Michel electron reconstruction using cosmic-ray data from the MicroBooNE LArTPC
R. Acciarri, C. Adams, R. An, J. Anthony, J. Asaadi, M. Auger, L. Bagby, S. Balasubramanian, B. Baller, C. Barnes, G. Barr, M. Bass, F. Bay, M. Bishai, A. Blake, T. Bolton, L. Bugel, L. Camilleri, D. Caratelli, B. Carls, R. Castillo Fernández, F. Cavanna, H. Chen, E. Church, D. Cianci, O. Hen, G. H. Collin, J. M. Conrad, M. R. Convery, J. I. Crespo-Anadón, M. Del Tutto, D. Devitt, S. Dytman, B. Eberly, A. Ereditato, L. Escudero, J. Esquivel, B. T. Fleming, W. Foreman, A. P. Furmanski, D. García-Gámez, G. T. Garvey, V. Genty, D. Goeldi, S. Gollapinni, N. Graf, E. Gramellini, H. Greenlee, R. Grosso, R. Guénette, A. Hackenburg, P. Hamilton, J. Hewes, Colton Hill, J. Ho, G. A. Horton-Smith, E.-c. Huang, C. James, J. Jan de Vries, C.-m. Jen, L. Jiang, R. A. Johnson, J. Joshi, H. Jöstlein, D. Kaleko, G. Karagiorgi, W. Ketchum, B. Kirby, M. Kirby, T. Kobilarcik, I. Kreslo, A. Laube, Ye Li, A. Lister, B. R. Littlejohn, S. Lockwitz, D. Lorca, W. C. Louis, M. Luethi, B. Lundberg, X. Luo, A. Marchionni, C. Mariani, J. Marshall, D. A. Martínez Caicedo, V. Meddage, T. Miceli, G.b. Mills, J. Moon, M. Mooney, C. D. Moore, J. Mousseau, R. Murrells, D. Naples, P. Nienaber, J. Nowak, O. Palamara, V. Paolone, V. PapavassiliouJournal of Instrumentation2017 · DOI · arXiv
The MicroBooNE liquid argon time projection chamber (LArTPC) has been taking data at Fermilab since 2015 collecting, in addition to neutrino beam, cosmic-ray muons. Results are presented on the reconstruction of Michel electrons produced by the decay at rest of cosmic-ray muons. Michel electrons are abundantly produced in the TPC, and given their well known energy spectrum can be used to study MicroBooNE's detector response to low-energy electrons (electrons with energies up to ∼ 50 MeV). We describe the fully-automated algorithm developed to reconstruct Michel electrons, with which a sample of ∼ 14,000 Michel electron candidates is obtained. Most of this article is dedicated to studying the impact of radiative photons produced by Michel electrons on the accuracy and resolution of their energy measurement. In this energy range, ionization and bremsstrahlung photon production contribute similarly to electron energy loss in argon, leading to a complex electron topology in the TPC. By profiling the performance of the reconstruction algorithm on simulation we show that the ability to identify and include energy deposited by radiative photons leads to a significant improvement in the energy measurement of low-energy electrons. The fractional energy resolution we measure improves from over 30% to ∼ 20% when we attempt to include radiative photons in the reconstruction. These studies are relevant to a large number of analyses which aim to study neutrinos by measuring electrons produced by νe interactions over a broad energy range.
Introduction: The Challenge of Low-Energy Electrons
To study neutrino oscillations and detect elusive signals like supernova neutrino bursts, physicists need to measure low-energy electrons (5–50 MeV) with high precision. However, liquid argon time projection chambers (LArTPCs) face a unique topological challenge at these energies.
When a low-energy electron travels through liquid argon, it doesn't just leave a single continuous track of ionization. It frequently undergoes bremsstrahlung, emitting radiative photons that can travel tens of centimeters before depositing their own energy via Compton scattering or pair production. Standard reconstruction algorithms often miss these "detached" hits, leading to a significant underestimate of the electron's total energy. This paper tackles the challenge of "re-attaching" these stray photons to the primary electron track to improve energy calorimetry.
Physics of Energy Loss in Argon
At energies around 50 MeV, radiative losses (bremsstrahlung) become comparable to ionization losses. This stochastic process means two electrons of the same initial energy can have vastly different detector signatures—one might be a single short track, while the other might look like a "sprinkle" of detached hits. This makes a one-size-fits-all energy correction impossible; individual photons must be identified.
Electron stopping power in argon showing the crossover between ionization and radiation at higher energies.
Researchers developed a fully automated method to identify Michel electrons and "re-attach" stray photons. The reconstruction pipeline follows several key steps:
Stopping Muon Identification: The algorithm looks for the "Bragg peak"—a characteristic spike in ionization density that occurs just before a muon comes to a complete stop.
Kink Detection: It identifies the vertex where the muon stopped and the Michel electron was emitted at a different angle.
Primary Ionization Clustering: The hits immediately connected to the vertex are clustered as the primary electron track.
Radiative Photon Recovery: The algorithm searches a "cone" (up to 80 cm away and within a 30-degree angle) from the electron's initial direction. It identifies isolated clusters of hits within this region and adds their energy to the total.
MicroBooNE event display showing a primary electron track and detached ionization clusters from bremsstrahlung photons.
By accounting for radiative photons, the MicroBooNE collaboration achieved a significant boost in performance:
Resolution Boost: Including radiative photons improved the fractional energy resolution from >30% to ~20%.
Energy Recovery: At 50 MeV, the "ionization-only" method recovered only 60% of the energy. Including tagged photons increased this to 76%.
Spectrum Shift: In the final data, the peak of the Michel electron energy spectrum shifted from ~20 MeV (ionization only) to ~30 MeV (full reconstruction), aligning much more closely with theoretical expectations.
Data-Simulation Agreement: The energy scales of the data and simulation distributions agreed to within 3%, validating the detector model.
Conclusion
While approximately 24% of the energy at 50 MeV remains uncaptured due to detector thresholds or photons escaping the search cone, this work demonstrates the necessity of photon tagging in LArTPCs. Future experiments like DUNE, located deep underground, will likely achieve even better results with this technique due to a much "quieter" environment compared to surface-level detectors.
Summary updated
Abstract
The MicroBooNE liquid argon time projection chamber (LArTPC) has been taking data at Fermilab since 2015 collecting, in addition to neutrino beam, cosmic-ray muons. Results are presented on the reconstruction of Michel electrons produced by the decay at rest of cosmic-ray muons. Michel electrons are abundantly produced in the TPC, and given their well known energy spectrum can be used to study MicroBooNE's detector response to low-energy electrons (electrons with energies up to ∼ 50 MeV). We describe the fully-automated algorithm developed to reconstruct Michel electrons, with which a sample of ∼ 14,000 Michel electron candidates is obtained. Most of this article is dedicated to studying the impact of radiative photons produced by Michel electrons on the accuracy and resolution of their energy measurement. In this energy range, ionization and bremsstrahlung photon production contribute similarly to electron energy loss in argon, leading to a complex electron topology in the TPC. By profiling the performance of the reconstruction algorithm on simulation we show that the ability to identify and include energy deposited by radiative photons leads to a significant improvement in the energy measurement of low-energy electrons. The fractional energy resolution we measure improves from over 30% to ∼ 20% when we attempt to include radiative photons in the reconstruction. These studies are relevant to a large number of analyses which aim to study neutrinos by measuring electrons produced by νe interactions over a broad energy range.
BibTeX
@article{acciarri2017michel,
author = {R. Acciarri and C. Adams and R. An and J. Anthony and J. Asaadi and M. Auger and L. Bagby and S. Balasubramanian and B. Baller and C. Barnes and G. Barr and M. Bass and F. Bay and M. Bishai and A. Blake and T. Bolton and L. Bugel and L. Camilleri and D. Caratelli and B. Carls and R. Castillo Fernández and F. Cavanna and H. Chen and E. Church and D. Cianci and O. Hen and G. H. Collin and J. M. Conrad and M. R. Convery and J. I. Crespo-Anadón and M. Del Tutto and D. Devitt and S. Dytman and B. Eberly and A. Ereditato and L. Escudero and J. Esquivel and B. T. Fleming and W. Foreman and A. P. Furmanski and D. García-Gámez and G. T. Garvey and V. Genty and D. Goeldi and S. Gollapinni and N. Graf and E. Gramellini and H. Greenlee and R. Grosso and R. Guénette and A. Hackenburg and P. Hamilton and O. Hen and J. Hewes and Colton Hill and J. Ho and G. A. Horton-Smith and E.-C. Huang and C. James and J. Jan de Vries and C.-M. Jen and L. Jiang and R. A. Johnson and J. Joshi and H. Jöstlein and D. Kaleko and G. Karagiorgi and W. Ketchum and B. Kirby and M. Kirby and T. Kobilarcik and I. Kreslo and A. Laube and Ye Li and A. Lister and B. R. Littlejohn and S. Lockwitz and D. Lorca and W. C. Louis and M. Luethi and B. Lundberg and X. Luo and A. Marchionni and C. Mariani and J. Marshall and D. A. Martínez Caicedo and V. Meddage and T. Miceli and G.B. Mills and J. Moon and M. Mooney and C. D. Moore and J. Mousseau and R. Murrells and D. Naples and P. Nienaber and J. Nowak and O. Palamara and V. Paolone and V. Papavassiliou},
title = {{Michel electron reconstruction using cosmic-ray data from the MicroBooNE LArTPC}},
journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
year = {2017},
doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/12/09/p09014},
}