Abstract
Previous studies have been conducted to assess the association of milk and dairy products consumption and oral or oropharyngeal cancer risk, with inconsistent results. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis to explore the role of milk and dairy products consumption on oral or oropharyngeal cancer risk. Databases of PubMed, Embase and Chinese Wanfang database were investigated until June 30th, 2019. The overall and subgroup associations were pooled with odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI). This study involving 4,635 cases and 50,777 participants from 12 publications suggested that an inverse association was found between milk and dairy products consumption and oral or oropharyngeal cancer risk (OR= 0.74, 95%CI= 0.59-0.92; I²= 65.9%, P for heterogeneity = 0.001). Four studies reported milk consumption on oral cancer risk, but no significant association was found (OR= 0.91, 95%CI= 0.61-1.37). Six studies about milk consumption and oropharyngeal cancer risk found that there was a positive association between them (OR= 0.63, 95%CI= 0.44-0.90). Conclusion: Findings from our meta-analysis indicated that milk and dairy products consumption may be associated with decreased risk of oral or oropharyngeal cancer.
Introduction
Oral and pharyngeal cancers represent the eighth most common cancer type globally, with tens of thousands of new cases diagnosed annually. While lifestyle factors like tobacco and alcohol use are well-known risks, the role of diet—specifically dairy consumption—has remained controversial. Previous individual studies have yielded inconsistent results: some suggested dairy is protective, while others found no significant link. Because individual studies often suffer from small sample sizes and limited statistical power, this meta-analysis pools data from multiple studies to provide a more robust estimate of how milk and dairy products influence cancer risk.
Methods
The researchers conducted a systematic review of literature from PubMed, Embase, and the Chinese Wanfang database up to June 2019. The study followed a standard meta-analysis pipeline:
- Inclusion Criteria: Only observational studies involving humans that provided Odds Ratios (OR) and 95% Confidence Intervals (CI) were included.
- Statistical Modeling: A random-effects model was used to pool the data, accounting for expected variation between studies.
- Heterogeneity & Bias: The $I^2$ statistic measured study variance. Sensitivity analyses ("leave-one-out") and Begg’s and Egger’s tests were employed to ensure stability and check for publication bias.
Datasets and Study Characteristics
The analysis pooled data from 12 case-control studies comprising 4,635 cancer cases and 50,777 total participants. The geographic distribution included 6 studies from Europe, 4 from Asia, and 2 from America.
Key Insights
- The Protective Effect of Dairy: An "inverse association" was found—as dairy consumption increases, the risk of these cancers generally decreases. This may be due to high-quality proteins in milk that boost the immune system.
- Anatomical Specificity: Dairy appears more protective against oropharyngeal cancer (middle throat, tonsils, base of tongue) than oral cancer (mouth, gums, front of tongue).
- Regional Variations: The protective effect was statistically significant in European populations (OR = 0.58), but did not reach significance in Asian and American populations.
Results Summary
- Overall Risk: Milk and dairy consumption was associated with an overall OR of 0.74 (95% CI: 0.59–0.92), representing a 26% reduction in risk.
- Oropharyngeal Cancer: The risk reduction was stronger, with an OR of 0.63 (37% reduction).
- Oral Cancer: The result was an OR of 0.91 (95% CI: 0.61–1.37), which was not statistically significant.
- Publication Bias: No evidence of publication bias was found ($P = 0.868$).
Limitations and Future Directions
While promising, several factors limit these conclusions:
- Study Design: All included studies were retrospective case-control studies, prone to recall bias.
- Dairy Diversity: Studies often failed to distinguish between dairy types (e.g., whole vs. skim milk, yogurt vs. cheese), which may have different biological effects.
- Heterogeneity: An $I^2$ value of 65.9% indicates significant differences between study populations or methodologies.
Future research should focus on large-scale prospective cohort studies to confirm these findings and investigate how specific dairy products impact different cancer subtypes.
Summary updated