Micro and macroevolution of sea anemone venom phenotype

Edward G. Smith, Joachim M. Surm, Jason Macrander, Adi Simhi, Guy Amir, Maria Y. Sachkova, Magda Lewandowska, Adam M. Reitzel, Yehu MoranNature Communications 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Venom is a complex trait with substantial inter- and intraspecific variability resulting from strong selective pressures acting on the expression of many toxic proteins. However, understanding the processes underlying toxin expression dynamics that determine the venom phenotype remains unresolved. By interspecific comparisons we reveal that toxin expression in sea anemones evolves rapidly and that in each species different toxin family dictates the venom phenotype by massive gene duplication events. In-depth analysis of the sea anemone, Nematostella vectensis, revealed striking variation of the dominant toxin (Nv1) diploid copy number across populations (1-24 copies) resulting from independent expansion/contraction events, which generate distinct haplotypes. Nv1 copy number correlates with expression at both the transcript and protein levels with one population having a near-complete loss of Nv1 production. Finally, we establish the dominant toxin hypothesis which incorporates observations in other venomous lineages that animals have convergently evolved a similar strategy in shaping their venom.

Introduction

Evolutionary biologists have long sought to bridge the gap between microevolutionary changes within populations and macroevolutionary shifts between species. Venom serves as an ideal model for this inquiry due to its polygenic nature and the intense selective pressures governing its composition. While sequence evolution in toxins is well-documented, the dynamics of toxin expression—the relative proportions of components in the venom cocktail—remain poorly understood. This study investigates whether venom evolves through gradual shifts or rapid pulses and identifies the genomic mechanisms driving these phenotypic changes.

Macroevolutionary Scale and Pulsed Evolution

To understand venom evolution across deep time, researchers analyzed transcriptomes from 29 sea anemone species spanning three superfamilies. Using Ancestral State Reconstruction (ASR), they modeled venom phenotype shifts over millions of years.

Phylogenetic distribution of toxin families and evolutionary model testing.

The analysis revealed that venom does not drift slowly according to a Brownian motion model. Instead, model testing (using Weighted AIC) strongly favored a "Pulsed" evolution model for most toxin families. This indicates that venom phenotypes undergo rapid, dramatic shifts. A toxin family that dominates the venom profile of one species may be nearly absent in a closely related neighbor, suggesting a highly dynamic evolutionary trajectory driven by rapid genomic changes.

The Dominant Toxin Hypothesis

A key finding of this research is the "Dominant Toxin Hypothesis." In 17 of the 29 species studied, a single toxin family accounts for more than 50% of the total venom expression.

PCA of venom phenotypes and mean expression levels of major toxin families.

As shown in the PCA analysis, species cluster based on their dominant toxin profiles. While the NaTx family was likely dominant in the common ancestor of sea anemones, various lineages have independently shifted dominance to other families, such as KTx3 or Actinoporins. This convergent strategy suggests that focusing genomic "volume" on a single effective weapon is an advantageous evolutionary path across the lineage.

Microevolutionary Resolution: Copy Number Variation in Nematostella vectensis

The study transitioned to a microevolutionary scale by focusing on the starlet sea anemone, Nematostella vectensis. By comparing populations along the US Atlantic coast using long-read sequencing (PacBio and Nanopore) and genomic qPCR, the team identified Copy Number Variation (CNV) as the primary engine of rapid venom evolution.

In N. vectensis, the diploid copy number of the dominant toxin gene, Nv1, varies dramatically from 1 to 24 across populations. There is a direct correlation between gene copy number, transcript levels (measured via nCounter technology), and final protein abundance (confirmed by LC-MS/MS proteomics). The most striking example of this dynamic is found in the Florida population, which has undergone a massive genomic contraction. While North Carolina populations maintain Nv1 as the third most abundant protein in their entire proteome, the Florida population has essentially zero production of this primary toxin, representing a "natural knockout" and a complete phenotypic shift at the population level.

Conclusion

Sea anemone venom is a highly dynamic trait driven by "genomic volume control." Rather than slow regulatory mutations, these organisms utilize rapid gene duplication and contraction events to scale toxin production. This "dominant toxin" strategy allows for quick adaptation to changing ecological pressures, though the specific drivers—such as shifts in prey or metabolic costs—remain subjects for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Venom is a complex trait with substantial inter- and intraspecific variability resulting from strong selective pressures acting on the expression of many toxic proteins. However, understanding the processes underlying toxin expression dynamics that determine the venom phenotype remains unresolved. By interspecific comparisons we reveal that toxin expression in sea anemones evolves rapidly and that in each species different toxin family dictates the venom phenotype by massive gene duplication events. In-depth analysis of the sea anemone, Nematostella vectensis, revealed striking variation of the dominant toxin (Nv1) diploid copy number across populations (1-24 copies) resulting from independent expansion/contraction events, which generate distinct haplotypes. Nv1 copy number correlates with expression at both the transcript and protein levels with one population having a near-complete loss of Nv1 production. Finally, we establish the dominant toxin hypothesis which incorporates observations in other venomous lineages that animals have convergently evolved a similar strategy in shaping their venom.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{smith2023micro,
  author = {Edward G. Smith and Joachim M. Surm and Jason Macrander and Adi Simhi and Guy Amir and Maria Y. Sachkova and Magda Lewandowska and Adam M. Reitzel and Yehu Moran},
  title = {{Micro and macroevolution of sea anemone venom phenotype}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-35794-9},
}
Figure