Message from the ISMAR 2019 Science and Technology Poster Chairs

Yanwen Guo, Xueying Qin, Andrés Navarro, Stephanie Maxwell2019 · DOI

This document is not a traditional research paper but rather the introductory "Message from the ISMAR 2019 Poster Chairs." It provides an overview of the poster track for the 2019 IEEE International Symposium on Mixed and Augmented Reality (ISMAR), detailing the selection process, the philosophy behind the session, and the final statistics for the conference held in Beijing.

TL;DR

The ISMAR 2019 poster track served as a vital incubator for early-stage Mixed and Augmented Reality (MR/AR) research, featuring 106 posters selected to spark community discussion. By utilizing an inclusive review process and an extended 6-page format, the chairs aimed to showcase everything from core algorithms to novel applications while providing a platform for emerging researchers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In high-stakes academic conferences, the "full paper" track often has a high barrier to entry, which can exclude promising but preliminary work, novel concepts, or niche applications. The Poster Chairs addressed the challenge of creating a rigorous yet welcoming venue for these "early-stage" ideas.

The goal was to ensure that the MR/AR community had a dedicated space to discuss the benefits and challenges of the field in a way that "matures novel ideas into scientific and technological contributions." Additionally, the chairs managed the logistical challenge of integrating papers that were originally submitted to the Science and Technology (S&T) track but were better suited for the interactive poster format.

Methods

The "methodology" described here pertains to the editorial and peer-review workflow:

  • Submission Timing: For the third year, posters were submitted after the main paper decisions were issued. This allowed authors of rejected S&T papers to pivot to the poster track.
  • Extended Format: The chairs maintained a 6-page limit for poster papers. This is longer than many other conferences and was intentionally designed to allow authors to include clear images and technical details (implementation, experimentation) that are often cut for space.
  • Review Process: Each submission was coordinated by one of the four poster chairs and reviewed by at least two external reviewers from the ISMAR community.
  • Selection Criteria: Reviews were based on whether the work had sufficient contribution to merit acceptance as a stand-alone piece, a work-in-progress, or a novel concept that would yield "forward-leading discussions."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper (as this is a conference preface, not a technical study).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inclusivity over Exclusivity: The chairs explicitly stated they did not consider a "maximum number of acceptances." Instead, they aimed to accept any "reasonably good poster" to take advantage of the ample exhibition space and support young researchers.
  • Posters as a "Fix-point": The chairs view the poster session not as a secondary tier, but as a "fix-point" of the conference—a stable venue for the community to engage in the most current, raw discussions about the field's trajectory.
  • The 6-Page Advantage: By allowing longer poster papers, the conference encourages "advanced contributions" that can receive early feedback before being polished into full journal or conference papers.

Key Results

The document provides the final "vital signs" of the ISMAR 2019 poster track:

  • Direct Submissions: 86 poster-paper submissions.
  • Acceptance Rate: 72 posters were accepted from direct submissions, resulting in an 83% acceptance rate.
  • S&T Transfers: 22 papers originally submitted to the Science and Technology track were added as posters.
  • Oral-to-Poster Requests: 12 papers accepted as orals were also presented as posters at the authors' request.
  • Total Program: A final total of 106 poster papers were presented at the conference.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Review Timeline: The chairs noted that the reviewers had to perform "intense and mindful work in a very short time frame," suggesting a perennial challenge in conference scheduling.
  • Future Directions: While not a research roadmap, the chairs emphasized that the wide range of topics—from basic theory to core algorithms—is expected to "spawn novel ideas" and lead to new fields of application for MR/AR in the coming years.

Summary updated

Abstract

Presents the introductory welcome message from the conference proceedings. May include the conference officers' congratulations to all involved with the conference event and publication of the proceedings record.
BibTeX
@misc{guo2019message,
  author = {Yanwen Guo and Xueying Qin and Andrés Navarro and Stephanie Maxwell},
  title = {{Message from the ISMAR 2019 Science and Technology Poster Chairs}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/ismar-adjunct.2019.00008},
}
Figure