Mechanistic Insight into the Photocatalytic Working of Fluorinated Anatase {001} Nanosheets

Monika Kus, Thomas Altantzis, Stephan Vercauteren, Ignacio Caretti, O. Leenaerts, Kees Joost Batenburg, Myrjam Mertens, Vera Meynen, B. Partoens, Sabine Van Doorslaer, Sara Bals, Pegie CoolThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Anatase nanosheets with exposed {001} facets have gained increasing interest for photocatalytic applications. To fully understand the structure-to-activity relation, combined experimental and computational methods have been exploited. Anatase nanosheets were prepared under hydrothermal conditions in the presence of fluorine ions. High resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy was used to fully characterize the synthesized material, confirming the TiO2 nanosheet morphology. Moreover, the surface structure and composition of a single nanosheet could be determined by annular bright-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (ABF-STEM) and STEM electron energy loss spectroscopy (STEM-EELS). The photocatalytic activity was tested for the decomposition of organic dyes rhodamine 6G and methyl orange and compared to a reference TiO2 anatase sample. The anatase nanosheets with exposed {001} facets revealed a significantly lower photocatalytic activity compared to the reference. In order to understand the mechanism for the catalytic performance, and to investigate the role of the presence of F–, light-induced electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) experiments were performed. The EPR results are in agreement with TEM, proving the presence of Ti3+ species close to the surface of the sample and allowing the analysis of the photoinduced formation of paramagnetic species. Further, ab initio calculations of the anisotropic effective mass of electrons and electron holes in anatase show a very high effective mass of electrons in the [001] direction, having a negative impact on the mobility of electrons toward the {001} surface and thus the photocatalysis. Finally, motivated by the experimental results that indicate the presence of fluorine atoms at the surface, we performed ab initio calculations to determine the position of the band edges in anatase slabs with different terminations of the {001} surface. The presence of fluorine atoms near the surface is shown to strongly shift down the band edges, which indicates another reason why it can be expected that the prepared samples with a large amount of {001} surface, but with fluorine atoms near the surface, show only a low photocatalytic activity.

Introduction

In the field of photocatalysis, titanium dioxide ($TiO_2$) is a cornerstone material for the degradation of organic pollutants. Among its polymorphs, anatase is particularly valued. Theoretical predictions have long suggested that the {001} facet of anatase is more reactive than the thermodynamically stable {101} facet. Consequently, significant research effort has been directed toward synthesizing anatase nanosheets dominated by these "high-energy" surfaces. However, experimental results have been inconsistent, with some studies reporting enhanced activity and others finding these nanosheets to be inferior to standard anatase. This study provides a comprehensive mechanistic investigation into why fluorinated {001} nanosheets often fail to meet theoretical expectations.

Experimental and Computational Methodology

The researchers synthesized anatase nanosheets (ANS) under hydrothermal conditions using fluorine ions as a stabilizing agent for the {001} facets. A multi-pronged approach was used for characterization:

  • Atomic-Scale Imaging: High-Angle Annular Dark-Field (HAADF) and Annular Bright-Field (ABF) Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) were employed to visualize the atomic arrangement, including light elements like oxygen and fluorine.
  • Electron Tomography: Using the DART algorithm, the team performed 3D reconstructions to accurately determine nanosheet thickness (4–10 nm).
  • Spectroscopy: Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) tracked the behavior of photoinduced charge carriers and the presence of $Ti^{3+}$ species.
  • Theory: Ab initio Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations (LDA+U) were performed to model the electronic properties, specifically focusing on carrier effective mass and band edge positions.

The Mobility Bottleneck: Effective Mass Anisotropy

A critical finding of this work is the extreme anisotropy in electron mobility within the anatase lattice. DFT calculations revealed that the "effective mass" of an electron—a parameter inversely proportional to its mobility—is significantly higher in the [001] direction (3.66) compared to the [100] direction (0.41). This nearly tenfold difference implies that electrons generated in the bulk of the nanosheet struggle to reach the {001} surface. Since photocatalytic reactions occur at the surface, this transport bottleneck inherently limits the efficiency of the {001} facets, regardless of their theoretical surface reactivity.

