Membrane binding of a cyanobacterial <scp>ESCRT</scp> ‐ <scp>III</scp> protein crucially involves the helix α 1‐3 hairpin conserved in all superfamily members

Lukas Schlösser, Mirka Kutzner, Nadja Hellmann, Dale O. Kiesewetter, J. W. Bieber, Ndjali Quarta, Xingwu Ge, Tom A. Goetze, Benedikt Junglas, Fumiki Matsumura, Mischa Bonn, Frauke Gräter, Carsten Sachse, Lu‐Ning Liu, Carla Schmidt, Camilo Aponte‐Santamaría, Dirk SchneiderProtein 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the cyanobacterial ESCRT-III protein IM30 binds to negatively charged membranes primarily through its conserved α1-α3 helical hairpin, a mechanism shared with eukaryotic ESCRT-III proteins. This finding highlights a conserved evolutionary link in membrane remodeling across diverse life forms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining the integrity and biogenesis of internal membrane systems, like thylakoid membranes in chloroplasts and cyanobacteria, is crucial for cellular function. The ESCRT-III protein family, previously thought to be exclusive to eukaryotes and archaea, plays a key role in membrane remodeling. IM30, a cyanobacterial homolog, is essential for thylakoid membrane maintenance. However, the precise molecular mechanisms by which IM30 interacts with and remodels membranes, especially its initial binding event, remained unclear. This paper aims to elucidate these mechanisms, particularly the role of specific protein regions and their conserved nature across the ESCRT-III superfamily.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Protein Variants and Purification: They generated and purified various IM30 variants, including truncated versions (e.g., IM30* lacking oligomerization propensity, IM30 α0-3, IM30 α1-3, IM30 α4-6, IM30 α1-6) to dissect the roles of different structural domains.
  • Spectroscopic Techniques:
    • Intrinsic Tryptophan (Trp) Fluorescence Spectroscopy: Used to monitor changes in IM30's environment upon binding to liposomes, indicating membrane association.
  • Circular Dichroism (CD) Spectroscopy: Employed to assess changes in the secondary structure of IM30 upon membrane binding and during thermal denaturation.
  • Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) Spectroscopy: Used to probe secondary structure changes in IM30 upon membrane binding.
  • Liposome Binding Assays:
    • Laurdan Fluorescence Spectroscopy: Utilized to probe changes in lipid bilayer microenvironment upon protein binding, providing insights into binding affinity and membrane structural alterations.
  • Biophysical Techniques:
    • Size Exclusion Chromatography (SEC): To determine the oligomeric state of IM30 variants in solution.
  • Light Scattering: To monitor the disassembly of IM30 oligomeric structures.
  • BS³ Crosslinking: To investigate protein-protein interactions and structural rearrangements in membrane-bound states.
  • Native Mass Spectrometry: To determine the mass of non-covalently assembled protein complexes.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: Microsecond-scale all-atom simulations of the IM30 α1-3 fragment with lipid bilayers were performed to investigate binding kinetics, affinity, and residue-level interactions.
  • In Vivo Localization Studies: Fluorescently tagged IM30 variants were expressed in living cyanobacteria (Synechocystis) and visualized using super-resolution microscopy to confirm membrane binding and localization in a cellular context.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The α1-α3 Hairpin is the Primary Membrane Anchor: The study strongly suggests that the conserved α1-α3 helical hairpin is the key player in IM30's initial binding to negatively charged membranes, driven by electrostatic interactions. This is a significant finding as it points to a conserved binding motif across the ESCRT-III family.
  • Oligomerization is Not Required for Initial Binding: Contrary to what might be expected for proteins that form large assemblies, IM30 can bind to membranes even when its ability to form stable barrels is impaired (IM30* variant). This implies that monomeric or small oligomeric forms can initiate membrane interaction.
  • Membrane Binding Induces Structural Rearrangements: IM30 undergoes significant conformational changes upon binding to membranes, affecting its secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure. These changes are influenced by the protein's initial oligomeric state and its surface density on the membrane.
  • Helix α0 Plays a Supporting Role: While the α1-α3 hairpin initiates binding, helix α0 appears to enhance membrane binding and is crucial for stabilizing internalized membrane tubules within assembled structures.
  • Evolutionary Conservation of Membrane Remodeling: The findings underscore a conserved mechanism of membrane binding and remodeling across prokaryotic (IM30/PspA) and eukaryotic ESCRT-III proteins, suggesting a shared evolutionary origin for these fundamental cellular processes.

