Microstructure Turbulence Measurement in the Northern South China Sea from a Long-Range Hybrid AUV

Yunli Nie, Xin Luan, Yan Huang, Libin Du, Dalei Song, Xiuyan LiuSensors 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hybrid AUV designed for high-resolution ocean turbulence measurements. By combining glider and AUV capabilities, it successfully collected continuous data in the Northern South China Sea, revealing how a strong thermocline acts as a "barrier" to energy transfer and significantly impacts mixing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding ocean turbulence is crucial for processes like contaminant dispersal, nutrient transport, and energy dissipation. Traditional methods for measuring turbulence, such as vertical profilers, are limited in their ability to capture spatial variability, especially horizontally. While AUVs and gliders have been developed for this purpose, there's a need for instruments that can efficiently cover large areas with both vertical and horizontal resolution over extended periods. This paper addresses the challenge of obtaining comprehensive, high-resolution turbulence data in complex ocean environments by developing and deploying a versatile hybrid AUV.

Methods

The core of this research is the development and deployment of a long-range hybrid autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV). This AUV uniquely combines the characteristics of a conventional AUV (propulsion, maneuverability) with those of a buoyancy-driven glider (efficient vertical movement). This hybrid design allows for flexible motion modes, including:

  • Glider mode: Yo-yo profiles for efficient vertical sampling.
  • Cruise mode: Forward propulsion for horizontal transects.
  • Drift mode: Low-power operation for extended observation.
  • Combined modes: To optimize data collection strategies.

For turbulence measurements, the AUV is equipped with a Cross-platform instrument for microstructure turbulence measurements (CPMTM). This instrument includes:

  • Shear probes: To measure velocity shear, a key indicator of turbulence.
  • Fast thermistor: For microstructure temperature fluctuations.
  • 3-axis accelerometer: To measure vehicle vibration, which can be used to filter out noise from the shear data.
  • Seabird CTD and Doppler Velocity Log (DVL): For essential hydrographic and navigation data.

Data processing involved converting raw shear probe voltage to velocity shear, screening data for validity (AUV speed > 0.4 m/s), removing singular data points, and applying bandpass filtering to isolate turbulence signals. Shear spectra were analyzed using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) and a Goodman method to remove vehicle motion noise. The dissipation rate (ε) was then estimated by integrating the wavenumber spectra, referencing the Nasmyth spectrum for normalization. Diapycnal diffusivity (Kp) was calculated using the Osborn relation.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected during a field experiment in the Northern South China Sea (nSCS) from September 10th to 17th, 2020. The experiment involved ten continuous profiles covering a horizontal span of 25 km and a depth of 200 m. The data collected included:

  • Turbulence microstructure data (velocity shear, dissipation rate, diapycnal diffusivity).
  • Hydrographic data (temperature, salinity, potential density).
  • AUV flight performance data (depth, heading, roll, pitch, vertical speed, horizontal speed).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on collecting novel in-situ data using the developed AUV.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid AUVs are powerful tools for ocean turbulence: The study demonstrates that a hybrid AUV can effectively collect high-quality, high-resolution turbulence data over large spatial scales, bridging the gap between traditional instruments and pure AUV/glider platforms.
  • The thermocline as a "barrier": The research highlights the significant role of the thermocline in the nSCS as a "barrier" that effectively damps the transfer of wind and heat energy from the surface mixed layer to deeper waters, leading to reduced turbulence below it.
  • Spatial variability of turbulence: The data reveals distinct differences in turbulence intensity between the surface mixed layer, the thermocline, and the deeper ocean, underscoring the importance of high-resolution sampling to capture these variations.
  • High-quality data validation: The agreement between the two shear probes and the excellent match of the noise-reduced shear spectra with the Nasmyth spectrum provide strong validation for the AUV's measurement capabilities.

Key Results

  • The hybrid AUV demonstrated stable flight performance, meeting the requirements for turbulence observation.
  • Ten continuous turbulence profiles were collected over a 25 km horizontal span and 200 m depth.
  • The dissipation rate (ε) ranged from 1.41 × 10⁻¹⁰ to 4.18 × 10⁻⁷ W·kg⁻¹.
  • Higher dissipation rates (10⁻⁹ to 10⁻⁸ W·kg⁻¹) were observed in the surface mixed layer, attributed to wind forcing.
  • In the thermocline (40-150 m), dissipation rates were lower (10⁻⁹.⁵ to 10⁻⁹ W·kg⁻¹), indicating reduced mixing.
  • Diapycnal diffusivity (Kp) ranged from 10⁻⁶ to 10⁻⁴ m²·s⁻¹, with higher values in the surface mixed layer and upper thermocline.
  • The noise-reduced shear spectra from the AUV's probes showed excellent agreement with the theoretical Nasmyth spectrum.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data contamination at upper 10m: The authors note that data from the upper 10 meters was deleted due to contamination from the hybrid AUV's tilt. This suggests a need for improved stabilization or filtering techniques for near-surface measurements.
  • AUV motion artifacts: While efforts were made to filter out vehicle motion noise (e.g., using accelerometer data and Goodman method), residual effects might still influence the most sensitive measurements, particularly at the limits of detection.
  • Future work: The paper implicitly suggests that this hybrid AUV platform is a powerful addition to oceanographic research. Future work could involve deploying this AUV in other oceanographic regions to study turbulence dynamics under different stratification and forcing conditions, and further refining data processing algorithms to improve near-surface data quality. The ability to survey large areas over long durations also opens avenues for studying long-term turbulent processes and their impact on ocean circulation and biogeochemistry.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study describes the development of a long-range hybrid autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV) for ocean turbulence measurement. It is a unique instrument, combining the characteristics of the conventional AUV and the buoyancy-driven glider, with a variety of flexible motion modes, such as cruise mode, glider mode, drift mode, and combination of multiple motion modes. The hybrid AUV was used for continuous turbulence measurement in the continental slope of the northern South China Sea in 2020. A total of ten continuous profiles were completed covering a horizontal span of 25 Km and a depth of 200 m. The hybrid AUV was operated in the combined glider and cruise mode. The hybrid AUV’s flight performance was stable and satisfied the requirement for turbulence observation. The measured velocity shears from both probes were in good agreement, and the noise-reduced shear spectra were in excellent agreement with the Nasmyth spectrum. The water column in the study area was highly stratified, with a thick thermocline. The dissipation rate (ε) varied from 1.41 × 10−10 to 4.18 × 10−7 W·kg−1. In the surface mixed layer, high values of ε (10−9∼10−8 W·kg−1) were observed toward the water surface. In the thermocline, ε was 10−9.5∼10−9 W·kg−1, which was smaller than the level of the surface mixed layer. This result was mainly because of the strong “barrier”-like thermocline, which damped the transmission of wind and heat energy from the surface mixed layer to the deep layer. Overall, this study demonstrates the utility of hybrid AUVs for collecting oceanic turbulence measurements. They are a powerful addition to traditional turbulence instruments, as they make it possible to survey large areas to obtain high-quality and high-resolution data in both vertical and horizontal directions over long durations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nie2023microstructure,
  author = {Yunli Nie and Xin Luan and Yan Huang and Libin Du and Dalei Song and Xiuyan Liu},
  title = {{Microstructure Turbulence Measurement in the Northern South China Sea from a Long-Range Hybrid AUV}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=TtlZ6wes7H},
}
Figure