Media and “the Fine Meshes of the Web of Power”: Based on the Statistics of Crime Rate in Virginia in 2022 Compared to Last Year and Before

Ziqian XieJournal of Education Humanities and Social Sciences 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Virginia abolished the death penalty in 2021 and welcomed a new governor in 2022. Meanwhile, widespread media reports suggested that the crime rate increased in 2022 compared to previous years. The new Republican governor claimed his Democratic predecessor made Virginia dangerous. This article investigates whether this is a factual representation or a constructed narrative for partisan purposes. By analyzing news topics from the last 18 months using Python and Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA), and applying Foucault’s theories on power and subjectivation, this paper concludes that the "dangerous Virginia" label is a narrative constructed by politicians to operate power. People cannot avoid being involved in the media, which has great effects on them in modern times; the narrative surrounding the Virginia crime rate is a prime example of media acting as a process of "subjectivation," trapping individuals in "the fine meshes of the web of power."

Introduction: The Disconnect Between Data and Perception

Following significant political shifts in Virginia—including the 2021 abolition of the death penalty and the 2022 inauguration of Governor Glenn Youngkin—a surge in media reports regarding a "rising crime rate" emerged. This study addresses the disconnect between statistical reality and public perception. The core challenge lies in understanding how media acts as a "filter" or a "fine mesh" that traps citizens within specific power structures, often utilizing simplified, fear-driven narratives to achieve political goals.

Methodology: Topic Modeling and Theoretical Synthesis

The research employed a multi-disciplinary approach combining data science and political theory:

  1. Web Scraping: News titles related to "Virginia crime rate" were collected from Google News using Python, spanning March 2021 to July 2022.
  2. Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA): This Natural Language Processing model discovered abstract topics within the scraped text. A relevance metric ($\lambda$) of 0.6 was used to balance word frequency with topic-specific peculiarity.
  3. Theoretical Framework: Quantitative findings were interpreted through Michel Foucault’s theories on "subjectivation" and the "panopticon," alongside criminological concepts like "exclusion bias."
Intertopic Distance Map and relevant terms for Topic 1, the most dominant theme identified in the media analysis.

Key Insights: Constructing the Narrative

The analysis revealed a strategic conflation of homicide rates with overall violent crime. While Virginia's murder rate had increased over the last decade, the overall violent crime rate in 2021 was actually 16% lower than ten years prior. By focusing on homicides, politicians created a narrative of a state in crisis.

The LDA analysis identified five primary pillars of this media narrative, as summarized in the table below:

Summary of the five main topics identified through LDA topic modeling, including their interpretations and key relevant terms.

Results and Discussion

The study found that while there was a modest 2.5% increase in violent crime in 2021 compared to 2020, media coverage focused almost exclusively on peak homicide rates. The LDA results showed that "Government funding in policies" was the most influential topic, suggesting the media's primary role was framing crime as an administrative failure of the previous leadership.

Drawing on Foucault, this process represents "subjectivation," where individuals internalize the discourses presented by the media, becoming subjects of power. The media functions as the "fine meshes of the web of power," making it difficult for citizens to remain independent of these political techniques.

Conclusion

The "dangerous" label applied to Virginia is a constructed narrative used by politicians to operate power. While statistics show nuanced trends, the media's selective focus creates a simplified reality that serves specific policy goals, such as increased police funding or harsher penalties. Future work should explore how the public can move from passive consumption to critical engagement with these media-driven political tendencies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Virginia abolished the death penalty in 2021 and welcomed a new governor in 2022. Meanwhile, widespread media reports that the crime rate goes up in 2022 compared to last year and before. The new Republican governor seriously claimed his Democrat predecessor to have made Virginia dangerous till today. In this article, whether it is a fact or a partisan battle that constructs a narrative will be investigated. Also, the five main topics of the news in the last year and a half will be summarized through the adoption of tools like Python and LDA (Latent Dirichlet Allocation). The review of the theories that explained the effects of media, especially on political policies, and Foucault’s theories on human subjection and involvement in political life, explained the significance of the research. This paper concludes that “Virginia is becoming more dangerous” tends to be a narrative constructed through media by politicians to operate power. People cannot avoid being involved in the media, which has great effects on them in modern times. The narrative surrounding the Virginia crime rate is an example of it. Media runs through the process of “subjectivation” but can only make people be trapped in “the fine meshes of the web of power”.
BibTeX
@article{xie2022media,
  author = {Ziqian Xie},
  title = {{Media and “the Fine Meshes of the Web of Power”: Based on the Statistics of Crime Rate in Virginia in 2022 Compared to Last Year and Before}},
  journal = {Journal of Education Humanities and Social Sciences},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.54097/ehss.v6i.4043},
}
Figure