Key Results

  • IM30 binding to liposomes requires a minimum of 40% negatively charged lipids (PG) to be detected via fluorescence spectroscopy.
  • The IM30 α1-3 helical hairpin fragment binds to membranes with high affinity, comparable to or even higher than full-length IM30* (monomeric variant).
  • MD simulations revealed that the α1-3 hairpin's binding kinetics and affinity are PG concentration-dependent, with specific residues in α1 and α2/3 mediating interaction.
  • In vivo studies in Synechocystis showed that IM30 variants containing the α1-3 hairpin localized to the cytoplasmic membrane, confirming its role in membrane association.
  • The study demonstrated that while IM30 wt forms barrel structures in solution, IM30* exists as monomers or small oligomers, and these different states exhibit distinct membrane binding behaviors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo Complexity: While in vitro studies provide mechanistic insights, the in vivo environment is more complex. The authors acknowledge that the observed in vivo localization of IM30 wt was primarily cytoplasmic with some puncta, suggesting that its membrane-bound fraction might be less abundant or harder to detect than expected, possibly due to its oligomeric state shielding interaction regions.
  • Role of Membrane Curvature: The paper touches upon the role of membrane curvature in IM30 binding but suggests that negatively charged surfaces are the primary drivers. Further investigation into the interplay between curvature and charge could be beneficial.
  • Detailed Mechanism of Tubule Stabilization: While α0 is implicated in stabilizing internalized tubules, the precise molecular details of this interaction and how it leads to tubule formation could be further explored.
  • Functional Consequences of Remodeling: The paper focuses on the binding and structural aspects of membrane remodeling. Future work could delve deeper into how these remodeling events directly impact thylakoid biogenesis and function.
  • Broader ESCRT-III Family: While the study highlights conserved mechanisms, further comparative studies across a wider range of ESCRT-III proteins from different organisms could solidify the evolutionary link.

Summary updated

Abstract

IM30, the inner membrane-associated protein of 30 kDa (also known as Vipp1) is essential for thylakoid membrane biogenesis and/or maintenance in chloroplasts and cyanobacteria. IM30 and its bacterial homolog PspA belong to the ESCRT-III superfamily, proteins previously thought to be restricted to eukaryotes and archaea. Despite low sequence similarity, IM30 shares key structural and functional features with eukaryotic ESCRT-IIIs, including a conserved α1-α2 helical hairpin core and the ability to form oligomeric barrel or rod assemblies that mediate membrane remodeling. Using IM30 variants, we now show that membrane binding of IM30 is driven by electrostatic interactions between the positively charged α1-α3 helical hairpin and negatively charged lipid surfaces, paralleling the role of charged helical regions in some eukaryotic ESCRT-IIIs. This likely is followed by lateral assembly of IM30 into higher-order barrel or rod structures on the membrane. Once assembled, α0 helices within these oligomers engage and stabilize internalized membrane tubules, mirroring membrane interaction strategies of eukaryotic ESCRT-IIIs, which use both N-terminal sequence motifs and charged residues on α1/α2. Thus, our findings demonstrate a conserved membrane binding and remodeling mechanism across the ESCRT-III superfamily, underscoring an evolutionary link in membrane dynamics between pro- and eukaryotes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schlosser2025membrane,
  author = {Lukas Schlösser and Mirka Kutzner and Nadja Hellmann and Dale O. Kiesewetter and J. W. Bieber and Ndjali Quarta and Xingwu Ge and Tom A. Goetze and Benedikt Junglas and Fumiki Matsumura and Mischa Bonn and Frauke Gräter and Carsten Sachse and Lu‐Ning Liu and Carla Schmidt and Camilo Aponte‐Santamaría and Dirk Schneider},
  title = {{Membrane binding of a cyanobacterial <scp>ESCRT</scp> ‐ <scp>III</scp> protein crucially involves the helix <i>α</i> 1‐3 hairpin conserved in all superfamily members}},
  booktitle = {Protein},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1002/pro.70387},
}
Figure