Surface Chemistry and Electronic Shifts

The study also highlights the detrimental role of the fluorine atoms required for synthesis. ABF-STEM and EELS data indicated that the surface layer is terminated by oxygen and fluorine, creating a "dead zone" where $Ti^{3+}$ reactive centers are absent from the immediate surface.

Furthermore, DFT modeling of the fluorinated surface showed a dramatic downward shift of the electronic band edges by up to 2.2 eV. This shift is caused by the surface dipole created by the highly electronegative fluorine atoms. Such a substantial change in the band structure alters the thermodynamic potential available for redox reactions, effectively reducing the "driving force" for the degradation of organic pollutants.

Photocatalytic Performance

The experimental performance of the ANS samples was compared against a commercial reference anatase. Despite the nanosheets having a significantly higher surface area (62 $m^2/g$ vs. 12 $m^2/g$), they were consistently less effective:

  • Rhodamine 6G Degradation: The reference sample achieved 99.1% degradation within 180 minutes, while the ANS sample reached only 43.2%.
  • Mineralization: Total Organic Carbon (TOC) analysis showed that the reference sample achieved 25% mineralization, whereas the ANS sample achieved a mere 6.4%.

Conclusion

This research clarifies the "structure-to-activity" relationship for fluorinated anatase {001} nanosheets. The perceived benefits of the high-energy {001} facet are undermined by two primary factors: the high effective mass of electrons moving toward the {001} surface and the electronic band-edge suppression caused by surface fluorine. These findings suggest that future efforts should focus on non-fluorinated stabilization methods or post-synthetic treatments to remove fluorine and "unlock" the potential of these specific crystal facets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Anatase nanosheets with exposed {001} facets have gained increasing interest for photocatalytic applications. To fully understand the structure-to-activity relation, combined experimental and computational methods have been exploited. Anatase nanosheets were prepared under hydrothermal conditions in the presence of fluorine ions. High resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy was used to fully characterize the synthesized material, confirming the TiO2 nanosheet morphology. Moreover, the surface structure and composition of a single nanosheet could be determined by annular bright-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (ABF-STEM) and STEM electron energy loss spectroscopy (STEM-EELS). The photocatalytic activity was tested for the decomposition of organic dyes rhodamine 6G and methyl orange and compared to a reference TiO2 anatase sample. The anatase nanosheets with exposed {001} facets revealed a significantly lower photocatalytic activity compared to the reference. In order to understand the mechanism for the catalytic performance, and to investigate the role of the presence of F–, light-induced electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) experiments were performed. The EPR results are in agreement with TEM, proving the presence of Ti3+ species close to the surface of the sample and allowing the analysis of the photoinduced formation of paramagnetic species. Further, ab initio calculations of the anisotropic effective mass of electrons and electron holes in anatase show a very high effective mass of electrons in the [001] direction, having a negative impact on the mobility of electrons toward the {001} surface and thus the photocatalysis. Finally, motivated by the experimental results that indicate the presence of fluorine atoms at the surface, we performed ab initio calculations to determine the position of the band edges in anatase slabs with different terminations of the {001} surface. The presence of fluorine atoms near the surface is shown to strongly shift down the band edges, which indicates another reason why it can be expected that the prepared samples with a large amount of {001} surface, but with fluorine atoms near the surface, show only a low photocatalytic activity.
BibTeX
@article{kus2017mechanistic,
  author = {Monika Kus and Thomas Altantzis and Stephan Vercauteren and Ignacio Caretti and O. Leenaerts and Kees Joost Batenburg and Myrjam Mertens and Vera Meynen and B. Partoens and Sabine Van Doorslaer and Sara Bals and Pegie Cool},
  title = {{Mechanistic Insight into the Photocatalytic Working of Fluorinated Anatase \{001\} Nanosheets}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.7b05586},
}
Figure