Methodological considerations for a chronic neural interface with the cuneate nucleus of macaques

Aneesha K. Suresh, Jeremy E. Winberry, Christopher Versteeg, Raeed H. Chowdhury, Tucker Tomlinson, Joshua M. Rosenow, Lee E. Miller, Sliman J. Bensmaı̈aJournal of Neurophysiology 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel methodological approach for chronically implanting electrode arrays in the primate cuneate nucleus (CN) and external cuneate nucleus (ECN). This breakthrough allows for the first time stable recordings from these crucial brainstem structures in awake, behaving animals, paving the way to understanding how touch and limb position information is processed at this early stage of the somatosensory pathway.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The neural basis of touch and limb proprioception (our sense of limb position and movement) has been extensively studied in peripheral nerves and the somatosensory cortex. However, the initial processing stages in the central nervous system – specifically the cuneate nucleus (CN) and external cuneate nucleus (ECN) – remain largely unexplored in primates. This is primarily due to the technical challenges of recording from these small, deep brainstem structures. Previous studies have largely relied on anesthetized or decerebrated animals, which eliminates crucial top-down modulatory signals from the cortex. This significantly limits our understanding of how these signals are encoded and transformed in intact, behaving primates, especially considering potential differences between primate and feline brain structures and their functional roles.

Methods

The authors developed a multi-stage approach:

  1. Acute Mapping: Initially, they performed acute electrophysiological recordings in anesthetized rhesus macaques to map the somatotopic organization (how different body parts are represented) and submodality (touch vs. proprioception) topography of the CN/ECN. This involved using standard microelectrode drives to identify the precise locations and boundaries of these nuclei.
  2. Chronic Implantation Strategy: Based on the acute mapping, they designed and implemented a chronic implantation procedure. This involved:
  3. Surgical Approach: A detailed surgical protocol for accessing the brainstem, including careful dissection and dura opening.
  4. Electrode Array Design: They utilized two types of electrode arrays: Utah Electrode Arrays (UEAs) and Floating Microelectrode Arrays (FMAs). FMAs offered customization in electrode length, which was crucial for targeting neurons at different depths.
  5. Implantation Technique: A refined implantation technique, including the use of adhesives (Tisseel or Vetbond) to stabilize the arrays and prevent expulsion, and careful lead routing to accommodate neck movement.
  6. Data Acquisition and Analysis:
    • Neural Recording: Single-unit and multi-unit activity were recorded using a Cerebus system.
  7. Receptive Field (RF) Mapping: Neuronal responses were characterized by manipulating joints, squeezing muscles, and brushing skin to determine the sensory input driving the neuron. A standardized numeric system was used to classify RF locations along the limb.
  8. Vibrotactile Stimulation: Controlled vibratory stimuli were delivered to assess frequency and amplitude responses.
  9. Center-Out Task: Monkeys performed a center-out task involving robotic perturbations to study responses to active and passive limb movements.
  10. Anatomical Imaging: X-ray and MRI were used post-implantation to confirm array placement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on recordings from live animal subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Primate CN/ECN is Crucial but Understudied: The paper highlights that while peripheral and cortical processing of touch and proprioception are well-understood, the CN/ECN represents a critical, yet largely unknown, processing stage in primates.
  • Chronic Implantation is Feasible and Necessary: The core contribution is demonstrating a viable method for chronic implantation, overcoming the limitations of acute recordings and enabling the study of neural coding in awake, behaving animals.
  • Topographical Organization Revealed: The study provides detailed maps of somatotopic and submodality organization within the primate CN/ECN, showing how touch and proprioceptive information is spatially arranged.
  • Submodality Segregation: Proprioceptive units tend to be more superficial and located more laterally compared to cutaneous units, suggesting a degree of segregation within the nuclei.
  • Somatotopic Progression: A clear distal-to-proximal trend of receptive fields was observed along both the medio-lateral and rostro-caudal axes, providing a functional map of the upper limb representation.
  • Array Design Matters for Longevity: The authors found that specific FMA designs (silicone-reinforced steel wires) and stabilization techniques (Vetbond) significantly improved array longevity and signal quality.

