Mechanisms of Lactone Hydrolysis in Neutral and Alkaline Conditions

Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli, Emilio Calle, Julio CasadoThe Journal of Organic Chemistry 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses advanced computational chemistry to unravel the intricate mechanisms of lactone hydrolysis under neutral and alkaline conditions. By combining explicit water molecules with continuum solvation models, the study provides quantitative insights into reaction pathways, supporting existing hypotheses about water's catalytic role and uncovering novel mechanisms, particularly for diketene.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The hydrolysis of esters, including lactones, is a fundamental reaction in organic chemistry with broad implications, from laboratory synthesis to biological processes and even chemical carcinogenesis. While extensive experimental data exists, computational studies on lactone hydrolysis mechanisms, especially under neutral and alkaline conditions, have been scarce. Understanding these mechanisms is crucial because the specific pathway (e.g., acyl vs. alkyl cleavage) can dictate the biological activity and toxicity of these compounds. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a detailed computational investigation into the hydrolysis mechanisms of a diverse set of lactones and linear esters, comparing their reactivity and validating theoretical predictions against experimental data.

Methods

The researchers employed a hybrid supermolecule-continuum solvation approach. This involves explicitly modeling a small number of solvent molecules (up to six water molecules) that are in direct contact with the reacting species, while the bulk solvent is represented by a Polarizable Continuum Model (PCM). This combination aims to capture the specific, localized effects of solvation while efficiently accounting for the bulk solvent environment.

Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations, specifically the B3LYP functional with a 6-31++G(d,p) basis set, were used for geometry optimizations and frequency calculations. For key species, particularly transition states and minima, more rigorous ab initio methods like MP2, MP4, and QCISD were employed for single-point energy calculations to enhance accuracy.

To ensure the correct reaction pathways were identified, Intrinsic Reaction Coordinate (IRC) calculations were performed to connect transition states with their corresponding reactants and products. The study also meticulously calculated enthalpies (ΔH) and free energies (ΔG), including corrections for solvation effects to accurately represent the energetics in solution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on in silico modeling and comparison with existing experimental data rather than training on a specific dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water as a Catalyst: The study provides strong computational evidence supporting the long-standing hypothesis that water molecules act as crucial base catalysts in ester hydrolysis, stabilizing transition states and facilitating proton transfer.
  • Lactone Reactivity: β-lactones, due to their ring strain, are computationally predicted to be the most susceptible to neutral hydrolysis, with specific pathways like BAL2 and BAL1 being favored for certain structures.
  • Diketene's Unique Behavior: Diketene exhibits exceptionally stable tetrahedral intermediates in both neutral and alkaline hydrolysis, attributed to its sp² hybridized carbonyl carbon transitioning to sp³ hybridization.
  • Elimination-Addition Mechanism for Diketene: Novel evidence is presented for an elimination-addition mechanism in the alkaline hydrolysis of diketene, which is kinetically similar to the standard addition-elimination (BAC2) pathway but offers an alternative route.
  • BAL1 as Decarboxylation: The study reinforces the idea that BAL1 hydrolysis in lactones is more accurately described as a decarboxylation reaction rather than a simple hydrolysis, forming CO₂ and an alkene.
  • BAC2 Dominance: Under alkaline conditions, the BAC2 mechanism is overwhelmingly favored for all studied compounds, with acyl-oxygen cleavage being more prevalent than alkyl-oxygen cleavage, even for β-lactones.

Key Results

  • Agreement with Experiment: The calculated activation free energies and reaction pathways show good qualitative and quantitative agreement with available experimental data, validating the computational approach.
  • Neutral Hydrolysis Barriers: Larger lactones (γ and δ) and ethyl acetate exhibit very high energy barriers for neutral hydrolysis, consistent with their low reactivity. β-lactones, however, show significantly lower barriers for specific pathways.
  • Alkaline Hydrolysis Barriers: Table 4 shows that for alkaline hydrolysis, the BAC2 mechanism consistently has lower energy barriers than the BAL2 mechanism for all compounds studied.
  • Diketene's Anomalous Enthalpy: The calculated activation enthalpy for diketene's alkaline hydrolysis significantly deviates from experimental values, motivating the investigation into the elimination-addition pathway.
  • Kinetic Isotope Effects (KIE): The study's calculations for COOMe and DIK predict KIE values (kH/kD) of 4.7 and 4.0, respectively, which are in semiquantitative agreement with experimental observations for similar reactions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Solvation Model Limitations: While the hybrid supermolecule-PCM approach is advanced, the authors acknowledge that the accuracy of solvation entropies can be affected by the "loose" hydrogen bonding in the hydration shell, especially for bimolecular reactions. This might lead to an overestimation of entropic contributions in some cases.
  • Basis Set and Method Effects: While B3LYP/6-31++G(d,p) provided good results, using a larger basis set (6-311++G(2df,2dp)) did not significantly improve accuracy and even increased the error for some calculations. Post-HF methods, while more rigorous, led to strongly overestimated results.
  • Experimental Data Scarcity: For some compounds, experimental data for specific mechanisms or parameters were unavailable, limiting direct comparison.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further experimental studies could help clarify the contribution of the BAL2 pathway to the alkaline hydrolysis of β-propiolactone and confirm the proposed elimination-addition mechanism for diketene. The authors also note that a parallel work addresses the acid-catalyzed hydrolysis of lactones.

Summary updated

Abstract

The neutral and base-catalyzed hydrolysis of nine carboxylic acid esters was studied using a hybrid supermolecule-PCM approach including six explicit water molecules. The molecules studied included two linear esters, four β-lactones, two γ-lactones, and one δ-lactone: ethyl acetate and methyl formate, β-propiolactone, β-butyrolactone, β-isovalerolactone, diketene (4-methyleneoxetan-2-one), γ-butyrolactone, 2(5H)-furanone, and δ-valerolactone. DFT and ab initio methods were used to analyze the features of the various possible hydrolysis mechanisms. For all compounds, reasonable to very good qualitative and quantitative agreement with experimental work was found, and evidence is provided to support long-standing hypotheses regarding the role of solvent molecule as a base catalyst. In addition, novel evidence is presented for the existence of an elimination-addition mechanism in the basic hydrolysis of diketene. A parallel work addresses the acid-catalyzed hydrolysis of lactones.
BibTeX
@article{gomezbombarelli2013mechanisms,
  author = {Rafael Gómez‐Bombarelli and Emilio Calle and Julio Casado},
  title = {{Mechanisms of Lactone Hydrolysis in Neutral and Alkaline Conditions}},
  journal = {The Journal of Organic Chemistry},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1021/jo400258w},
}
Figure