Methods for determining three-dimensional wheelchair pushrim forces and moments: a technical note.

Rory A. Cooper, R.n. Robertson, D.p. VanSickle, Michael L. Boninger, Sean D. ShimadaPubMed 1997

TL;DR

This paper introduces a refined methodology for analyzing the complex 3D forces and moments generated during manual wheelchair propulsion. By directly measuring pushrim forces and moments and employing new analytical techniques, the authors provide a more accurate framework for understanding wheelchair biomechanics, potentially resolving discrepancies in previous research and informing injury prevention strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Manual wheelchair propulsion is a critical form of locomotion, yet its biomechanics are not standardized in terms of how pushrim forces and moments are analyzed. Previous studies have reported differing results, potentially due to variations in calculation methods. A key challenge is accurately determining the "point of force application" (PFA) on the pushrim and the resulting hand moment, which are crucial for understanding propulsion efficiency and the risk of upper limb injuries like carpal tunnel syndrome. Existing methods often rely on assumptions, such as the PFA coinciding with a specific joint, which may not accurately reflect the complex interaction between the hand and the pushrim.

Methods

The authors developed and utilized a system called the SMARTWheel, which directly measures 3D forces and moments at the pushrim. Their technical note focuses on the analytical techniques used to process this data. Key methods include:

  • Direct Measurement: Using a 3D force and torque sensing SMARTWheel to capture forces (Fx, Fy, Fz) and moments (Mx, My, Mz) at the pushrim.
  • Coordinate System Transformation: Employing homogeneous rotation matrices to transform forces and moments between the world coordinate system and the wheel coordinate system.
  • Point of Force Application (PFA) Calculation: A novel approach using the measured moments (Mx, My) and force (Fz) to directly calculate the PFA using Equation 9. This contrasts with previous methods that assumed the PFA was coincident with a metacarpophalangeal (MP) joint.
  • Tangential and Radial Force Calculation: Deriving these forces using the calculated PFA and the force/moment data, providing a more accurate measure than methods assuming negligible hand moment.
  • Wrist Moment Estimation: Calculating the moment applied by the hand (Mw) by considering the difference between the total torque at the wheel axle (Mz) and the torque generated by the tangential force (Ft * R).

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a single veteran with paraplegia who was an experienced manual wheelchair user. The data consisted of five consecutive propulsion strokes collected at a speed of 1.39 m/s and a power output of 14 W on a wheelchair dynamometer. Kinematic data from a three-camera system was synchronized with the kinetic data from the SMARTWheel.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PFA is Dynamic and Variable: The PFA is not static and can vary within the hand throughout the propulsion stroke, especially during the mid-propulsion phase.
  • Kinetic Data for PFA is Crucial: Using kinetic data to determine hand contact position (and thus PFA) is more reliable than kinematic data alone, as the hand can obscure the pushrim from camera view.
  • Assumptions Matter: Previous assumptions about the PFA coinciding with an MP joint or neglecting wrist moment can lead to significant errors in calculating tangential forces and understanding propulsion efficiency.
  • Wrist Moment is Non-Negligible: Wrist moments are present and can influence the accuracy of force calculations if not accounted for. This has implications for understanding the etiology of wrist injuries.
  • Standardization is Needed: The paper highlights the need for standardized methods and terminology in wheelchair biomechanics research to allow for better cross-validation and advancement of the field.

Key Results

  • PFA vs. MP Joint: The PFA calculated using the new kinetic method led the second MP joint by an average of 0.2 radians (approximately 11.5° or 5 cm) for the subject.
  • Tangential Force Accuracy: Using the PFA derived from kinetic data resulted in a larger tangential force (Ft) compared to methods assuming negligible wrist moment, with a mean difference of 35.4 N.
  • Wrist Moment Comparison: The mean difference in estimated wrist moment (Mw) between the kinetic PFA method and the MP joint assumption was small, averaging 0.6 N•m. Both methods indicated a negative (counter-clockwise) wrist moment, which could be relevant to wrist injury mechanisms.
  • Variability: The PFA showed greater variability (higher SDs) near the beginning and end of the propulsion stroke compared to the second MP joint, but was more stable during the mid-propulsion phase when moments were larger.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Subject Data: The study's findings are based on data from a single subject, limiting generalizability. Future work should involve larger, diverse subject populations.
  • PFA Instability: The PFA calculation can become unstable when moments are small, particularly at the beginning and end of the propulsion phase. The authors suggest caution when applying Equation 9 in these "gray regions."
  • Cross-Validation: The paper emphasizes the need for cross-validation of different analytical methods to establish reliable metrics.
  • Clinical Relevance: Future research should focus on how these refined biomechanical analyses can inform clinical interventions and injury prevention strategies for manual wheelchair users. The authors suggest that standardized methods are essential for making progress in understanding the high incidence of upper limb pain and injury.

Summary updated

Abstract

This technical note illustrates that some of the differences that have been reported regarding wheelchair propulsion may be due to the methods used to calculate key variables. Wheelchair ambulation is a very important form of locomotion that lacks a standard pushrim force and moment analysis system. We have developed tools for analyzing upper limb biomechanics during manual wheelchair propulsion. Among the tools is a system that allows the direct measurement of global coordinate forces F(x), F(y), F(z) and corresponding moments. The analytical techniques presented here allow calculation of radial (F(r)) and tangential (F(t)) forces, the determination of point of force application (PFA), and the moment applied by the hand (M(hz)). Our results show that the PFA can be calculated from kinetic data. Comparison of the PFA to the second metacarpophalangeal (MP) joint, calculated from kinematic data and used in previous studies, resulted in a 0.2 radian difference on average, with the PFA showing greater variation near the beginning and ending of the propulsion phase. Analysis of methods for calculating the applied tangential force showed that using the PFA provides a more accurate measurement of this force than the previous method of assuming negligible hand-moment contribution. The hand moment was compared using the calculated PFA and assuming the PFA was coincident with the second MP joint. Both methods provided similar results with a mean difference of 0.6 N x m. The methods presented in this paper provide a framework for analyzing wheelchair propulsion forces and moments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cooper1997methods,
  author = {Rory A. Cooper and R.N. Robertson and D.P. VanSickle and Michael L. Boninger and Sean D. Shimada},
  title = {{Methods for determining three-dimensional wheelchair pushrim forces and moments: a technical note.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {1997},
}
Figure