Methanol to hydrocarbons reaction over HZSM-22 and SAPO-11: Effect of catalyst acid strength on reaction and deactivation mechanism

Jinbang Wang, Jinzhe Li, Shutao Xu, Yuchun Zhi, Yingxu Wei, Yanli He, Jingrun Chen, Mozhi Zhang, Quanyi Wang, Wenna Zhang, Xinqiang Wu, Xinwen Guo, Zhongmin LiuCHINESE 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the methanol-to-hydrocarbons (MTH) reaction over two zeolites, HZSM-22 and SAPO-11, highlighting the critical role of catalyst acidity in influencing reaction pathways, product selectivity, and deactivation mechanisms. The findings reveal that stronger acidity, as seen in HZSM-22, promotes light alkene production and faster cracking of heavier hydrocarbons, while weaker acidity in SAPO-11 favors the formation of longer-chain hydrocarbons.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The conversion of methanol to hydrocarbons (MTH) is a crucial process for producing light alkenes and liquid fuels from abundant non-petroleum resources like coal, biomass, and natural gas, especially given dwindling oil supplies and increasing demand. While various zeolite catalysts have been explored, understanding the intricate reaction mechanisms and deactivation pathways remains a significant challenge. Previous research has pointed to the importance of catalyst topology and acidity. Specifically, this paper aims to elucidate how the acid strength of catalysts with similar one-dimensional 10-ring channel structures (HZSM-22 and SAPO-11) impacts the MTH reaction's activity, product distribution, and deactivation mechanisms. This knowledge is vital for optimizing catalyst design and process conditions for more efficient and selective hydrocarbon production.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to characterize the catalysts and study the MTH reaction:

  • Catalyst Preparation and Characterization:
    • XRD (X-ray Diffraction): To confirm the crystalline structure and phase purity of HZSM-22 and SAPO-11.
  • XRF (X-ray Fluorescence): To determine the elemental composition (Si/Al ratio).
  • SEM (Scanning Electron Microscopy): To visualize the morphology and crystal size of the catalysts.
  • N2 Physisorption: To measure surface area (BET) and pore volume, characterizing the porous structure.
  • NH3-TPD (Temperature Programmed Desorption of Ammonia): To quantify the Brønsted acidity and its distribution.
  • 1H MAS NMR (Magic Angle Spinning Nuclear Magnetic Resonance) Spectroscopy: Used with a bulky probe (perfluorotributylamine) to differentiate between internal and external acidic sites.
  • TGA (Thermogravimetric Analysis): To quantify the amount of coke deposited on spent catalysts.
  • GC-MS (Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry): To identify and quantify organic species retained in the catalysts after reaction, particularly coke precursors.
  • In situ FTIR (Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy): To monitor changes in surface species (Brønsted acid sites and aromatic species) during the reaction in real-time.
  • Catalytic Performance Evaluation:
    • Methanol Conversion Tests: Conducted in a fixed-bed reactor at various temperatures (350-550 °C) to assess activity and product selectivity.
  • 12C/13C-Methanol Isotopic Switching Experiments: Used to trace the reaction pathways and understand the incorporation of new carbon atoms into products.
  • Co-reaction of 13C-Methanol and 12C-1-Butene: Employed to specifically investigate the role of acidic strength in the alkene methylation and cracking pathway.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes self-prepared or supplied catalysts and analyzes reaction products and spent catalysts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Acidity Dictates Reactivity and Selectivity: The most striking finding is how the difference in acid strength between HZSM-22 (stronger acidity) and SAPO-11 (weaker acidity) profoundly influences the MTH reaction. Stronger acidity in HZSM-22 leads to higher activity and a preference for lighter alkenes (C2-C4), while weaker acidity in SAPO-11 favors longer-chain hydrocarbons (C5+).
  • Dual Deactivation Mechanisms: Deactivation occurs via two primary routes: at lower temperatures, it's due to pore blockage by condensed aromatic compounds, and at higher temperatures, it's due to graphitic coke deposition on the catalyst surface.
  • HZSM-22's Rapid Low-Temperature Deactivation: HZSM-22, despite its higher activity, deactivates faster at lower temperatures (<450 °C). This is attributed to the more rapid formation and accumulation of coke precursors within its pore mouths, likely due to its stronger acidity promoting the formation of heavier aromatics.
  • Alkene Methylation-Cracking Dominance: Isotopic switching experiments strongly support the alkene methylation and cracking pathway as the primary mechanism for hydrocarbon formation over both catalysts, rather than the hydrocarbon pool mechanism typically observed in larger-pore zeolites.
  • Temperature's Role in Product Distribution: For HZSM-22, increasing temperature shifts product selectivity from C5+ hydrocarbons to lighter alkenes (ethene and propene), indicating enhanced cracking. SAPO-11 shows less pronounced shifts with temperature.

Key Results

  • Activity: HZSM-22 exhibits higher methanol conversion than SAPO-11 across the investigated temperature range.
  • Product Selectivity:
    • At 350-500 °C, SAPO-11 primarily produces C5+ hydrocarbons.
  • HZSM-22, especially at higher temperatures (450-550 °C), favors ethene and propene.
  • Co-feeding with 1-butene shows HZSM-22 favors C3-C5 hydrocarbons, while SAPO-11 favors C4-C6 hydrocarbons, with HZSM-22 promoting more cracking.
  • Deactivation:
    • Coke deposition increases with temperature for both catalysts.
  • GC-MS analysis of retained species reveals that heavier aromatics contribute to deactivation at lower temperatures.
  • In situ FTIR confirms the loss of Brønsted acid sites and the formation of aromatic species during HZSM-22 deactivation at 400 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on two specific catalysts with one-dimensional channels. The findings might not be directly generalizable to zeolites with different pore structures.
  • While the general mechanisms are elucidated, the precise kinetic parameters and detailed elementary steps of the methylation and cracking reactions are not fully detailed.
  • The paper notes that polymethylated benzene species found in the catalysts might not be efficient hydrocarbon pool species due to the limited channel environment, suggesting a need for further investigation into their role.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that tuning the acidic properties of catalysts is a promising avenue for optimizing MTH processes. This implies further research into modifying acid strength and distribution in various zeolite frameworks.
  • Investigating catalysts with different pore structures to understand how topology interacts with acidity in the MTH reaction would be a logical next step.
  • Further exploration into the precise role of specific aromatic species in deactivation and potential strategies to mitigate their formation could be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2015methanol,
  author = {Jinbang Wang and Jinzhe Li and Shutao Xu and Yuchun Zhi and Yingxu Wei and Yanli He and Jingrun Chen and Mozhi Zhang and Quanyi Wang and Wenna Zhang and Xinqiang Wu and Xinwen Guo and Zhongmin Liu},
  title = {{Methanol to hydrocarbons reaction over HZSM-22 and SAPO-11: Effect of catalyst acid strength on reaction and deactivation mechanism}},
  booktitle = {CHINESE},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1016/s1872-2067(15)60953-6},
}
Figure