Microbial coexistence through chemical-mediated interactions

Lori Niehaus, Ian Boland, Minghao Liu, Kevin Chen, David Fu, Catherine Henckel, Kaitlin Chaung, Suyen Espinoza Miranda, Samantha Dyckman, Matt Crum, Sandra Dedrick, Wenying Shou, Babak MomeniNature Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a mediator-explicit model to understand how microbial species with different growth rates can coexist in continuous culture. They found that facilitation and self-restraint are key drivers of coexistence, and that the consumption of chemical mediators by microbes is crucial for promoting stable communities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Microbial communities are essential for many ecological processes and human health, but understanding how diverse species with varying growth rates can stably coexist within these communities remains a significant challenge. Traditional models often simplify species interactions into pairwise fitness effects, which may not accurately capture the complex chemical signaling and resource exchange that occurs in real microbial ecosystems. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how chemical mediators, such as metabolites and waste products, influence microbial coexistence in a continuous growth environment, mimicking conditions found in industrial bioreactors or the human gut.

Methods

The researchers developed a "mediator-explicit model" where interactions between species are mediated by specific chemical compounds. Each species can produce and consume multiple chemicals, and these chemicals can, in turn, influence the growth rates of multiple species. They incorporated two main types of chemical influences:

  • Inhibition: Modeled as a linear decrease in growth rate with increasing inhibitor concentration, or in some cases, a threshold effect.
  • Facilitation: Modeled using a saturating form, similar to the Monod equation, where the effect of a facilitator plateaus at higher concentrations.

They then used this model to simulate "enrichment" experiments. In these simulations, a community of species is grown in excess resources and periodically diluted. Species that drop below a certain abundance are removed. Coexistence is defined as species that persist through this process. To understand the causal role of different interactions, they also performed "knock-out" experiments, where specific influence links were removed from the model to observe the impact on coexistence and stability.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention using large, pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, they generated their own data through simulations based on their model. They also conducted experimental characterizations of chemical facilitation and inhibition using E. coli and Brevibacillus strains, providing data to constrain their model's parameters (e.g., growth rate responses to specific chemicals like acetic acid and erythromycin).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Facilitation and Self-Restraint are Key: The study strongly suggests that positive interactions (facilitation) and negative self-interactions (self-restraint, where a species inhibits its own growth) are crucial for promoting microbial coexistence.
  • Inhibition is Generally Detrimental: While some inhibition is present, the model indicates that "other-inhibition" (one species inhibiting another) is generally detrimental to coexistence.
  • Topology Over Strength: When interactions are strong, the pattern of who facilitates or inhibits whom (the network topology) becomes more important for coexistence than the sheer strength of those interactions.
  • Mediator Consumption Matters: The consumption or degradation of chemical mediators by microbes significantly enhances coexistence. This is because it acts as a negative feedback mechanism, preventing dominant species from completely outcompeting others.
  • Depletable Mediators Favor Coexistence: Communities relying on depletable mediators (those that are consumed) show higher coexistence than those using reusable mediators.

Key Results

  • Simulated enrichment experiments showed that communities with a higher proportion of facilitative interactions had a greater likelihood of achieving higher species richness.
  • The strength of interactions needed to be sufficiently high to drive coexistence beyond what would be predicted by neutral theory (where species with similar growth rates coexist by chance). Beyond a certain point, increasing interaction strength did not further improve coexistence.
  • Knock-out experiments revealed that removing facilitative influences often led to a drop in final species richness, indicating a causal role for facilitation in maintaining coexistence. Similarly, removing self-restraint had a moderate impact, while removing other-inhibition sometimes benefited coexistence.
  • Communities where chemical mediators were consumed (depletable) exhibited significantly higher coexistence compared to communities where mediators were reusable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The model assumes additive interactions between mediators, which might not always hold true in complex biological systems. The exact form of inhibition and facilitation was also simplified for tractability.
  • Experimental Validation: While the model was informed by experimental data, a more rigorous experimental validation with well-characterized systems is needed to fully confirm the model's predictions.
  • Network Structure: The study primarily used randomly assigned interaction networks. Future work could explore how intrinsic modularity or specific network structures might influence coexistence.
  • Environmental Heterogeneity: The model assumes constant environmental conditions and excess resources. Incorporating temporal or spatial heterogeneity, or resource limitation, could provide a more complete picture of microbial community dynamics.
  • Phenotypic Variation: The model does not account for potential evolutionary or phenotypic variations within species populations, which could also impact coexistence.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many microbial functions happen within communities of interacting species. Explaining how species with disparate growth rates can coexist is important for applications such as manipulating host-associated microbiota or engineering industrial communities. Here, we ask how microbes interacting through their chemical environment can achieve coexistence in a continuous growth setup (similar to an industrial bioreactor or gut microbiota) where external resources are being supplied. We formulate and experimentally constrain a model in which mediators of interactions (e.g. metabolites or waste-products) are explicitly incorporated. Our model highlights facilitation and self-restraint as interactions that contribute to coexistence, consistent with our intuition. When interactions are strong, we observe that coexistence is determined primarily by the topology of facilitation and inhibition influences not their strengths. Importantly, we show that consumption or degradation of chemical mediators moderates interaction strengths and promotes coexistence. Our results offer insights into how to build or restructure microbial communities of interest.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{niehaus2019microbial,
  author = {Lori Niehaus and Ian Boland and Minghao Liu and Kevin Chen and David Fu and Catherine Henckel and Kaitlin Chaung and Suyen Espinoza Miranda and Samantha Dyckman and Matt Crum and Sandra Dedrick and Wenying Shou and Babak Momeni},
  title = {{Microbial coexistence through chemical-mediated interactions}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-10062-x},
}
Figure