminal Wrongdoers}},
  year = {2014},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}

Loading related content...

Figure