Microbial coexistence through chemical-mediated interactions

Lori Niehaus, Ian Boland, Minghao Liu, Kevin Chen, David Fu, Catherine Henckel, Kaitlin Chaung, Suyen Espinoza Miranda, Samantha Dyckman, Matt Crum, Sandra Dedrick, Wenying Shou, Babak MomenibioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a computational model that explicitly incorporates chemical mediators to understand how microbial species coexist. They found that facilitative interactions and self-restraint are key drivers of coexistence, while direct inhibition of other species is detrimental. This work highlights the importance of understanding the mechanisms of interaction, not just their net effect on fitness, for predicting microbial community stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how diverse microbial species can stably coexist within a community is a fundamental question in ecology with significant implications for fields like synthetic biology and environmental engineering. While many studies have explored factors influencing coexistence, a major gap has been the neglect of the specific mechanisms by which species interact. Previous models often simplified interactions to direct fitness effects between pairs of species, overlooking the crucial role of chemical mediators (like metabolites or waste products) that can create indirect interactions and complex community dynamics. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and validating a model that explicitly accounts for these chemical mediators.

Methods

The authors developed a mechanistic model that simulates microbial community assembly through an "enrichment" process. This process mimics experimental conditions where a diverse initial pool of species is grown and periodically diluted, allowing a subset of species to persist and potentially coexist. The model explicitly incorporates:

  • Chemical Mediators: Species produce and consume various chemicals, which in turn influence the growth rates of other species.
  • C-links and f-links: "c-links" represent the production or consumption of chemicals by species, while "f-links" represent the fitness influence of chemicals on species.
  • Interaction Types: Influences can be facilitative (promoting growth) or inhibitory (hindering growth), and can be directed towards oneself ("self-restraint") or other species.
  • Mediator Properties: The model distinguishes between "depletable" mediators (consumed or degraded) and "reusable" mediators (unaffected by recipients).

They then used this model to simulate numerous community assembly scenarios and analyzed the characteristics of communities that achieved stable coexistence. To validate their approach, they also compared their mechanistic model's predictions to those of simpler "pairwise fitness" models, which abstract away the mediator details.

Datasets

The paper does not use external datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies on simulated data generated by their custom computational model. They also reference experimental data from previous studies to inform the functional forms of their model's interactions (e.g., linear inhibition, saturable facilitation).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mechanisms Matter: The way species interact (e.g., through depletable vs. reusable chemicals) is as important as the net effect of the interaction for determining coexistence.
  • Facilitation is Favored: Communities that achieve coexistence tend to have a higher proportion of facilitative interactions, where one species benefits another.
  • Self-Restraint is Key: Species that produce self-inhibitory chemicals (self-restraint) also contribute positively to coexistence. This acts as an internal feedback mechanism that can prevent a species from outcompeting others.
  • Inhibition is Detrimental: Direct inhibition of other species, while seemingly a competitive strategy, actually hinders coexistence.
  • Depletable Mediators Enhance Coexistence: Interactions mediated by chemicals that are consumed or degraded are more conducive to coexistence than those mediated by reusable chemicals.
  • Pairwise Models Fall Short: Simple pairwise models, which ignore the underlying mechanisms and shared mediators, often fail to accurately predict microbial coexistence, especially when interactions are complex.

Key Results

  • Simulations showed that facilitation and self-restraint were significantly enriched in coexisting communities compared to the initial species pool.
  • Conversely, inhibition of other species was disfavored in coexisting communities.
  • "Knock-out" experiments demonstrated that removing facilitative links often led to reduced species richness, indicating a causal role in coexistence. Removing self-restraint had a moderate impact, while removing inhibition of others sometimes even benefited coexistence.
  • The model predicted that depletable mediators significantly increase the likelihood of coexistence compared to reusable mediators.
  • Pairwise models (like Lotka-Volterra) were shown to underestimate coexistence in communities with depletable mediators and overestimate it in communities with reusable mediators, highlighting the limitations of ignoring interaction mechanisms.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Experimental Validation: While their model is constrained by experimental observations of interaction forms, rigorous experimental validation of specific predictions requires well-characterized microbial systems with known interactions and mediators, which are currently scarce.
  • Simplified Assumptions: The model assumes additive effects of multiple mediators and does not incorporate evolutionary changes, species behavior plasticity, or intrinsic heterogeneity within populations.
  • Network Architecture: While they explored binomial and power-law network architectures, more complex and realistic network structures could be investigated.
  • Environmental Factors: The model assumes abundant shared resources. Future work could explore how resource scarcity influences coexistence, potentially favoring species with lower intrinsic fitness.
  • Beyond Pairwise: The study strongly advocates for mechanistic, mediator-explicit models over pairwise models for predicting microbial coexistence, suggesting this approach is crucial for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Many microbial functions happen within communities of interacting species. Explaining how species with intrinsically disparate fitness can coexist is important for applications such as manipulating host-associated microbiota or engineering industrial communities. Previous coexistence studies have often neglected interaction mechanisms. Here, we formulate and experimentally constrain a model in which chemical mediators of microbial interactions (e.g. metabolites or waste-products) are explicitly incorporated. We construct many instances of coexistence by simulating community assembly through enrichment and ask how species interactions can explain coexistence. We show that growth-facilitating influences between members are favored in assembled communities. Among negative influences, self-restraint, such as production of self-inhibiting waste, contributes to coexistence, whereas inhibition of other species disrupts coexistence. Coexistence is also favored when interactions are mediated by depletable chemicals that get consumed or degraded, rather than by reusable chemicals that are unaffected by recipients. Our model creates null predictions for coexistence driven by chemical-mediated interactions.
BibTeX
@misc{niehaus2018microbial,
  author = {Lori Niehaus and Ian Boland and Minghao Liu and Kevin Chen and David Fu and Catherine Henckel and Kaitlin Chaung and Suyen Espinoza Miranda and Samantha Dyckman and Matt Crum and Sandra Dedrick and Wenying Shou and Babak Momeni},
  title = {{Microbial coexistence through chemical-mediated interactions}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/358481},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure