MgAl2O4:Cr3+ and emerald display a different colour but the local symmetry is the same: Microscopic origin

J. M. García‐Lastra, M. T. Barriuso, J. A. Aramburu, M. MorenoarXiv 2008 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The difference in colour between emerald (Be3Si6Al2O18:Cr3+, green) and the Cr3+-doped spinel MgAl2O4 (red) is striking, considering that in both systems colour is due to CrO69- complexes with D3 symmetry and the measured Cr3+-O2- distance is practically the same (1.98 and 1.97 Å, respectively). By means of density functional calculations, it is shown that this surprising difference can reasonably be explained once the electric field, ER, which all lattice ions lying outside the CrO69- complex exert on localized electrons, is taken into consideration. The origin of the different shape of ER in the two host lattices is analysed in detail. It is shown that ER raises (decreases) the 2p(O) levels for Be3Si6Al2O18:Cr3+ (MgAl2O4:Cr3+) along the trigonal axis thus favouring a decrease (increase) of 10Dq. This work demonstrates the key role played by ER—not considered in traditional ligand field theory—for understanding the differences exhibited by the same complex embedded in host lattices with different crystal structures.

Introduction

In gemstone mineralogy, the $Cr^{3+}$ ion is famously responsible for a wide palette of colors. When substituting for aluminum in a crystal lattice, it produces the deep red of ruby and the vibrant green of emerald. Traditionally, these optical properties are explained via Ligand Field Theory (LFT), which posits that the color is primarily a function of the immediate coordination environment—specifically the $CrO_6^{9-}$ octahedral complex and the metal-ligand distance.

However, a significant paradox exists when comparing emerald ($Be_3Si_6Al_2O_{18}:Cr^{3+}$) and chromium-doped spinel ($MgAl_2O_4:Cr^{3+}$). Both minerals feature $Cr^{3+}$ ions in sites with $D_3$ local symmetry and nearly identical chromium-oxygen distances (~1.98 Å). Under standard LFT assumptions, these two systems should exhibit nearly identical colors. In practice, spinel is red while emerald is green. This study investigates the microscopic origin of this discrepancy, identifying the internal electric field of the host lattice as the decisive factor.

Computational Methodology

The researchers utilized Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations performed with the Amsterdam Density Functional (ADF) code. The electronic properties of the $CrO_6^{9-}$ cluster were analyzed in two distinct environments:

  1. In Vacuo: The cluster was treated as an isolated entity in a vacuum.
  2. Lattice-Embedded: The cluster was subjected to the internal electric field ($E_R$) generated by the surrounding ions of the crystal lattice.

The study employed the Perdew-Wang (PW91) functional with high-quality basis sets (Triple Zeta Polarized for Chromium and Double Zeta Polarized for Oxygen). By explicitly incorporating the electrostatic potential ($V_R$) of the host lattice, the model could account for the deformation of chromium electron orbitals caused by the "extended neighborhood" of the crystal.

The Role of the Internal Electric Field ($E_R$)

The core finding of the study is that the "in vacuo" model fails to explain the color difference. When isolated, the difference in the crystal field splitting parameter ($10Dq$) between emerald and spinel is calculated at only ~300 $cm^{-1}$. To account for the observed red-to-green shift, a difference of over 2000 $cm^{-1}$ is required.

The inclusion of the internal electric field ($E_R$) resolves this. In the spinel lattice, the field increases the energy splitting, shifting the absorption toward the red spectrum. Conversely, in emerald, the field decreases the splitting, resulting in the characteristic green hue. This effect is driven by the directionality of the $d$-orbitals; because these orbitals are non-spherical, they are highly sensitive to the specific spatial configuration of the external electric field. Even when local symmetry is identical, the arrangement of ions in the second and third coordination shells creates distinct field shapes that interact uniquely with the $Cr^{3+}$ electrons.

Results and Comparative Analysis

The DFT calculations successfully reproduced the experimental sequence of $10Dq$ values: $Spinel > Ruby > Emerald$.

  • Spinel: The lattice field provides a supplementary contribution ($\Delta_R$) that increases $10Dq$ by approximately 4000 $cm^{-1}$ relative to the vacuum state.
  • Emerald: The field acts to raise the $2p(O)$ levels along the trigonal axis, which effectively decreases the $10Dq$ value.

While the model correctly predicted the color trends, it did show some quantitative overestimation. For instance, the calculated difference between spinel and ruby was 2600 $cm^{-1}$, whereas experimental data suggests a smaller gap of 450 $cm^{-1}$. The authors attribute this to uncertainties in experimental atomic distances and potential $4s$ orbital contamination in the basis sets.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that transition metal complexes cannot be viewed as isolated islands. The "active" electrons are sensitive to the electrostatic environment of the entire host crystal. By accounting for the internal electric field ($E_R$), the study provides a microscopic explanation for why identical local complexes can produce vastly different colors. This highlights a significant limitation in traditional Ligand Field Theory and underscores the necessity of considering long-range electrostatic interactions in solid-state chemistry.

Summary updated

Abstract

The difference in colour between emerald (Be3Si6Al2O18:Cr3+, green) and the Cr3+-doped spinel MgAl2O4 (red) is striking, considering that in both systems colour is due to CrO69- complexes with D3 symmetry and the measured Cr3+-O2- distance is practically the same (1.98 and 1.97 angstroms, respectively). By means of density functional calculations it is shown that this surprising difference can reasonably be explained once the electric field, ER, which all lattice ions lying outside the CrO69- complex exert on localized electrons, is taken into consideration. The origin of the different shape of ER in the two host lattices is analysed in detail. It is shown that ER raises (decreases) the 2p(O) levels for Be3Si6Al2O18:Cr3+ (MgAl2O4:Cr3+) along the trigonal axis thus favouring a decrease (increase) of 10Dq. The present work demonstrates the key role played by ER (not considered in the traditional ligand field theory) for understanding the differences exhibited by the same complex embedded in host lattices which do not have the same crystal structure. Some remarks on the colour of Cr2O3 pure compound are also reported.
BibTeX
@misc{garcialastra2008mgal,
  author = {J. M. García‐Lastra and M. T. Barriuso and J. A. Aramburu and M. Moreno},
  title = {{MgAl2O4:Cr3+ and emerald display a different colour but the local symmetry is the same: Microscopic origin}},
  year = {2008},
  eprint = {0805.3186},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0805.3186},
}
Figure