Metrics and Uniqueness Criteria on the Signatures of Closed Curves

Alex M. Kokot, Ian KleinarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper explores the paradigm of the differential signature introduced in 1996 by Calabi et al. This methodology has vast implications in fields such as computer vision, where these techniques can potentially be used to verify a person's handwriting is consistent with prior documents, or in medical imaging. Motivated by examples regarding key failures in this invariant, we provide new criteria for the correspondence between a curve and its signature to be unique in a general setting. To show this result, we introduce new methods regarding the signature, particularly through the lens of differential equations, and the extension of the signature to include information on higher order derivatives of the curvature function corresponding to the curve and desired group action. We additionally show results regarding the robustness of the signature, showing that under a suitable metric on the space of subsets of $\mathbb{R}^n$, if two signatures are sufficiently close then so too will the corresponding equivalence classes of curves they correspond to, given certain conditions on these signatures.

Introduction

In computer vision and medical imaging, a fundamental challenge is determining if two shapes are "congruent" under various transformations, such as rotation, translation, or shearing (group actions). Differential signatures—geometric fingerprints composed of invariants like curvature and its derivatives—serve as a primary tool for this task. Ideally, a signature should uniquely identify a curve. However, previous research has identified "uniqueness failures" where distinct curves produce identical signatures. This paper addresses these gaps by establishing new mathematical criteria for uniqueness and quantifying the robustness of signatures against noise.

Methods: Signatures as Phase Portraits

The authors re-imagine the signature through the lens of differential equations. By treating the signature as a phase portrait, they can analyze the "flow" of a curve's geometric properties. To resolve cases where a standard signature (plotting curvature against its first derivative) might overlap itself and cause ambiguity, the authors extend the signature to include higher-order derivatives ($S^{(i)}$). This higher-dimensional approach allows self-intersections in lower-order signatures to "dissipate," restoring uniqueness.

A signature represented as a phase portrait. The vector field illustrates the "speed" at which a curve traverses its signature, a key element in the authors' uniqueness proofs.

Another key methodological innovation is the use of "Tube Neighborhoods." Instead of the standard Hausdorff distance, the authors introduce a tube metric to define the distance between two signatures. This provides a more geometrically intuitive framework for comparing curves and proving global uniqueness by partitioning signatures into segments where derivatives are non-zero.

Key Results and Robustness

The paper provides formal proofs (Theorems 8 and 9) that for both Euclidean and Affine group actions, an injective signature uniquely defines an equivalence class of curves, provided the signature avoids the $u$-axis (where the derivative of curvature is zero).

Crucially, the authors demonstrate that the signature method is stable for practical engineering applications. They prove that the distance between two curves is $O(\delta)$, where $\delta$ is the distance between their signatures. This linear robustness ensures that small perturbations in data—such as sensor noise or discretization errors—lead to only small errors in shape identification.

Robustness of the signature method. The plot demonstrates how small perturbations (noise) in the signature correspond to bounded variations in the reconstructed curve properties.

Conclusion

By bridging the gap between differential geometry and differential equations, this research provides a rigorous foundation for the use of signatures in shape recognition. While challenges remain—particularly regarding the computational complexity of higher-order derivatives in noisy environments—the established uniqueness criteria and robustness bounds offer a significant step forward for reliable computer vision systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper explores the paradigm of the differential signature introduced in 1996 by Calabi et al. This methodology has vast implications in fields such as computer vision, where these techniques can potentially be used to verify a person's handwriting is consistent with prior documents, or in medical imaging, to name a few examples. Motivated by examples provided by Hickman in 2011 and Musso and Nicolodi in 2009 regarding key failures in this invariant, we provide new criteria for the correspondence between a curve and its signature to be unique in a general setting. To show this result, we introduce new methods regarding the signature, particularly through the lens of differential equations, and the extension of the signature to include information on higher order derivatives of the curvature function corresponding to the curve and desired group action. We additionally show results regarding the robustness of the signature, showing that under a suitable metric on the space of subsets of $\mathbb{R}^n$, if two signatures are sufficiently close then so too will the corresponding equivalence classes of curves they correspond to, given certain conditions on these signatures.
BibTeX
@misc{kokot2020metrics,
  author = {Alex M. Kokot and Ian Klein},
  title = {{Metrics and Uniqueness Criteria on the Signatures of Closed Curves}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2009.13004},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.13004},
}
Figure