Meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies identifies novel loci that influence cupping and the glaucomatous process

Henriët Springelkamp, René Höhn, Aniket Mishra, Pirro G. Hysi, Chiea Chuen Khor, Stephanie Loomis, Jessica N. Cooke Bailey, Jane Whitney Gibson, Guðmar Þorleifsson, Sarah F. Janssen, Xiaoyan Luo, Wishal D. Ramdas, Eranga N. Vithana, Monisha E. Nongpiur, Grant W. Montgomery, Liang Xu, Jenny Mountain, Puya Gharahkhani, Yi Lu, Najaf Amin, Lennart C. Karssen, Kar Seng Sim, Jin‐Moo Lee, Adriana I. Iglesias, Virginie J. M. Verhoeven, Michael A. Hauser, Seng‐Chee Loon, Dominiek D. G. Despriet, Abhishek Nag, Cristina Venturini, Paul G. Sanfilippo, Arne Schillert, Jae H. Kang, John Landers, Friðbert Jónasson, Angela J. Cree, Leonieke M. E. van Koolwijk, Fernando Rivadeneira, Emmanuelle Souzeau, Vésteinn Jónsson, Geeta Menon, Paul Mitchell, Jie Jin Wang, Elena Rochtchina, John Attia, Rodney J. Scott, Parker Magin, Tien Yin Wong, Paul N. Baird, Jing Xie, Michael Inouye, Ananth C. Viswanathan, Xueling Sim, Robert N. Weinreb, Paulus T.v.m. de Jong, Ben A. Oostra, André G. Uitterlinden, Albert Hofman, Sarah Ennis, Unnur Þorsteinsdóttir, Kathryn P. Burdon, R. Rand Allingham, Murray H. Brilliant, Donald L. Budenz, William G. Christen, John H. Fingert, David S. Friedman, Douglas Gaasterland, Terry Gaasterland, Jonathan L. Haines, Peter Kraft, Richard K. Lee, Paul R. Lichter, Yutao Liu, Sayoko E. Moroi, Louis R. Pasquale, Margaret A. Pericak‐Vance, Anthony Realini, Julia E. Richards, Joel S. Schuman, William K. Scott, Kuldev Singh, Arthur J. Sit, Douglas Vollrath, Janey L. Wiggs, Gadi Wollstein, Donald J. Zack, Kang Zhang, Peter Donnelly, Inês Barroso, Jenefer M. Blackwell, Elvira Bramon, Matthew A. Brown, Juan P. Casas, Aiden CorvinNature Communications 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This large-scale meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies (GWAS) has identified 10 new genetic loci associated with the vertical cup-to-disc ratio (VCDR), a key indicator of glaucoma. These findings significantly expand our understanding of the genetic underpinnings of optic nerve cupping and, importantly, demonstrate that individuals with higher genetic predisposition to VCDR have a substantially increased risk of developing primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Glaucoma is a leading cause of irreversible blindness worldwide, characterized by the degeneration of the optic nerve. A crucial clinical measure for assessing glaucoma progression is the vertical cup-to-disc ratio (VCDR), which reflects the size of the optic cup relative to the optic disc. While VCDR is known to be heritable, previous genetic studies had identified only a limited number of genetic loci associated with it, explaining only a small fraction of the disease's genetic variance. This left a significant gap in our understanding of the complex genetic architecture underlying optic nerve cupping and its direct link to glaucoma. The researchers aimed to address this by conducting the largest meta-analysis of GWAS for VCDR to date, seeking to discover new genetic variants and better quantify their contribution to glaucoma risk.

Methods

The study employed a multi-stage meta-analysis approach, a standard but powerful technique in genetic epidemiology for increasing statistical power by combining data from multiple independent studies.

  • Stage 1: A genome-wide meta-analysis was performed on summary data from 10 populations of European ancestry (n=21,094). This stage aimed to identify statistically significant associations (genome-wide significance threshold of P < 5.0 × 10⁻⁸) between single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and VCDR.
  • Stage 2: The top associations from Stage 1 were then tested for replication and cross-ancestry transferability in individuals of Asian ancestry (n=6,784).
  • Stage 3: Further analyses involved adjusting VCDR associations for optic disc area and spherical equivalent to disentangle genetic influences on these related traits. A genetic risk score was also constructed from the identified VCDR loci and tested for association with POAG risk in separate case-control studies.
  • Stage 4: Gene-based tests (using VEGAS software) and pathway analyses were conducted to identify novel loci not captured by single SNP associations and to explore the biological pathways implicated in VCDR.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a large consortium of international studies:

  • European Ancestry Cohorts (Stage 1): 10 populations totaling 21,094 individuals.
  • Asian Ancestry Cohorts (Stage 2): 4 populations totaling 6,784 individuals.
  • Case-Control Studies for POAG Risk: 5 studies used for validating the association between the genetic risk score and POAG.

The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather aggregated existing data from well-established cohorts within the International Glaucoma Genetics Consortium.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Expanding the Genetic Landscape: The identification of 10 novel loci significantly more than doubles the previously known genetic associations with optic disc cupping, providing a much richer picture of the genetic factors at play.
  • Direct Link to Glaucoma Risk: The study moves beyond simply identifying VCDR-associated loci to demonstrating a direct link to POAG risk. The genetic risk score derived from these loci showed a substantial increase in POAG risk for individuals in the highest quintile, highlighting the clinical relevance of these genetic findings.
  • Disentangling Genetic Influences: By adjusting for disc area and spherical equivalent, the researchers were able to differentiate genetic effects specific to VCDR from those influencing overall optic disc size or refractive error, leading to a more precise understanding of the genetic architecture.
  • Biological Pathways Implicated: Pathway analysis pointed towards "negative regulation of cell growth" and "cellular stress response" as key biological mechanisms involved in VCDR and potentially glaucoma pathogenesis. This suggests potential therapeutic targets for neuroprotection.

