Method to extract minimally damaged collagen fibrils from tendon

Yehe Liu, Nelly Andarawis‐Puri, Steven J. EppellJournal of Biological Methods 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new, gentler method for extracting individual collagen fibrils from tendon tissue using a trypsin-based solution. This technique preserves the fibrils' natural structure and length, unlike harsher methods that can cause damage and shortening, making it ideal for detailed mechanical studies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the mechanical properties of individual collagen fibrils is crucial for comprehending the overall strength and function of connective tissues like tendons. However, extracting these fibrils from tough tendon tissue without damaging them has been a significant challenge. Previous methods often involved harsh treatments like homogenization or drying, which can alter fibril morphology and properties, leading to inaccurate experimental results. This paper aims to provide a less disruptive method for isolating intact collagen fibrils from mammalian tendons, enabling more reliable studies of their native characteristics.

Methods

The core of this paper introduces a novel "trypsin-based extraction" method. The process involves:

  1. Tissue Pretreatment: Tendon tissue is gently cut longitudinally to disrupt the endotenon without severing the entire structure.
  2. Trypsin Extraction Medium Treatment: The tissue is incubated in a solution containing trypsin, which helps to swell the tissue and loosen the collagen fibrils. This step is crucial and differs from simple water swelling.
  3. Fibril Extraction: Swollen tissue is then gently manipulated with tweezers in an aqueous solution, allowing individual fibrils to be released. This manual separation is key to minimizing mechanical damage.

This new method is compared against two others:

  • Water Extraction: A gentler method previously used for sea cucumber dermis, involving swelling in EDTA and then deionized water. This method proved ineffective for mammalian tendons.
  • Mechanical Extraction: A more aggressive approach using tissue homogenization (blending), which is known to be disruptive.

The extracted fibrils were analyzed using:

  • Dark-field light microscopy: To visualize and measure fibril lengths.
  • Scanning electron microscopy (SEM): To examine fibril surface morphology (D-banding) and measure fibril diameters.
  • SDS-PAGE: To assess potential molecular-level damage to collagen by evaluating protein molecular weight distributions.

Datasets

The study utilized the following biological materials:

  • Rat tail tendon
  • Rat patellar tendon
  • Sea cucumber dermis (used as a comparative model due to its known amenability to extraction)

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on evaluating the extraction methods themselves.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Trypsin's Role: The enzymatic action of trypsin, without directly digesting collagen, appears to be key in loosening the extracellular matrix surrounding collagen fibrils in tendons, facilitating their gentle extraction.
  • Mechanical vs. Enzymatic: A gentle enzymatic approach is significantly less damaging to collagen fibrils than aggressive mechanical homogenization. This is evident in both fibril length and structural integrity.
  • Preservation of Native Structure: The trypsin-based method successfully preserves critical structural features like D-banding on the fibril surface and maintains fibril diameter, suggesting minimal morphological alteration.
  • Tendon Specificity: While water extraction works for sea cucumber dermis, it's insufficient for mammalian tendons, highlighting the need for a more robust yet gentle approach for these tougher tissues.

Key Results

  • Fibril Length: Trypsin-extracted fibrils from rat patellar tendons were significantly longer (mean ~150 µm) than those extracted by homogenization (mean ~95 µm). Similarly, sea cucumber fibrils extracted with trypsin were longer and less varied in length compared to homogenized ones. Some trypsin-extracted fibrils exceeded 1000 µm in length.
  • Morphological Integrity: SEM images confirmed that trypsin-extracted fibrils retained their characteristic D-banding patterns, indicating preservation of surface structure.
  • Fibril Diameter: The variation in fibril diameter along the length was comparable between trypsin-extracted and water-extracted sea cucumber fibrils, suggesting no significant diameter alteration by the trypsin method.
  • Molecular Integrity: SDS-PAGE analysis showed no evidence of collagen chain scission or molecular weight changes in either rat tendon or reconstituted bovine collagen fibrils treated with trypsin, indicating no significant molecular-level damage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sub-Fibrillar Damage: While the method shows less damage than homogenization, the authors acknowledge that rigorous proof of undetectable sub-rupture damage is difficult to provide.
  • Mechanism of Trypsin Action: The precise biochemical mechanism by which trypsin facilitates fibril liberation from tendon tissue is not fully elucidated and is suggested for future work.
  • Broader Applicability: While the method is expected to work for other mammalian tendons due to conserved tissue structure, direct testing on human tendons is a logical next step.
  • Biomaterial Design: The method provides a pathway to obtain native collagen fibrils for biomaterial design targets and for studying structure-function relationships across different species.

Summary updated

Abstract

A new method is presented to extract collagen fibrils from mammalian tendon tissue. Mammalian tendons are treated with a trypsin-based extraction medium and gently separated with tweezers in an aqueous solution. Collagen fibrils released in the solution are imaged using both dark-field light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. The method successfully extracts isolated fibrils from rat tail and patellar tendons. To examine whether the method is likely to damage fibrils during extraction, sea cucumber dermis fibril lengths are compared against those obtained using only distilled water. The two methods produce fibrils of similar lengths. This is contrasted with fibrils being shortened when extracted using a tissue homogenizer. Scanning electron microscopy shows the new method preserves D-banding features on fibril surfaces and that fibril diameter does not vary substantially compared with water extracted fibrils.
BibTeX
@article{liu2016method,
  author = {Yehe Liu and Nelly Andarawis‐Puri and Steven J. Eppell},
  title = {{Method to extract minimally damaged collagen fibrils from tendon}},
  journal = {Journal of Biological Methods},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.14440/jbm.2016.121},
}
Figure