Mechanism Study of Symmetric Mechanism-Rolling Bearing Dynamic System Considering the Influence of Temperature Factor

Chengshi Zhang, Tongtong Liu, Yanliang Wang, Hongliang He, Chao ZhangSymmetry 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper develops a more realistic dynamic model for rolling bearings by incorporating the effects of temperature on material properties like thermal expansion, hardness, and friction. This improved model leads to more accurate simulations of bearing behavior, especially for fault diagnosis, by accounting for how real-world temperature fluctuations impact bearing performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rolling bearings are ubiquitous in machinery, operating under diverse conditions, including high temperatures. Traditional dynamic models of rolling bearings often simplify or ignore the significant impact of temperature on the material properties of the bearing components. As temperature rises, key parameters such as the thermal expansion coefficient, hardness, and friction coefficient change. These changes, in turn, alter the bearing's stiffness and damping characteristics, leading to discrepancies between simulated and actual dynamic responses. This gap is critical because inaccurate dynamic models can hinder effective fault diagnosis and lead to suboptimal performance or premature failure of machinery. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a dynamic model that explicitly accounts for these temperature-dependent material property variations.

Methods

The researchers first analyzed how three key material properties of GCr15 bearing steel—thermal expansion coefficient, hardness value, and friction coefficient—change with temperature. They established functional relationships for these changes.

  1. Thermal Expansion Coefficient: They focused on the instantaneous linear expansion coefficient, noting its increase with temperature.
  2. Hardness Value: They observed a decrease in Rockwell hardness (HRC) with increasing temperature.
  3. Friction Coefficient: They utilized the average friction coefficient, which was found to increase with temperature.

These relationships were then integrated into a conventional dynamic model of a 6307 deep groove ball bearing. The modified model incorporates these temperature-dependent parameters to update the stiffness ($K_b$) and damping ($C_d$) of the bearing system. The study then simulated the dynamic response of the bearing under various temperatures, analyzing the resultant forces ($F_x$, $F_y$, $F$) and acceleration. Finally, they compared the simulated fault characteristic frequencies with experimental data to validate the model's effectiveness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on established material property data and simulations based on a 6307 deep groove ball bearing model. Experimental data for comparison was obtained from a self-built test bench.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temperature is a critical, often overlooked, factor: The study powerfully demonstrates that ignoring temperature's effect on material properties leads to significant deviations in bearing dynamic models.
  • Interplay of properties: The research highlights how thermal expansion, hardness, and friction coefficient interact and influence the bearing's stiffness and damping, ultimately affecting its dynamic response.
  • Friction's dominant role: While all three factors are considered, the friction coefficient emerges as having a more significant impact on the dynamic response when analyzed individually.
  • Improved fault diagnosis: By incorporating temperature effects, the simulated fault characteristic frequencies become much closer to experimental results, suggesting a substantial improvement in the accuracy and reliability of bearing fault diagnosis.
  • Real-world relevance: The findings emphasize that a temperature-aware model is crucial for understanding and predicting bearing behavior in actual operating conditions, leading to better engineering decisions.

Key Results

  • Thermal Expansion: The thermal expansion coefficient of GCr15 bearing steel increases with temperature.
  • Hardness: Hardness (HRC) decreases as temperature rises.
  • Friction: The average friction coefficient increases with temperature.
  • Dynamic Response:
    • Individually, increased thermal expansion and friction coefficient lead to a decrease in amplitude acceleration.
  • Decreased hardness leads to an increase in amplitude acceleration.
  • When all three factors are combined, the overall amplitude acceleration shows a downward trend with increasing temperature, which is more consistent with actual working conditions.
  • Fault Frequency Accuracy: The simulated fault characteristic frequency of the inner ring of the 6307 bearing, when considering temperature, is closer to the experimental signal frequency (e.g., 126.423 Hz vs. 127 Hz) compared to models that do not account for temperature.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on a specific bearing type (6307 deep groove ball bearing) and material (GCr15 bearing steel).
  • The paper mentions that the data used for analysis comes from a self-built test bench, but the data itself is not disclosed due to the need for further research.
  • While the paper discusses the impact of temperature, the exact methodology for obtaining the "functional relationship expressions" for each parameter is detailed, but the specific experimental verification of these relationships is not elaborated upon beyond referencing existing literature.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that this temperature-aware dynamic model can be applied to a broader range of bearing types and operating conditions.
  • The research has practical implications for improving system reliability, reducing maintenance costs, and enhancing safety in various industries, including high-speed mechanical systems, industrial production lines, and aerospace.
  • Further research could explore the combined effects of other environmental factors alongside temperature.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the symmetry of their structure and the way they rotate, rolling bearings are often used at high temperatures and high speeds. When the temperature changes, the material properties of the rolling bearing change, which in turn causes the dynamic model equation of the rolling bearing to change. Given the problem in that the conventional dynamic model equation does not consider temperature changes, but because temperature changes cause changes in material performance parameters resulting in differences between the dynamic simulation signals and the actual signals, this paper fully considers three factors, namely, the thermal expansion coefficient, the hardness value, and the friction coefficient. With the influence of temperature changes, a study on the mechanism of the symmetric mechanism-rolling bearing dynamic system considering the influence of temperature factors is proposed. First, combined with the material properties of the rolling bearing, the changes in thermal expansion coefficient, hardness value, and friction coefficient caused by temperature changes were analyzed. Second, the functional relationship expressions obtained above were substituted into the existing conventional dynamic model. Finally, the comprehensive functional relationship formula was substituted into the conventional dynamic model to obtain the rolling bearing dynamic model under temperature difference changes. By studying the mechanism of the symmetric mechanism-rolling bearing dynamic system that considers the influence of temperature factors, this method can undertake a more comprehensive consideration of the dynamic analysis research into rolling bearing fault diagnosis, thereby verifying the effectiveness of the method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023mechanism,
  author = {Chengshi Zhang and Tongtong Liu and Yanliang Wang and Hongliang He and Chao Zhang},
  title = {{Mechanism Study of Symmetric Mechanism-Rolling Bearing Dynamic System Considering the Influence of Temperature Factor}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=5WNUnMbXRo},
}
Figure