Abstract
A new method for the specific surface energy investigation based on a combination of the force spectroscopy and the method of nanofriction study using atomic force microscopy was proposed. It was shown that air humidity does not affect the results of investigation by the proposed method as opposed to the previously used methods. Therefore, the method has high accuracy and repeatability in air without use of climate chambers and liquid cells. The proposed method has a high local resolution and is suitable for investigation of the specific surface energy of individual nanograins or fixed nanoparticles. The achievements described in the paper demonstrate one of the method capabilities, which is to control the growth mechanism of thin magnetic films. The conditions for the transition of the growth mechanism of thin Ni<sub>80</sub>Fe<sub>20</sub> films from island to layer-by-layer obtained via electrolyte deposition have been determined using the proposed method and the purpose made probes with Ni coating.
Introduction
Surface energy is a fundamental property that dictates how atoms stick to a surface, influencing everything from the strength of an adhesive to the performance of a magnetic sensor. In thin-film manufacturing, the ratio of surface energy between the substrate and the deposited material determines the growth mechanism: whether atoms form isolated "islands" (Volmer–Weber growth) or a smooth, continuous "layer-by-layer" coating.
Measuring this at the nanoscale is notoriously difficult. Traditional AFM "force spectroscopy" involves pulling a tip vertically off a surface to measure adhesion. However, in ambient air, a thin layer of water always coats surfaces. When the tip lifts, it creates a water meniscus (a "capillary bridge") that adds a massive, phantom force to the measurement. To get accurate data, researchers usually have to use expensive vacuum chambers or liquid cells. This paper introduces a way to obtain accurate results in ambient air.
The Lateral Separation Method
The authors propose a lateral separation method. Instead of pulling the tip up, they drag it across the surface in "contact mode" and record the cantilever twist (torsion).
- The Physics: When the AFM tip starts moving, it experiences a peak "static friction" force ($F_{st}$) before it begins to slide at a lower "sliding friction" force ($F_{fr}$).
- The Innovation: The authors realized that the difference between these two forces ($F_{ls} = F_{st} - F_{fr}$) is proportional to the energy required to break the static contact. By moving laterally, the tip stays inside the adsorbed water layer rather than fighting to pull out of it, effectively canceling out the capillary force error.
- Modeling: They adapted the Bradley model of contact mechanics to convert these lateral force measurements into quantitative Specific Surface Energy (SSE) values ($\gamma$).
Experimental Validation and Results
To validate the method, measurements were taken on reference samples (Silicon and Gold) and experimental nanostructured $Ni_{80}Fe_{20}$ (Permalloy) films across a humidity range of 34% to 69%.
The most striking result is the humidity independence. While the "normal" (vertical) method saw measured surface energy jump by 300% as humidity increased, the lateral method remained nearly constant. This proves that lateral movement successfully bypasses the meniscus effect.
The lateral method showed a deviation of less than 5% across varying humidity levels, whereas the standard vertical method failed completely in air. For NiFe nanograins, the SSE was measured at 0.27–0.39 N/m for island-growth modes and dropped to 0.15 N/m for the layer-by-layer mode.
Controlling Thin Film Growth
The researchers confirmed a quantitative threshold for growth mechanisms. When the SSE of the film nanograins ($\gamma_f$) is higher than the SSE of the substrate ($\gamma_s$), the film forms rough, clumped islands. By using ultra-short pulses ($10^{-5}$ s) during electrodeposition, they could drop the SSE of the NiFe grains significantly (down to 0.15 N/m). This flipped the energy ratio ($\gamma_f < \gamma_s$), forcing the film to grow in a smooth, layer-by-layer fashion. This resulted in NiFe films with a surface roughness of just 1.5 nm, compared to 14.7 nm in standard DC mode.
Conclusion and Future Work
The lateral AFM method provides a high-resolution, humidity-immune way to measure surface energy in ambient conditions. While parameters like scanning speed and normal load must be carefully controlled, the technique opens new doors for studying biological objects and catalysts. Future work will focus on standardizing correction factors for scanning speeds and testing the Bradley model's limits for complex nanostructures.
Reference: Zubar, T. I., et al. (2020). Method of surface energy investigation by lateral AFM: application to control growth mechanism of nanostructured NiFe films. Scientific Reports. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-71416-w
Summary updated