Key Results

  • 10 Novel Loci: The meta-analysis identified 10 new genetic loci significantly associated with VCDR.
  • Increased POAG Risk: Individuals in the highest quintile of the genetic risk score derived from these loci had a 2.5-fold increased risk of primary open-angle glaucoma compared to those in the lowest quintile.
  • Phenotypic Variance Explained: The identified VCDR loci, along with age and sex, explained 5.1-5.9% of the VCDR phenotypic variability in Europeans, with the new loci contributing 1.6-1.8%.
  • Gene-Based Discoveries: Gene-based testing identified two additional novel genes (REEP5 and PITPNB) associated with VCDR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Variance Explained: While a significant step forward, the identified genetic variants still explain a relatively small proportion of the total VCDR and POAG heritability. This suggests that many more genetic factors, potentially including rare variants or complex gene-gene interactions, remain to be discovered.
  • Ancestry Differences: While cross-ancestry transferability was tested, some differences in allele frequencies and effect directions were observed between European and Asian populations, underscoring the need for diverse population studies.
  • Functional Validation: The paper identifies candidate genes and pathways but does not provide direct functional validation of how these genetic variants influence VCDR or glaucoma. Future work will likely focus on experimentally characterizing the biological mechanisms of these newly identified loci.
  • Therapeutic Implications: The identified pathways related to cell growth regulation and stress response offer promising avenues for developing novel neuroprotective therapies for glaucoma. Further research into these pathways could lead to new treatment strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Glaucoma is characterized by irreversible optic nerve degeneration and is the most frequent cause of irreversible blindness worldwide. Here, the International Glaucoma Genetics Consortium conducts a meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies of vertical cup-disc ratio (VCDR), an important disease-related optic nerve parameter. In 21,094 individuals of European ancestry and 6,784 individuals of Asian ancestry, we identify 10 new loci associated with variation in VCDR. In a separate risk-score analysis of five case-control studies, Caucasians in the highest quintile have a 2.5-fold increased risk of primary open-angle glaucoma as compared with those in the lowest quintile. This study has more than doubled the known loci associated with optic disc cupping and will allow greater understanding of mechanisms involved in this common blinding condition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{springelkamp2014meta,
  author = {Henriët Springelkamp and René Höhn and Aniket Mishra and Pirro G. Hysi and Chiea Chuen Khor and Stephanie Loomis and Jessica N. Cooke Bailey and Jane Whitney Gibson and Guðmar Þorleifsson and Sarah F. Janssen and Xiaoyan Luo and Wishal D. Ramdas and Eranga N. Vithana and Monisha E. Nongpiur and Grant W. Montgomery and Liang Xu and Jenny Mountain and Puya Gharahkhani and Yi Lu and Najaf Amin and Lennart C. Karssen and Kar Seng Sim and Jin‐Moo Lee and Adriana I. Iglesias and Virginie J. M. Verhoeven and Michael A. Hauser and Seng‐Chee Loon and Dominiek D. G. Despriet and Abhishek Nag and Cristina Venturini and Paul G. Sanfilippo and Arne Schillert and Jae H. Kang and John Landers and Friðbert Jónasson and Angela J. Cree and Leonieke M. E. van Koolwijk and Fernando Rivadeneira and Emmanuelle Souzeau and Vésteinn Jónsson and Geeta Menon and Paul Mitchell and Jie Jin Wang and Elena Rochtchina and John Attia and Rodney J. Scott and Parker Magin and Tien Yin Wong and Paul N. Baird and Jing Xie and Michael Inouye and Ananth C. Viswanathan and Xueling Sim and Robert N. Weinreb and Paulus T.V.M. de Jong and Ben A. Oostra and André G. Uitterlinden and Albert Hofman and Sarah Ennis and Unnur Þorsteinsdóttir and Kathryn P. Burdon and R. Rand Allingham and Murray H. Brilliant and Donald L. Budenz and Jessica N. Cooke Bailey and William G. Christen and John H. Fingert and David S. Friedman and Douglas Gaasterland and Terry Gaasterland and Jonathan L. Haines and Michael A. Hauser and Jae H. Kang and Peter Kraft and Richard K. Lee and Paul R. Lichter and Yutao Liu and Stephanie Loomis and Sayoko E. Moroi and Louis R. Pasquale and Margaret A. Pericak‐Vance and Anthony Realini and Julia E. Richards and Joel S. Schuman and William K. Scott and Kuldev Singh and Arthur J. Sit and Douglas Vollrath and Robert N. Weinreb and Janey L. Wiggs and Gadi Wollstein and Donald J. Zack and Kang Zhang and Peter Donnelly and Inês Barroso and Jenefer M. Blackwell and Elvira Bramon and Matthew A. Brown and Juan P. Casas and Aiden Corvin},
  title = {{Meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies identifies novel loci that influence cupping and the glaucomatous process}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms5883},
}
Figure