Military Training: Does It predispose service personnel to Negative Mental Health Issues?

Michael Bonner, Graham EllenderJournal of Mental Health Disorders 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that the intense, identity-remolding nature of military recruit training, characterized by a "total institution" environment, can predispose service personnel to negative mental health outcomes, including depression, anxiety, and PTSD, both during and after their service. It calls for military organizations to research and adapt training methods to mitigate these risks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical question of whether the foundational experience of military recruit training, designed to transform civilians into soldiers, inadvertently creates a vulnerability to negative mental health issues. While military service is known for its inherent stressors, this paper focuses on the initial training phase as a potential predisposing factor. It highlights that this period involves intense physical and psychological challenges, systematic remodeling of civilian identity, and a highly controlled environment where failure to conform can lead to punishment. The authors contend that this environment, even if recruits initially cope, can lay the groundwork for latent mental health challenges that may manifest later, particularly under the extreme stress of operational service. The paper aims to shed light on how this foundational experience might contribute to long-term mental well-being issues for service members.

Methods

This paper is primarily a literature review and conceptual analysis, drawing on existing research, psychological constructs, and anecdotal evidence from military psychology. The authors synthesize findings from various studies on military training, operational stress, mental health outcomes (PTSD, depression, anxiety), and psychological concepts like "locus of control" and "total institutions." They do not present new empirical data or conduct novel experiments. Instead, they analyze and interpret existing literature to build a case for the link between recruit training and negative mental health.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Total Institution" Impact: Military recruit training often functions as a "total institution" (Goffman's concept), where all aspects of life are controlled, individuals are treated uniformly, and activities are rigidly scheduled. This environment can systematically break down civilian identity and instill new behaviors, potentially impacting mental well-being.
  • Locus of Control (LOC) as a Predictor: A strong correlation exists between an "external" locus of control (believing outcomes are due to chance or external factors) and adverse mental health outcomes, including depression. Individuals with a high "internal" LOC (believing outcomes are due to their own actions) are generally more resilient. Recruit training can foster an external LOC, especially in those who enter with less developed social skills or independence.
  • "Brainwashing" for Military Mindset: The paper suggests that recruit training employs methods akin to "brainwashing" (breaking, assimilation, instillation, reaffirming) with the explicit purpose of shattering the civilian mind and instilling a new military one. This process, while necessary for military function, is argued to be inherently psychologically taxing and potentially traumatic.
  • Stigma as a Barrier to Help-Seeking: A significant barrier to addressing mental health issues within the military is the pervasive stigma associated with mental illness. Service members often fear negative career impacts, ostracization by peers, or being perceived as weak, leading them to avoid seeking help.
  • Operational Service as a Trigger: While recruit training may predispose individuals, the actual manifestation of severe mental health issues often occurs during operational service (combat or peacekeeping). The extreme stressors of these environments can trigger latent conditions or create new ones like PTSD, depression, and anxiety.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results in the traditional sense, as it is a review. However, it synthesizes findings that indicate:

  • Mental health-related problems are a significant cause of attrition during basic military training in the US armed services, with depression and anxiety being primary factors.
  • Approximately 7% of US Navy recruits (over 3,000 individuals annually) are discharged for psychological reasons, making it the most common cause of separation.
  • Studies on Australian Gulf War veterans and US service members deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan show increased risks of anxiety disorders, depression, and PTSD following deployment, with combat exposure being a key risk factor.
  • Peacekeeping operations, while often perceived as lower threat, can also expose personnel to a range of stressors that impact mental health, with some studies showing mental health illness comparable to Vietnam War veterans.
  • Approximately 60% of military personnel experiencing mental health problems do not seek help, largely due to stigma.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Anecdotal Evidence: While the authors draw on a military psychologist's experience, some statements may not have a peer-reviewed background, indicating a reliance on anecdotal evidence alongside research.
  • Causation vs. Predisposition: The paper strongly suggests that recruit training predisposes individuals to negative mental health issues rather than directly causing them in all cases. The interplay between training, individual resilience, and operational stressors is complex.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for military organizations to conduct further research into how recruit training can be structured to better meet service requirements without negatively impacting recruits' mental well-being. They also highlight the importance of addressing the stigma surrounding mental health and ensuring adequate support systems are in place for both active-duty personnel and veterans. The responsibility of military and supporting organizations to facilitate follow-up and identify/rectify negative mental health outcomes acquired during service is also stressed.

Summary updated

Abstract

At initial (basic) training recruits from all services and most nations are subject to an intense environment where they are physically and mentally challenged throughout their waking day. Their civilian experiences and identity are systematically remodeled to fit the requirements of the nation’s services. Most recruits are able to cope with this extreme environment, albeit with some impact on their mental wellbeing, whereas those unable to cope either physically or emotionally are discharged from the Military through medical or administrative procedures. The recruit training environment is characterized by being totally controlled by another person (instructor) where they must succeed (perform) and conform to the service requirements or suffer formal and informal punishments. It is contended that this form of totally controlled environment impacts on the recruit’s mental wellbeing. Its effects either manifest immediately at a significant level, necessitating discharge, or occur at a lower level enabling service personnel to remain effective whilst staying in the Military; in some cases, not manifesting until they face the rigours of operational service. Operational service, be it war-like or peacekeeping, is an extremely stressful environment that can trigger latent mental health challenges or create new challenges, including but not limited to, depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder. Negative mental health resulting from Military service can led to self-isolation and marital discord resulting in some instances to homelessness or at worst suicide. It is incumbent on the Military to investigate the manner in which recruit training is conducted, and to determine if changes could reduce the predisposition to negative mental health consequences, both from recruit training and subsequent military service.
BibTeX
@article{bonner2022military,
  author = {Michael Bonner and Graham Ellender},
  title = {{Military Training: Does It predispose service personnel to Negative Mental Health Issues?}},
  journal = {Journal of Mental Health Disorders},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.33696/mentalhealth.2.012},
}
Figure