Microstructural, Mechanical, and Durability Related Similarities in Concretes Based on OPC and Alkali-Activated Slag Binders

Kirk Vance, Matthew Aguayo, Akash Dakhane, Deepak Ravikumar, Jitendra Jain, Narayanan NeithalathInternational Journal of Concrete Structures and Materials 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Alkali-activated slag (AAS) concretes offer a sustainable alternative to traditional Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC), yet their adoption in large-scale infrastructure requires a deep understanding of their performance relative to conventional standards. This study provides a comprehensive side-by-side comparison of AAS and OPC-based binders, focusing on reaction kinetics, compressive strength, microstructural features, and chloride transport resistance. The results demonstrate that by optimizing the activator modulus ($M_s$), AAS systems can achieve mechanical and durability characteristics that are equivalent to, or even surpass, those of high-performance OPC blends.

Introduction: The Environmental Imperative

The production of Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) is a significant contributor to global carbon emissions, accounting for approximately 5% of the world's $CO_2$ output. To mitigate this environmental impact, the construction industry is exploring "clinkerless" binders such as alkali-activated slag (AAS). AAS utilizes ground granulated blast furnace slag—a byproduct of steel manufacturing—activated by chemical solutions. However, for these materials to transition from the laboratory to large-scale infrastructure, engineers require evidence that they behave predictably and reliably compared to the "gold standard" of OPC.

Methodology

The researchers evaluated several binder systems:

  • Control: Plain OPC.
  • Modified OPC: Blends containing 20% Fly Ash (FA) or 6% Silica Fume (SF).
  • AAS: Slag activated with sodium silicate solutions, varying the activator modulus ($M_s$)—the ratio of $SiO_2$ to $Na_2O$—between 1.0 and 2.0.

The study employed isothermal calorimetry to track reaction kinetics, Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MIP) for pore structure analysis, and electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) to map internal microstructures. Durability was assessed through Rapid Chloride Permeability (RCPT) and Non-Steady State Migration (NSSM) tests.

Key Insights: Optimizing the Chemical "Glue"

A critical finding of the study is the role of the activator modulus ($M_s$). While higher alkalinity (lower $M_s$) triggers a rapid initial reaction, a higher silica content (higher $M_s$) is necessary for long-term strength and a refined pore structure.

Isothermal calorimetric response of AAS binders showing the influence of activator modulus (Ms) on reaction kinetics.

As shown in the calorimetric data, increasing the $M_s$ shifts the reaction peaks, indicating a change in the timing of the chemical activation. An $M_s$ of 2.0 was identified as the "sweet spot," balancing initial reaction rates with superior long-term performance.

Mechanical Performance and Microstructural Equivalence

Despite the chemical differences between the C-A-S-H gel in AAS and the C-S-H gel in OPC, their physical architectures are remarkably similar. Both systems reached total porosities of 20–23% with nearly identical critical pore sizes. Furthermore, electrical impedance models revealed that the resistance of connected pores in AAS falls within the same range as high-performance OPC, providing a non-destructive "fingerprint" of material quality.

Comparison of compressive strength development for (a) OPC-based systems and (b) AAS systems with varying activator moduli.

The strength development curves illustrate that AAS with an $M_s$ of 2.0 achieved 28-day strengths (~75 MPa) that exceeded those of plain OPC and were comparable to silica fume-modified blends. This confirms that AAS is not merely a "fringe" material but a robust mechanical peer to traditional cement.

Durability and Service Life

AAS systems exhibited exceptional resistance to chloride ion transport, a primary cause of reinforced concrete degradation. In non-steady state migration tests, 28-day-old AAS concrete performed as well as 90-day-old silica fume-modified OPC. This suggests that AAS could significantly extend the service life of structures in harsh, chloride-rich environments, such as coastal infrastructure.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that performance-equivalent alkali-activated slag systems can be proportioned to meet the demands of modern construction. By carefully selecting the activator chemistry, AAS can match the mechanical and microstructural fingerprints of OPC while offering a significantly lower environmental footprint. Future work will focus on long-term stability factors such as carbonation and leaching to further solidify the case for AAS in global infrastructure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alkali-activated slag concretes are being extensively researched because of its potential sustainability-related benefits. For such concretes to be implemented in large scale concrete applications such as infrastructural and building elements, it is essential to understand its early and long-term performance characteristics vis-à-vis conventional ordinary portland cement (OPC) based concretes. This paper presents a comprehensive study of the property and performance features including early-age isothermal calorimetric response, compressive strength development with time, microstructural features such as the pore volume and representative pore size, and accelerated chloride transport resistance of OPC and alkali-activated binder systems. Slag mixtures activated using sodium silicate solution (SiO2-to-Na2O ratio or Ms of 1–2) to provide a total alkalinity of 0.05 (Na2O-to-binder ratio) are compared with OPC mixtures with and without partial cement replacement with Class F fly ash (20 % by mass) or silica fume (6 % by mass). Major similarities are noted between these binder systems for: (1) calorimetric response with respect to the presence of features even though the locations and peaks vary based on Ms, (2) compressive strength and its development, (3) total porosity and pore size, and (4) rapid chloride permeability and non-steady state migration coefficients. Moreover, electrical impedance based circuit models are used to bring out the microstructural features (resistance of the connected pores, and capacitances of the solid phase and pore-solid interface) that are similar in conventional OPC and alkali-activated slag concretes. This study thus demonstrates that performance-equivalent alkali-activated slag systems that are more sustainable from energy and environmental standpoints can be proportioned.
BibTeX
@article{vance2014microstructural,
  author = {Kirk Vance and Matthew Aguayo and Akash Dakhane and Deepak Ravikumar and Jitendra Jain and Narayanan Neithalath},
  title = {{Microstructural, Mechanical, and Durability Related Similarities in Concretes Based on OPC and Alkali-Activated Slag Binders}},
  journal = {International Journal of Concrete Structures and Materials},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/s40069-014-0082-3},
}
Figure