Microwave diagnostics of flare plasma by the direct fitting method based on data from the Siberian Radioheliograph

Dmitriy Smirnov, Viktor MelnikovSolnechno-Zemnaya 2024 · DOI

This paper presents a sophisticated method for probing the "invisible" engines of solar flares: the magnetic fields and high-energy particles within the solar corona. By applying a genetic algorithm to microwave data from the Siberian Radioheliograph (SRH), the researchers successfully tracked how magnetic field strength fluctuates in real-time during a flare, providing a rare direct look at magnetic energy dissipation.

TL;DR

Researchers used the Siberian Radioheliograph to perform "direct fitting" of microwave spectra, revealing that magnetic fields within solar flares weaken rapidly during peak energy release and recover afterward. This study provides quantitative evidence of magnetic energy being converted into particle acceleration at rates of up to 11 Gauss per second.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solar flares are massive explosions triggered by the sudden reconfiguration of magnetic fields (magnetic reconnection). While we can easily see the light from these flares, measuring the actual physical parameters—like the magnetic field strength ($B$) or the density of accelerated electrons—inside the flaring region is notoriously difficult.

Standard optical and UV observations don't provide direct measurements of the coronal magnetic field. Microwave emission (specifically gyrosynchrotron radiation) is a powerful diagnostic tool because its spectrum is highly sensitive to the local environment. However, extracting physical values from a microwave spectrum is an "inverse problem" with a complex, multi-dimensional landscape where traditional mathematical solvers often get stuck in local minima.

Methods

The authors employed a Direct Fitting Method combined with a Genetic Algorithm (GA) for optimization.

  1. Instrument: They used data from the Siberian Radioheliograph (SRH), which observes the sun in the 3–6 GHz and 6–12 GHz ranges.
  2. Theory: The team used the FastGS codes to calculate theoretical gyrosynchrotron spectra based on seven parameters, including magnetic field strength ($B$), its orientation ($\theta$), plasma density ($n_0$), and the electron energy spectral index ($\delta$).
  3. Optimization: Because the "fitness landscape" of the model is so complex, they used a genetic algorithm. This approach "evolves" a population of potential solutions, using selection and mutation to find the global best fit between the observed and theoretical spectra for both left- and right-circularly polarized light.
  4. Validation: Before analyzing real flares, they ran the algorithm on synthetic "model" sources to prove that the parameters could be recovered accurately even if only a portion of the microwave spectrum was observed.

Datasets

The study analyzed two specific solar flare events recorded by the SRH:

  • January 20, 2022: A GOES class M5.5 flare located near the solar limb.
  • July 16, 2023: A GOES class M1.1 flare located on the solar disk.
  • Calibration Source: A stable, compact sunspot was used as a reference to align and calibrate images across different frequencies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Breathing" Magnetic Field: The most significant finding is the inverse relationship between radiation intensity and magnetic field strength. During the "growth phase" of a flare peak, the magnetic field strength decreases. During the "decay phase," it increases. This is a direct observation of the magnetic field "giving up" its energy to power the flare.
  • High-Speed Dissipation: The rate of magnetic field change is remarkably high. In the January 2022 event, the field dropped at a rate of ~11 G/s. This supports theories of rapid magnetic energy dissipation in the solar corona.
  • Robustness of Partial Spectra: The authors demonstrated that even if an instrument doesn't capture the entire microwave peak (the "turnover frequency"), the "optically thick" (rising) part of the spectrum still contains enough information to reliably estimate the magnetic field and its orientation.

Key Results

  • Magnetic Dynamics: In the January 20, 2022 flare, the magnetic field dropped from approximately 990 G to 360 G during the first peak.
  • Electron Hardening: The energy spectral index ($\delta_1$) was found to "harden" (decrease) during the peaks, indicating a higher proportion of very high-energy electrons during the most intense phases of the flare.
  • Spatial Consistency: By tracking the "center of brightness," the authors noted that while the source moved slightly (up to 8 arcseconds), the magnetic field changes were likely intrinsic to the plasma rather than just an effect of the source moving to a different location.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplicity: The current fitting assumes a homogeneous "box" model for the radio source. In reality, flare loops are complex, 3D structures with varying densities and field strengths.
  • Spatial Resolution: While the SRH is a major step forward, its resolution still blends some fine-scale structures. The authors suggest that "unresolved" movements of the source could still influence the results.
  • Future Expansion: The researchers highlight the recent activation of a new 12–24 GHz array at the SRH. This higher frequency range will allow for even more precise diagnostics of the densest and most magnetically intense regions of solar flares, potentially resolving the "moving source" vs. "field dissipation" ambiguity.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we analyze images and the frequency spectrum of microwave emission in the maximum of brightness distribution in the January 20, 2022 and July 16, 2023 flares recorded by the Siberian Radioheliograph in the 3–6 GHz and 6–12 GHz ranges. We use the obtained spectrum data for radio diagnostics of magnetic field strength and orientation, plasma density, and parameters of accelerated particles in a radio source. The radio diagnostics is carried out by a method based on minimizing the functional containing the intensities of theoretically calculated and observed frequency spectra of left-polarized and right-polarized emission. Since the form of such a multidimensional functional is quite complex, and it is not possible to minimize it by standard approaches, we employ a genetic minimization method. The radio diagnostics allows us to determine features of the dynamics of the magnetic field intensity and orientation, as well as the density and the energy spectral index of non-thermal electrons in the region of maximum brightness of the radio source. We have found that during the growth phase of the main radiation peaks the magnetic field decreases, whereas during the decay phase, on the contrary, it increases. The rate of these changes varies from a few G/s to 11 G/s for the January 20, 2022 flare and is about 1 G/s for the July 16, 2023 flare.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{smirnov2024microwave,
  author = {Dmitriy Smirnov and Viktor Melnikov},
  title = {{Microwave diagnostics of flare plasma by the direct fitting method based on data from the Siberian Radioheliograph}},
  booktitle = {Solnechno-Zemnaya},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.12737/szf-103202404},
}
Figure