Key Results

  • The study successfully mapped the somatotopic and submodality organization of the CN/ECN in rhesus macaques.
  • They demonstrated that proprioceptive units are generally more superficial than cutaneous units.
  • A distal-to-proximal somatotopic organization was identified, with distal RFs located more medially and rostrally, and proximal RFs more laterally and caudally.
  • Chronic implants, particularly those with improved FMA designs and stabilization, showed improved longevity, with some arrays remaining functional for up to 6 months.
  • Early implants often failed within days or weeks due to lead breakage, highlighting the importance of the design modifications.
  • Sample recordings from awake monkeys showed responses to tactile stimuli (vibration, indentation) and limb perturbations, demonstrating the potential of the chronic interface.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Distinguishing CN and ECN: The authors acknowledge that definitively distinguishing between the CN and ECN based solely on electrophysiological responses is challenging due to similar proprioceptive responses. Histological analysis post-mortem is likely necessary for precise localization.
  • RF Stability Turnover: Receptive fields of units recorded with FMAs showed turnover at a relatively rapid rate (approximately every other day), suggesting movement of the array within the tissue. This is attributed to the mobility of the brainstem.
  • UEA vs. FMA: While UEAs offer greater coverage and more closely spaced electrodes, FMAs were found to be more advantageous for targeting cutaneous digit representations due to their customizable electrode length and insertion technique.
  • Future Work: The developed methodology opens the door to a wide range of future research, including:
  • Detailed characterization of tactile and proprioceptive coding in the CN/ECN of awake, behaving primates.
  • Investigating the influence of top-down cortical modulation on CN/ECN responses.
  • Understanding how sensory information is transformed as it ascends the somatosensory pathway.
  • Exploring the potential for brain-computer interfaces utilizing signals from these nuclei.

Summary updated

Abstract

While the response properties of neurons in the somatosensory nerves and anterior parietal cortex have been extensively studied, little is known about the encoding of tactile and proprioceptive information in the cuneate nucleus (CN) or external cuneate nucleus (ECN), the first recipients of upper limb somatosensory afferent signals. The major challenge in characterizing neural coding in CN/ECN has been to record from these tiny, difficult-to-access brain stem structures. Most previous investigations of CN response properties have been carried out in decerebrate or anesthetized animals, thereby eliminating the well-documented top-down signals from cortex, which likely exert a strong influence on CN responses. Seeking to fill this gap in our understanding of somatosensory processing, we describe an approach to chronically implanting arrays of electrodes in the upper limb representation in the brain stem in primates. First, we describe the topography of CN/ECN in rhesus macaques, including its somatotopic organization and the layout of its submodalities (touch and proprioception). Second, we describe the design of electrode arrays and the implantation strategy to obtain stable recordings. Third, we show sample responses of CN/ECN neurons in brain stem obtained from awake, behaving monkeys. With this method, we are in a position to characterize, for the first time, somatosensory representations in CN and ECN of primates.<b>NEW & NOTEWORTHY</b> In primates, the neural basis of touch and of our sense of limb posture and movements has been studied in the peripheral nerves and in somatosensory cortex, but coding in the cuneate and external cuneate nuclei, the first processing stage for these signals in the central nervous system, remains an enigma. We have developed a method to record from these nuclei, thereby paving the way to studying how sensory information from the limb is encoded there.
BibTeX
@article{suresh2017methodological,
  author = {Aneesha K. Suresh and Jeremy E. Winberry and Christopher Versteeg and Raeed H. Chowdhury and Tucker Tomlinson and Joshua M. Rosenow and Lee E. Miller and Sliman J. Bensmaı̈a},
  title = {{Methodological considerations for a chronic neural interface with the cuneate nucleus of macaques}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00436.2017},
}
Figure