Microseismic positioning of an isolated working face under complex geological conditions and its engineering application

L. ZhaoFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a comprehensive four-part framework—spanning signal categorization, arrival-time picking, and optimization—to accurately locate microseismic events in complex mining environments. By integrating dual-phase (P and S wave) data with a novel variable-step search algorithm, the researchers achieved a 99.4% phase recognition accuracy and significantly reduced positioning errors compared to traditional industry-standard methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In deep underground mining, "isolated working faces" (sections of coal surrounded by previously mined areas) are prone to high stress and sudden structural failures like rockbursts. Monitoring microseismic activity—tiny tremors caused by rock fracturing—is essential for safety.

However, complex geological conditions create a "noisy" environment where traditional methods struggle. Standard algorithms like STA/LTA (Short-Term Average/Long-Term Average) often fail to distinguish between actual signals and background noise, or they struggle to precisely "pick" the arrival times of different seismic waves (P-waves and S-waves). Furthermore, traditional optimization algorithms used to calculate the source location often get stuck in local minima or require pre-measured wave velocities that are difficult to obtain accurately in changing strata.

Methods

The authors propose an integrated pipeline consisting of four novel components:

  1. Adaptive Rotational Categorization: A pre-processing step that uses adaptive high-pass filtering and zero-crossing rates to identify and group seismic phases, filtering out invalid background noise more effectively than static window methods.
  2. TFA-DC Method (Time-Frequency Analysis - Downhill Comparison): This method uses power density spectrograms and FIR band-pass filtering to simultaneously identify the exact arrival of the P-wave and the peak of the S-wave.
  3. Variable-Step Accelerated Search: A new optimization algorithm designed to find the seismic source coordinates. Unlike Genetic Algorithms (GA) or Simulated Annealing (SA), which can be computationally expensive or unstable, this method adjusts its search "stride" dynamically to converge on the global minimum faster and more reliably.
  4. TD-DL Method (Dual-Phase Seismic Source Location): A joint inversion approach that uses both P-wave and S-wave data in a single objective function. Crucially, it treats wave velocity as a variable to be solved, removing the need for error-prone manual velocity measurements.

The researchers also developed a "one-click" Matlab-based software suite to make these tools accessible to mine engineers.

Datasets

The methods were validated using real-world data from the Tashan Mine in Datong, China, specifically the 8204–2 isolated working face.

  • Field Data: 168 microseismic signal segments collected from seven monitoring stations.
  • Validation Data: Data from controlled blasting at the mine was used as a "ground truth" to compare the calculated source locations against known coordinates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Dual Phases: Most traditional systems rely heavily on P-wave arrivals. By mathematically linking P-wave and S-wave data into a single objective function, the authors found they could "offset" the errors inherent in picking just one phase, leading to much higher positioning stability.
  • Moving Beyond Fixed Velocity: One of the biggest headaches in geophysics is that wave velocity changes as rock density and stress change. By including velocity as an independent variable in the search algorithm, the system becomes self-correcting.
  • Efficiency via Variable Steps: The "aha moment" for the optimization was realizing that fixed-step searches are either too slow or too imprecise. The variable-step approach allows the algorithm to "sprint" toward the general area of the source and then "crawl" to find the exact coordinate.

Key Results

  • Higher Accuracy: The adaptive recognition method reached 99.4% accuracy, a 4.8% improvement over the improved STA/LTA method.
  • Zero Failure Rate: The TFA-DC picking method achieved a 0% failure ratio in identifying wave arrivals, even in low signal-to-noise conditions.
  • Superior Stability: In comparative tests against Genetic Algorithms and Simulated Annealing, the variable-step search method showed a standard deviation of 0 for the objective function value and location error, indicating perfect convergence consistency.
  • Reduced Error: The TD-DL positioning method reduced calculation errors by 9.5% for P-waves and 14.5% for S-waves compared to traditional single-phase methods.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note a specific technical limitation: because of the smoothing effect of band-pass filtering, the P-wave arrival picked by the TFA-DC method is often slightly earlier than the actual physical arrival. Conversely, the S-wave is picked at its peak rather than its start, which is slightly later than the actual arrival.

While the dual-phase objective function helps mitigate these offsets, future work could focus on refining the filtering process to narrow these time windows even further. Additionally, the current model assumes a relatively uniform velocity for both phases; future iterations could explore more complex, multi-layered velocity models for even more heterogeneous geological strata.

Summary updated

Abstract

In view of the inability to accurately locate vibrations in isolated workings under complex geological conditions, an adaptive rotational categorization method, a downhill comparison method based on time-frequency analysis (TFA-DC method), a variable-step acceleration search method, and a dual-phase seismic source location method (TD-DL method) are proposed. A set of integrated software with features of “visualization”, “interactive” and “one-click” was developed for microseismic data processing. Results show that compared with the improved STA/LTA method, the recognition accuracy of the island working face microseismic signal by the adaptive wheel classification method is increased by 4.8%. Compared with the improved STA/LTA method, the TFA-DC method has the advantage that it can simultaneously pick up the exact p wave and the peak S wave, and the failure ratio is 0. Compared with simulated annealing algorithm and genetic algorithm, stepwise accelerated search method has better results. The standard deviation of objective function value, location error and wave velocity error are all 0. Method improves the positioning of the TD - DL detector coordinates, dual phase and coherence of known information, such as the positioning result positioning error is only the p wave and S wave ChanZhen phase positioning method of 9.5% and 14.5%, to a certain extent offset the p wave and S wave ChanZhen phase calculation of the positioning error, so as to improve the effect of source localization precision of the inversion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023microseismic,
  author = {L. Zhao},
  title = {{Microseismic positioning of an isolated working face under complex geological conditions and its engineering application}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2022.1043790},
}
Figure