MilkyWay@home: Harnessing volunteer computers to constrain dark matter in the Milky Way

Heidi Jo Newberg, Matthew Newby, Travis Desell, Malik Magdon‐Ismail, Bolesław K. Szymański, Carlos A. VarelaProceedings of the International Astronomical Union 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces MilkyWay@home, a distributed computing project leveraging over 25,000 volunteers to analyze tidal streams in the Milky Way. By fitting these streams to N-body simulations, the project aims to map the distribution of dark matter within our galaxy, a crucial step in understanding galactic evolution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the distribution of dark matter in the Milky Way is fundamental to comprehending its formation and evolution. While we know dark matter exists, its precise distribution remains elusive. Tidal streams, remnants of disrupted dwarf galaxies and globular clusters, act as tracers of the Milky Way's gravitational potential. However, analyzing these faint structures and comparing them to complex simulations is computationally intensive. Traditional methods struggle with the inherent uncertainties in stellar distances and the sheer volume of data required. This paper addresses the challenge of efficiently processing vast astronomical datasets and performing computationally demanding simulations to infer the Milky Way's dark matter distribution.

Methods

The core of the MilkyWay@home project lies in two main applications:

  1. Statistical Photometric Parallax for Tidal Stream Fitting: This method tackles the uncertainty in stellar distances. Instead of relying on precise distance measurements for each star, it uses statistical knowledge of the absolute magnitudes of stellar populations (specifically, F turnoff stars) to infer the underlying density distribution of tidal streams. This involves:
  2. Assuming parameterized models for stellar density.
  3. Transforming these models to observed coordinates (l, b, g).
  4. Convolving the model with the distribution of absolute magnitudes to account for line-of-sight smearing.
  5. Incorporating the survey's detection efficiency as a function of apparent magnitude.
  6. Using an optimization technique (like conjugate gradient descent, though computationally expensive) to find model parameters that best fit the observed data.
  7. N-body Simulations for Tidal Stream Comparison: This application uses N-body simulations to generate synthetic tidal streams. The goal is to find simulation parameters (e.g., properties of the progenitor dwarf galaxy, its orbit) that produce streams closely matching the observed spatial density of real tidal streams. The "goodness-of-fit" is measured using the Earth-Mover Distance (EMD) to compare the density profiles of observed and simulated streams.

Datasets

The primary datasets used are from large-scale sky surveys, specifically:

  • Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS): Provides essential data on stellar positions and magnitudes.
  • Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS): Complements SDSS data, particularly in infrared wavelengths.

The paper also refers to using data from the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy and its tidal tails, as well as the Virgo overdensity. Future work anticipates incorporating data from upcoming surveys like LAMOST and Gaia.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Citizen Science for Astrophysics: The project demonstrates the power of distributed computing (via BOINC) in tackling computationally intensive astrophysical problems that would be prohibitive for individual institutions.
  • Statistical Parallax as a Distance Solution: The statistical photometric parallax method is a clever workaround for the inherent difficulty in obtaining precise distances for millions of faint stars, enabling the study of faint substructures.
  • Tidal Streams as Dark Matter Probes: Tidal streams, by their very nature, are shaped by the Milky Way's gravitational potential. By accurately modeling these streams and their progenitors, we can indirectly map the distribution of the underlying dark matter.
  • Earth-Mover Distance for Stream Matching: The use of EMD provides a robust metric for comparing the density distributions of observed and simulated tidal streams, going beyond simple histogram comparisons.

Key Results

  • Half a PetaFLOPS of Computing Power: MilkyWay@home currently utilizes over 25,000 active volunteers, contributing approximately 0.5 PetaFLOPS of computing power.
  • Published Results on Sagittarius Dwarf Stream: The stream-fitting application has successfully fit the leading tidal tail of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy, with ongoing work on its trailing tail and bifurcated pieces.
  • Improved Density Modeling: The statistical photometric parallax method allows for a more accurate description of the spatial density of tidal streams, even accounting for survey limitations.
  • Computational Efficiency: The parallelized algorithm significantly reduces computation time, making previously intractable analyses feasible.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Current Methods:
    • The current N-body fitting is limited to analyzing the spatial density of stars along the stream.
  • The initial fitting of tidal streams was done in segments, and the position and distance of the stream center varied arbitrarily across the sky.
  • The current N-body application is primarily focused on fitting dwarf galaxy progenitor properties.
  • Future Work:
    • Expanding to Multiple Dimensions: Incorporating additional spatial dimensions and kinematic measures (radial velocities, proper motions) into the stream fitting.
  • Fitting Multiple Tidal Streams: The ultimate goal is to use multiple tidal streams simultaneously to constrain the Milky Way's potential and dark matter distribution.
  • Improved N-body Fitting: Fitting the density of streams in at least two dimensions, and incorporating radial velocities and velocity dispersions.
  • Leveraging Gaia Data: Utilizing the precise astrometric data from the Gaia mission to significantly improve proper motion measurements and thus kinematic fitting.
  • Interactive Volunteer Involvement: Exploring mechanisms for volunteers to directly influence parameter fitting and providing feedback on their contributions.
  • Developing a Self-Consistent Halo Model: Creating a comprehensive model of the smooth stellar halo component and major tidal streams.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract MilkyWay@home is a volunteer computing project that allows people from every country in the world to volunteer their otherwise idle processors to Milky Way research. Currently, more than 25,000 people (150,000 since November 9, 2007) contribute about half a PetaFLOPS of computing power to our project. We currently run two types of applications: one application fits the spatial density profile of tidal streams using statistical photometric parallax, and the other application finds the N -body simulation parameters that produce tidal streams that best match the measured density profile of known tidal streams. The stream fitting application is well developed and is producing published results. The Sagittarius dwarf leading tidal tail has been fit, and the algorithm is currently running on the trailing tidal tail and bifurcated pieces. We will soon have a self-consistent model for the density of the smooth component of the stellar halo and the largest tidal streams. The N -body application has been implemented for fitting dwarf galaxy progenitor properties only, and is in the testing stages. We use an Earth-Mover Distance method to measure goodness-of-fit for density of stars along the tidal stream. We will add additional spatial dimensions as well as kinematic measures in a piecemeal fashion, with the eventual goal of fitting the orbit and parameters of the Milky Way potential (and thus the density distribution of dark matter) using multiple tidal streams.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{newberg2013milkyway,
  author = {Heidi Jo Newberg and Matthew Newby and Travis Desell and Malik Magdon‐Ismail and Bolesław K. Szymański and Carlos A. Varela},
  title = {{MilkyWay@home: Harnessing volunteer computers to constrain dark matter in the Milky Way}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1017/s1743921313006273},
}
Figure